Verithiathe honest score on any app
Updated July 2026 · real, multi-region App Store reviews
Head-to-head

NYMCU Mobile Banking vs PenFed Mobile

NYMCU Mobile Banking 4.8★ · Free to download 70
Winner NYMCU Mobile Banking
PenFed Mobile 4.8★ · Free to download 55

NYMCU Mobile Banking offers a simpler, more convenient banking experience for everyday tasks, despite some reliability issues, while PenFed Mobile struggles with a clunky interface and inconsistent functionality, particularly for mobile check deposits and bill pay.

Full reviews: NYMCU Mobile Banking · PenFed Mobile

NYMCU Mobile Banking is generally praised for its ease of use and convenience for basic banking, though it faces criticism for frequent app issues and poor customer service. PenFed Mobile, while having loyal long-term customers, is often described as difficult to navigate, unreliable for key features like mobile deposits and bill pay, and having frustrating customer support.

Head to head

Features edge: NYMCU Mobile BankingR1R3R11R14
NYMCU Mobile Banking NYMCU users appreciate the ease of checking balances, transferring money, and depositing checks R3. However, there are requests for budgeting features R3, the ability to transfer funds to other MCU accounts or family members R11R14R24, and options to make principal-only loan payments . Zelle functionality is described as tedious or not working R1R11.
PenFed Mobile PenFed users can transfer to external accounts and manage all accounts . However, the bill pay system is often reported as not working, difficult to use, or missing accounts . Mobile check deposit is a significant pain point, with issues like auto-capture being too fast or not allowing retakes R66R70R73. Users also struggle to find basic functions like ordering checks or routing numbers .
Ease of Use edge: NYMCU Mobile BankingR2R3R4R9
NYMCU Mobile Banking Many NYMCU users find the app simple, easy to use, and convenient for everyday banking R2R3. However, a recurring frustration is the frequent need for verification codes, which can be slow to arrive and required for simple actions like checking balances R9. Some users also report the app is barely functional or difficult to use R4.
PenFed Mobile PenFed users describe the app as easy to use and navigate when it works . However, many find it difficult to locate needed information or basic functions . Logging in can be problematic, with issues like passkey not working, face ID being inconsistent, or the app not remembering login info . The mobile check deposit auto-capture feature is widely criticized for being too fast and not allowing retakes R70R73.
Reliability tieR10R13R15R16
NYMCU Mobile Banking NYMCU suffers from significant reliability issues. Users report the app crashing, not working, being slow, or constantly buffering R10R13R15R16. Frequent updates are seen as making things worse R13. Some users experience issues with logging in or accessing accounts due to these problems .
PenFed Mobile PenFed also has reliability problems, with users reporting the app freezing on the splash screen , bill pay not working , and login errors persisting for months . The mobile deposit feature is frequently cited as unreliable or inaccessible R95. Some users experience lag and 'too many attempts' errors when logging in .
Customer Support tieR6R7R9R12
NYMCU Mobile Banking NYMCU customer service is a major point of contention. Users describe reps as disrespectful, incompetent, or providing horrible service R6R7R12. There are complaints about extremely long wait times when trying to contact the bank R9. Fraud prevention is also criticized as terrible, with members waiting while fraudulent activity occurs R7.
PenFed Mobile PenFed customer service also receives negative feedback, with users reporting difficulty reaching a human, representatives not knowing how the system works, and long hold times . Some users are unable to get issues fixed, such as login problems or setting up autopay dates . However, some long-term members praise PenFed for excellent service, being understanding, and always ready to help .
Price/Value tieR5R8R26R31
NYMCU Mobile Banking NYMCU is praised for quick direct deposits, often received faster than other institutions R8R26. Users generally feel it's a good place to save money and provides good value R5R31. The app is free to download.
PenFed Mobile PenFed offers benefits like 5% cash back on fuel and a points system . Many long-term members express satisfaction with the credit union's services and support over decades . The app is free to download.
Pick NYMCU Mobile Banking if

Pick NYMCU Mobile Banking if you prioritize a generally simple and convenient app for basic banking tasks like checking balances and transferring money, and appreciate faster direct deposits R2R3R8.

Pick PenFed Mobile if

Pick PenFed Mobile if you are a long-term, loyal PenFed member who values the credit union's overall services and support, and can tolerate a less intuitive and sometimes unreliable mobile app experience .

Evidence note: Both apps have a significant number of negative recent reviews despite high lifetime ratings, indicating a decline in user satisfaction or persistent issues that are not being addressed. The free-to-download nature means all users, regardless of their banking relationship, are reviewing the app, which can skew negativity.

Frequently asked

Does NYMCU Mobile Banking offer budgeting features?
No, NYMCU Mobile Banking does not currently offer a built-in budgeting section, though users have requested this feature to automatically categorize spending R3.
Can I transfer funds to other members with NYMCU Mobile Banking?
Users report disappointment that they cannot easily transfer funds to other MCU accounts or to family members, including children's accounts R11R14R24.
Are there issues with mobile check deposit on PenFed Mobile?
Yes, many PenFed Mobile users report significant issues with mobile check deposit, including the auto-capture feature being too fast, not allowing retakes, or accounts being ineligible for the service R66R70R73R95.
How is customer service for NYMCU and PenFed?
Both NYMCU and PenFed receive significant criticism for their customer service, with reports of long wait times, unhelpful representatives, and difficulty resolving issues R6R7R9R12.

What reviewers actually said

Built only from these 120 real reviews (foreign ones translated). Superscripts jump to the quote here. Apple has no per-review links, so [ref] opens that app's reviews on the App Store.

  1. [R1] NYMCU Mobile Banking 2/5 · US Zelle: The Zelle process is tedious and requires some serious updating
  2. [R3] NYMCU Mobile Banking 3/5 · US MCU App Review: Convenient Banking with a Need for Budgeting Features: I’ve had a good experience using the MCU app overall. I like how easy it is to check my balances, transfer money between accounts, and deposit checks from my phone. The app is simple and convenient for everyday banking. One feature I’d love to see added is a built-in budgeting section. It would be helpful if the app automatica
  3. [R11] NYMCU Mobile Banking 4/5 · US Using Zelle/ transfer: My Zelle often does not work. Also my Sister and I live in two different states both with MCU accounts unable to transfer funds to each other.
  4. [R14] NYMCU Mobile Banking 4/5 · US Neil B: Would like to transfer funds to other MCU accounts
  5. [R2] NYMCU Mobile Banking 5/5 · US Simple to use: Simple to use
  6. [R4] NYMCU Mobile Banking 2/5 · US Barely Functional: If I had a choice I would never use this app! You can’t do anything of value with this.
  7. [R9] NYMCU Mobile Banking 3/5 · US Damn verification: Convenient but not when you have to keep waiting for a verification code that takes long at times and I’m waiting to make a transaction and I need a code every time I’m checking my balance. Also to contact the bank it’s always an extremely long wait
  8. [R10] NYMCU Mobile Banking 2/5 · US Don’t get: Take forever to download half the time it doesn’t work this app has a bunch of problems
  9. [R13] NYMCU Mobile Banking 1/5 · US Useless updates: Why constantly update when the updates make things worse. Stop fixing what’s not broken
  10. [R15] NYMCU Mobile Banking 3/5 · US Great app when it works: This app works flawlessly…. When it actually works. The system updates are an inconvenience. My app has not been working for a week now. Who needs that?
  11. [R16] NYMCU Mobile Banking 1/5 · US Horrible: Both MCU apps are no good at all . Don’t understand how a major credit union always has issues with their mobile apps. It sucks my card has been locked for days I have no access to my money or can’t unlock my card .
  12. [R6] NYMCU Mobile Banking 3/5 · US My opinion: You don’t help the core customers enough banking feels primitive I had a disrespectful conversation with one of your representatives when I was filing a home loan and was told that my 25+ years track record of on time payments was not enough didn’t even bother to open up my account and take a look I stand back and watch people who don’t even work for the city, obtain accounts and get l
  13. [R7] NYMCU Mobile Banking 1/5 · US Horrible Service: I am trying to Stop Fraudulent activity and they got me waiting to connect why do members have to wait while crooks take their money you should have an App to handle everything with Member privileges like Stop fraudulent transactions and alerts why do I continue with this nonsense
  14. [R12] NYMCU Mobile Banking 3/5 · US Customer Disservice: MCU has the worst & most incompetent customer reps.
  15. [R5] NYMCU Mobile Banking 5/5 · US I will say yes to it anytime: A good place to save ur money . They are true
  16. [R8] NYMCU Mobile Banking 5/5 · US CS second to none: NYMCU direct deposit received fast than any other financial institution
  17. [R26] NYMCU Mobile Banking 5/5 · US Direct deposit: What I like about Mcu is that we don’t have to wait till Friday to get paid. We automatically receive our paycheck on Wednesday instead of waiting Thursday or Friday like every other bank that makes the customers wait till Thursday or Friday to receive their paycheck.
  18. [R31] NYMCU Mobile Banking 5/5 · US NYMCU: The best Credit Union in the world. I want to continue the good relations with MCU at all times.
  19. [R24] NYMCU Mobile Banking 3/5 · US Transfers to other MCU members: I’m very disappointed that can not transfer funds to my children’s smart Apple accounts. This option would make it so much easier for parents to continue to save for their children’s future. Please make this an option on the banking app.
  20. [R66] PenFed Mobile 3/5 · US Scan Check issue: Scanning a check is not always successful. It scanned the front of the truck as both the front and the back. I don’t see a way to edit the back so I have to start again
  21. [R70] PenFed Mobile 2/5 · US UPDATE has made capturing checks worse: The auto capture tool for checks was working fine before. Before, You’d set the front of your check. Auto Capture it. Great. Then It’d take you back out of auto capture, you flip your check to its back , you click on back option . Auto capture. And done. Worked great! BUT Now, -it makes you do it “all at once” and too fast. If you are not fast enough turning
  22. [R73] PenFed Mobile 2/5 · US Mobile check deposit auto capture doesn’t allow retaking of photos: When using auto capture to photo checks, there is not apparent option to retake photos if necessary.
  23. [R95] PenFed Mobile 1/5 · US This is not a credit union it’s a joke: Mobile deposit doesn’t work despite having an account since 2017. I tried for the first time to use mobile deposits and I was told that my account is in eligible. I called Support multiple times and yet nobody can tell me why mobile deposit doesn’t work. This is a garbage credit union. This may as well be an online bank. It’s not a real bank. Once I finall

Synthesized from 120 recent App Store reviews · updated July 2026 · View on the App Store