Papa Johns Pizza & Delivery alternatives
Papa Johns Pizza & Delivery users often seek alternatives due to persistent app issues, including problems with rewards, payment methods, and order customization. Many also express frustration with pricing and inconsistent promotions. Alternatives like Domino's, Pizza Hut, Jimmy John's, Panera Bread, and Taco Bell offer different experiences, from varied menu options to potentially more reliable app functionality.
Why users look for alternatives to Papa Johns Pizza & Delivery
- The app frequently has bugs that prevent users from applying rewards, gift cards, or promotions, leading to frustration and missed savings.R3R7R26R34
- Users experience technical difficulties with the app, such as login failures, password resets not working, and general slowness or crashes, making it difficult to place orders.R9R13R16R42
- The app has issues with payment processing, including credit card declines and problems with Apple Pay, sometimes charging and refunding multiple times.R10R24R50
- Customization options within the app can be buggy, such as being unable to remove toppings from vegetarian pizzas or save delivery instructions.R1R12R39
- Some users find the prices too high, especially after various fees, and note that certain menu items or crust types, like NY style, have been removed.R18R21
- Customers report issues with order accuracy, unexpected cancellations without notice, and problems with delivery service areas.R4R40
The alternatives
Domino's offers a wide range of pizza options and deals, with an app that users generally find easy to use for ordering . However, some report issues with the app signing them out, losing points, or being slow R53.
Better for: Domino's is better for users looking for competitive prices and deals on pizza, and who appreciate a generally straightforward ordering experience when the app functions correctly . It might suit those who want to track their order process .
Head-to-head: Papa Johns Pizza & Delivery vs Domino's Pizza USAPizza Hut provides a variety of pizza options and is praised by some for its amazing food . However, its app frequently suffers from critical login and payment issues, making it unusable for many customers R65R68.
Better for: Pizza Hut could be better for those who prioritize the taste of the pizza itself and are willing to order by phone if the app fails, especially if they are looking for gluten-free crust options .
Head-to-head: Papa Johns Pizza & Delivery vs Pizza HutJimmy John's is known for its fresh and fast sandwich delivery, often described as 'freaky fast' R80. The app is generally easy to use, and users appreciate deals like free sandwiches upon registration . However, some report issues with gift card redemption, point usage, and order tracking .
Better for: Jimmy John's is ideal for users seeking quick, fresh sandwich delivery rather than pizza, and who value speed and ease of use in an ordering app R80. It suits those who enjoy simple, classic sandwiches like the Pepe .
Head-to-head: Papa Johns Pizza & Delivery vs Jimmy John’s SandwichesPanera Bread offers a menu of soups, salads, and sandwiches, with an app praised for its ease of use and quick service R94. Users enjoy the Sip Club for drinks and appreciate the dependable, delicious food . Some find the food expensive and note issues with item availability and payment options R95.
Better for: Panera Bread is better for those looking for fresh, hot food beyond pizza, including breakfast options, and who appreciate an easy-to-use app for quick ordering and delivery . It suits users who might subscribe to their Sip Club for beverages .
Head-to-head: Papa Johns Pizza & Delivery vs Panera BreadTaco Bell offers a range of fast food items, with many users expressing strong loyalty and enjoyment of the food and deals . The app allows for customization and can be fun to use, but frequently experiences payment processing errors, login issues, and problems with rewards and location tracking R107R109R110.
Better for: Taco Bell is best for users who frequently crave Taco Bell's specific menu items and appreciate the potential for deals and bonuses through the app . It suits those who are comfortable with occasional app glitches for the sake of their favorite fast food R108.
Head-to-head: Papa Johns Pizza & Delivery vs Taco Bell Fast Food & DeliveryYou should stick with Papa Johns Pizza & Delivery if you consistently find their pizza taste superior, especially the stuffed crust, and experience reliable service and timely orders from your local store . It's also a good choice if you benefit from their $6.99 pairings deal and find the app easy to use for basic ordering without encountering the common bugs .
Evidence note: No alternative had too few reviews to judge.
Frequently asked
Why do Papa Johns users have trouble with rewards?
Are Papa Johns prices considered expensive?
Does the Papa Johns app have login problems?
What reviewers actually said
Built only from these 120 real reviews (foreign ones translated). Superscripts jump to the quote here. Apple has no per-review links, so [ref] opens that app's reviews on the App Store.
- [R3] Papa Johns Pizza & Delivery WHY CANT I EVER OPEN MY REWARDS: I have been ordering since September each time it tells me I have earned papa dough but it never loads always says " failure to load" customer service is useless FIX THE APP!!!!!
- [R7] Papa Johns Pizza & Delivery Papa dough: Your papa dough always reads error and I don’t know how many pizzas I bought from you, but I know I should have a good amount of rewards. Fix your app already
- [R26] Papa Johns Pizza & Delivery Promos: I have good promo coupons but the app isn’t letting me use them. Please look into your site and improve. Thanks!
- [R34] Papa Johns Pizza & Delivery Discounts Don’t Always Apply: Several times I have received good offers via email or text message. When l go to Papa Johns website; l get messages informing me promised discount is unavailable. And good luck contacting the Papa Johns location preparing your order! There- l receive, ‘You have to order online.’ I end up paying full price- no discount. Disappointing experience that sadly occurs often
- [R9] Papa Johns Pizza & Delivery Almost force to sign up: It almost forces you to sign up I have never signed up before in my life, but yet the email I use you say is already signed up, but yet you won’t let me login and you won’t send me a code.
- [R13] Papa Johns Pizza & Delivery Trash: Online I get a new phone and this pos won’t recognize me until I re-summit a new account and than says I already exist, I’m not running in circles for you or anyone else. Get it right
- [R16] Papa Johns Pizza & Delivery Got kicked off the app: I got kicked off the app several times while trying to place my order. made me hangry
- [R42] Papa Johns Pizza & Delivery App sucks: Tried to reset password. App refuses to reset. This app sucks and will be the last time ordering papa John’s
- [R10] Papa Johns Pizza & Delivery Payment method: You need to have an option to pay at the store that is not cash. Some people do not like putting their credit cards online.
- [R24] Papa Johns Pizza & Delivery Made it to hard to pay: They make is so hard to just pay.
- [R50] Papa Johns Pizza & Delivery Payment issues: Tried to order pizza and it kept saying my card was declined, charged me and refunded five times. Ended up having to use Apple Pay for it to work
- [R1] Papa Johns Pizza & Delivery Screwed up App: If you order a Vegetarian pizza, it wont let you remove the onions and the green peppers . It removes all the toppings and reverts back to a cheese pizza.
- [R12] Papa Johns Pizza & Delivery Delivery Instructions Bug: I would order pizza more often except the app doesn’t let me save the Delivery Instructions on my iPhone. I have to enter the gate code in the instructions but the app will not allow me to scroll down to the save button and the keyboard blocks the button. It’s been like this for a long time. I’m tired of cold pizza because of the delay in delivery because the driver can’
- [R39] Papa Johns Pizza & Delivery Stuffed Crust: Tried to order a stuffed crust with half sauce and half plain but the option doesn’t exist for sauce anymore. Only for toppings. Super gay.
- [R18] Papa Johns Pizza & Delivery NY style GONE!: I’m upset that I can no longer order NY style crust.
- [R21] Papa Johns Pizza & Delivery When did this get so expensive: $20 for a medium pepperoni and brownies(using papa deals $6.99 per and $3 papa cash) once they are done with all the random fees. Normally I’d get chicken and onion but they are charging an extra $2 for chicken. If this wasn’t a pregnancy craving I would have just gotten a pizza door dashed from a good pizza from a wood fire place for that price.
- [R4] Papa Johns Pizza & Delivery The app and this particular store are terrible.: I scheduled an order for delivery, got no call or email and my order was cancelled with no notice. Now I have 8 people who have been waiting hours for lunch and I had to place the order again after going through automated menus and waiting on hold. It’s an absolute nightmare.
- [R40] Papa Johns Pizza & Delivery Bad service: Unable to order delivery anymore cause the service they use keeps sending my orders all the way to mandeville instead of the picayune store. So I have to call in and order for delivery and I am unable to use my points if ordering on the phone. That’s so stupid and inconvenient!!
- [R51] Domino's Pizza USA It would be nice if I could use it.: The app signed me out then the password reset link wouldn’t work and now my account has been locked for a few days. The bot is worthless and customer support hasn’t gotten back to me. Hopefully they can fix it because when the app works it’s good but if you can’t use the app it’s worthless.
- [R53] Domino's Pizza USA Inconsistent: App keeps signing me out. Annoying. Lost my business today, no time for it.
- [R54] Domino's Pizza USA Wings: I had a pool game. I ordered pizza and wings. The wings were very tiny. They did not have enough sauce and like they drizzled the sauce on top. Worst experience ever at domino’s in Irvine
- [R55] Domino's Pizza USA Used to be Phenomenal: Hey Team Dominos, Could we get an option to reorder our last order? My wife and I have ordered the same thing for almost a decade, if we could auto reorder that exactly as is, that gives us a chance to also peruse and add a new thing to the cart here and there. The current way that you've implemented this requires someone to go all the way into the build a pizza menu and
- [R65] Pizza Hut Awful: I tried to sign in on app by receiving a code. They send the code at for example 5:49pm. I type it in at 5:50pm, it says invalid code. When placing an order on the website during checkout it says webpage error. Then it reloads. Please fix this problem if you want your customers to take advantage of your reward program.
- [R66] Pizza Hut Tips on Tax: App is fine, but auto tip includes tax in calculation, which annoys me.
- [R67] Pizza Hut Sad Face: Well updated the app. Not sure whose fault but lost all my points Pizza Hut prices went way up can’t hit contactless delivery and only 40 characters to explain to the driver where to go for delivery. #sadface
- [R68] Pizza Hut Unusable: I used to use this all the time but now it won’t let me select a payment method so I can’t order anything. I deleted and redownloaded the app. It still does it.
- [R79] Jimmy John’s Sandwiches App does not work: And advertises an $8.99 meal deal but then when I click it, it tries to charge me $14.87
- [R80] Jimmy John’s Sandwiches Loves it: Always fresh and fast!
- [R81] Jimmy John’s Sandwiches No update: I was waiting in the car for 15 min outside in the car for update of my pickup ready! No notification! When I go into the store, my pickup was already there!!
- [R82] Jimmy John’s Sandwiches Adds?: Wtf, why am I getting other business adds on an order app? Delete!
- [R93] Panera Bread Can't change currency: This app was working fine until it didn't. I went to Japan back in April and came back and ever since the app didn't update from yen to USD and I have no way to fix this. I deleted and reinstalled the app, logged in via website and the currency shows USD so I don't understand why it won't fix it when I've also enabled location services so it sees I'm in the United States. I
- [R94] Panera Bread Service: Quick service
- [R95] Panera Bread Payments feature: I don’t like that you cannot pay with more than one payment type. For instance, I had a gift card and I wanted to use it online, but it can only be used in the store if the order is more than the gift card balance.
- [R96] Panera Bread iPad app is PAINFULLY missing: An iPad version of this app is PAINFULLY missing. On a daily basis, our office passes around an iPad to place a large $250+ group order, but it’s never for Panera Bread since there’s no iPad app. What a shame, since Panera Bread is a popular/favorite on our floor, but it’s just too hard to place a 25+ person order on an iPhone-sized app when we need 10+ customizati
- [R107] Taco Bell Fast Food & Delivery The app is bugging: It wouldn’t give me my welcome reward and I’m new to the app never used it
- [R108] Taco Bell Fast Food & Delivery iOS interface overhaul: I love Taco Bell. I have unironically spent thousands of dollars on Taco Bell over the last 10 years. I have never had any sort of issue ordering and/or picking up my food. *THAT BEING SAID* I feel the layout of the iOS app needs to be changed because me and my girlfriend keep exiting out of our orders instead of adding them to the bag. I know this sounds silly but I promis
- [R109] Taco Bell Fast Food & Delivery Fix app location tracking: The app should prioritize and remind the user what location to drive to and suggest the closer location. Currently the location just keeps the last location used. I will change my review to 5 stars once this is fixed.
- [R110] Taco Bell Fast Food & Delivery Pay with App in Drive Thru: What the hell happened to being able to pay with my default CC in the app in the drive thru??? I have been a 3 different Taco Bell’s now in the past few months and they have no idea what I’m talking about/saying they don’t see it
- [R36] Papa Johns Pizza & Delivery Gift card issue: Every time I try to use a gift card on this app it never works. Even though I know the gift card has money on it. Very annoying they need to fix this problem.
Synthesized from 120 recent App Store reviews · updated July 2026 · View on the App Store