Verithiathe honest score on any app
Updated July 2026 · real, multi-region App Store reviews
Head-to-head

Macy's vs Poshmark

Macy's 4.9★ · Free to download 75
Winner Macy's
Poshmark 4.8★ · Free + IAP 65

Choose Macy's for a more reliable shopping experience with fewer complaints about app functionality.

Full reviews: Macy's · Poshmark

Macy's app generally receives higher ratings for quality and customer service compared to Poshmark, which has faced criticism for its recent updates and customer support issues. While both apps have their strengths, Macy's offers a more stable shopping experience overall.

Head to head

features edge: Macy'sR2R3R24R62
Macy's Macy's users appreciate the quality of products and variety available, though some desire a more streamlined purchasing process R2R3R24.
Poshmark Poshmark users enjoy the ease of listing items but express frustration over aggressive upselling and recent changes that complicate the user experience R62R67.
ease of use edge: Macy'sR1R10R37R67
Macy's Macy's users report issues with app functionality, such as freezing and cluttered interfaces, but many find it generally user-friendly R1R10R37.
Poshmark Poshmark users frequently complain about confusing updates and a cluttered interface that detracts from the shopping experience R67.
reliability edge: Macy'sR4R31R41R61
Macy's Macy's users report significant issues with order processing and customer service, but many still trust the brand for quality R4R31R41.
Poshmark Poshmark users have raised serious concerns about customer service and the risk of scams, leading to dissatisfaction among sellers R61R82.
price/value edge: Macy'sR9R24R60R63
Macy's Macy's users feel they get good quality for their money, though some express concerns about rising prices R9R24R60.
Poshmark Poshmark users often feel that the fees associated with selling items reduce overall value, and some are frustrated by the cost of promoting listings R63.
support edge: Macy'sR31R41R61R82
Macy's Macy's users report mixed experiences with customer service, with some finding it helpful while others faced issues R31R41.
Poshmark Poshmark users consistently report poor customer service experiences and lack of support when issues arise R61R82.
Pick Macy's if

you prefer a more traditional shopping experience with a focus on quality and customer service.

Pick Poshmark if

you are looking to sell items and enjoy a community-driven marketplace, despite some recent frustrations.

Evidence note: Macy's has a higher lifetime rating and more positive reviews overall, while Poshmark's recent updates have led to significant dissatisfaction among users.

Frequently asked

Which app is better for shopping?
Macy's app is generally better for shopping due to its higher ratings and more positive user experiences regarding product quality and customer service, despite some functionality issues. Poshmark, while good for selling, has faced complaints about customer support and usability.

What reviewers actually said

Built only from these 120 real reviews (foreign ones translated). Superscripts jump to the quote here. Apple has no per-review links, so [ref] opens that app's reviews on the App Store.

  1. [R2] Macy's 5/5 · US Formal gowns: Macys is definitely the go to store for dresses. Excellent quality and great prices.
  2. [R3] Macy's 3/5 · US Make it easier to Buy items !: I’ve given feedback many times. I like that you can scroll photos of an item while in search list, and mostly the app works fine. But 2 requests I have made would make app shopping so much easier & benefits Macys are: 1) a ‘buy now’ button on shopping item page or 2) a way to check off less items in the cart that you want to purchase now without moving others to save
  3. [R24] Macy's 5/5 · US Great Deals: Macys has some of the best deals in a economy where everything is going up in price I can rely on Macy’s for quality Beds Clothing Kitchenwear Jewelry and more and always the best quality brands it is like shopping at a discount outlet online. I hope they stay in business and do not go away good department stores are rare and Macys is great.
  4. [R62] Poshmark 5/5 · US Most Easy Listing App!: Love this app! Not like others that will make you go low on prices, Poshmark makes it easier for seller to list and connect to their buyers!
  5. [R1] Macy's 1/5 · US Go back to the old easy way!: Go back to the old and quite all the CLUTTER with other ads that are not items at Macy’s store! Macy was the ONLY store I shopped. I did a lot over your app. NOT any more. It was easier to just open the app and see what’s on sale. Now I have to filter through DOOR DASH!??😖👎👎
  6. [R10] Macy's 1/5 · US Only fills half screen: The Macy’s app only displays half the screen on my iPad mini 5. I’m running iPadOS 26.5. I’ve restarted the iPad and reinstalled the app. Every other app works normally.
  7. [R37] Macy's 2/5 · US Freezes: I’m not sure what’s been going on with the app, but I can’t actually search for specifics items and use filters. The second I put in the filters, it just freezes and won’t show me the results. I keep hoping it will start working again, but the problem has persisted for over 6 months, despite constantly uninstalling and reinstalling the app. The end result, I’m just not buying anything from
  8. [R67] Poshmark 1/5 · US I hate every update: I hate every new update. I dislike that you can no longer see how many followers a person has. I dislike that you can no longer see how many likes you have at first glance. I dislike that you can't see how many a new alert you have. It used to show a number. No one seems to follow anyone anymore and no one seems to share anything anymore. The ease of use and the community fe
  9. [R4] Macy's 1/5 · US Jo Ann: This second time I’m having a horrible time trying to place an order Both times missed out on using my $10 rewards 1st time order cancelled no explanation. This time denied my credit card you didn’t have correct one. I added this time as default. My account seems to be a mess in the app
  10. [R31] Macy's 1/5 · US Customer service is not up to par.: I don’t recommend Macy’s to anyone. Delivery service sucks. Never get my items on time and to my right address. I hate it but I need it. That’s the only reason I shop with Macy’s.
  11. [R41] Macy's 1/5 · US Platinum Customer: Terrible customer support
  12. [R61] Poshmark 1/5 · US Scam app: Provides no support if you get scammed out of a purchase. I would stay clear
  13. [R9] Macy's 3/5 · US Elizabeth Arden day cream: The price has gone up way too much!! I intend to find a less expensive replacement.
  14. [R60] Macy's 5/5 · US Great service: Dresses prices are reasonable value for your money
  15. [R63] Poshmark 3/5 · US Poshmark: It’s not like EBay or marketplace at all. You pay a lot in my opinion to post something most of the time not worth it.
  16. [R82] Poshmark 1/5 · US Did me dirty: I made an account that my friend recommended to do and when I got my first sale I was happy and did all the steps it wanted me to do but then I got scammed OFF THE REAL APP AND EVERYTHING and lost over 450 bucks

Synthesized from 120 recent App Store reviews · updated July 2026 · View on the App Store