Verithiathe honest score on any app
Updated July 2026 · real, multi-region App Store reviews
Head-to-head

USAA DriveSafe vs State Farm®

USAA DriveSafe 4.5★ · Free to download 40
Winner State Farm®
State Farm® 4.8★ · Free to download 65

State Farm® is generally preferred for its broader functionality and more reliable core insurance services, despite some login and app freezing issues, while USAA DriveSafe struggles significantly with accurate driving data collection and user experience for its discount program.

Full reviews: USAA DriveSafe · State Farm®

State Farm® offers a more comprehensive and generally user-friendly app for managing insurance, even with occasional technical glitches. USAA DriveSafe, while aiming for discounts, is plagued by persistent inaccuracies in tracking, privacy concerns, and a frustrating user experience.

Head to head

Driving Data Accuracy & Fairness edge: State Farm®R1R2R3R5
USAA DriveSafe USAA DriveSafe users frequently report inaccurate tracking, such as being penalized for harsh braking when none occurred, or for phone use while parked or using hands-free features R2. A major complaint is the app's inability to distinguish between a driver and a passenger, leading to constant manual corrections R1R5R7R9. Some users also note that the score can fluctuate without clear reasons or events R3R31R55.
State Farm® State Farm® users also experience issues with their Drive Safe & Save feature, particularly with the app incorrectly identifying them as a driver when they are a passenger, and vice versa . Some manual transmission drivers find the app unfairly penalizes them for gradual acceleration . There are also reports of the app being a significant battery drain R120.
Privacy & Data Collection tieR1R4R7R9
USAA DriveSafe USAA DriveSafe requires location services to be 'Always On,' which users find invasive and a drain on battery life R4R7. The app tracks every location visited and struggles to differentiate between the driver's phone use and a passenger's, raising privacy concerns R1R9.
State Farm® State Farm®'s Drive Safe & Save feature also requires 'Always On' location services, which some users dislike due to privacy implications and battery drain R81R120.
App Reliability & Performance tieR12R15R27R29
USAA DriveSafe USAA DriveSafe users report issues with the app stalling when reviewing trips R15, not recording correct routes , and general unreliability R29. Some users struggle with login issues and the app not working properly after updates or due to phone settings R12R27.
State Farm® State Farm® users frequently encounter login problems, requiring constant password resets or being locked out of their accounts . The app is also reported to be slow, freeze often, or require reinstallation to function R61. Some users face issues with payment methods or policy information not displaying correctly .
Core Insurance Features & Support edge: State Farm®R7R39R55R61
USAA DriveSafe Reviews for USAA DriveSafe focus almost exclusively on the driving program itself, with little mention of broader insurance features or support within the app. Some users appreciate the discount, but the app's flaws often overshadow this benefit R7R39R55.
State Farm® State Farm®'s app is praised for being user-friendly for filing and tracking claims . Users appreciate the ease of accessing policy information and getting assistance . However, some report difficulties with customer support, including unresponsive agents or bots R61.
Pick USAA DriveSafe if

You are a USAA member who drives very little, is willing to manually edit every trip for accuracy, and prioritizes a potential discount over privacy and a smooth user experience R3R7R39.

Pick State Farm® if

You are a State Farm customer who values a comprehensive app for managing claims and policy details, and are willing to tolerate occasional login issues or app freezes .

Evidence note: Reviews for USAA DriveSafe are almost exclusively about the driving program, while State Farm® reviews cover both the driving program and broader insurance app functionality. This makes a direct comparison on all dimensions challenging, as USAA's core insurance app features are not detailed in the provided reviews.

Frequently asked

Which app is better for getting insurance discounts?
State Farm®'s Drive Safe & Save program is generally more reliable for discounts, as USAA DriveSafe is frequently criticized for inaccurate tracking that can unfairly penalize users and reduce their discounts R3R7R31R55.
Do these apps drain phone battery?
Yes, both USAA DriveSafe and State Farm®'s Drive Safe & Save features are reported by users to significantly drain phone battery because they require location services to be 'Always On' R4R7R81R120.
Can these apps tell if I'm a driver or passenger?
Both apps struggle with accurately identifying whether the user is the driver or a passenger, leading to frequent manual corrections by users (R1, R5, R7, R9, , , , R29, R39, for USAA; for State Farm).

What reviewers actually said

Built only from these 120 real reviews (foreign ones translated). Superscripts jump to the quote here. Apple has no per-review links, so [ref] opens that app's reviews on the App Store.

  1. [R1] USAA DriveSafe 1/5 · US Collects data from Uber and other non insured with USAA vehicles.: The app is absolutely ignorant as to what and when I drive. If I uber on a Mexico vacation it collects data. If I ride with someone else it collects data. If I drive a vehicle insured by State Farm it collects data. At least State Farm has a module in the vehicle that lets them know ONLY when I’m driving/riding in the vehicle
  2. [R2] USAA DriveSafe 4/5 · US Good enough: Does a decent job with limited false positives but tell me why I get dinged for “hands free calling” when I get a phone call but don’t even answer it?
  3. [R3] USAA DriveSafe 3/5 · US Driving: I’m old and don’t drive very far anymore and just noticed my discount just dropped from 6%to 5% and the score went from mid 70’s to 70. I just got home. No phone use or hard breaking. I don’t get it.
  4. [R5] USAA DriveSafe 4/5 · US Finally! Recognition of Great Driving! But the app makes many mistakes.: 60 years of driving with zero infractions. Glad that my driving habits finally get a cash reward. But this app continues to be unable to distinguish whether I am the driver or the passenger. My wife and I are almost always together in the car, sharing driving duties. But the app fails to identify who is driving and I have to
  5. [R4] USAA DriveSafe 2/5 · US Always on: This is the ONLY app on my phone that requires location services “Always On”. It refuses to work with “while using app” & keeping the app open in the background. Always On drains my battery & interrupts my privacy. USAA needs to fix their protocol requirements for this app or I’m going to have to drop out of their drive safe program.
  6. [R7] USAA DriveSafe 1/5 · US Discount is good but app does not track well: Have been using for over a year and you can get a good discount. But app cannot reliably recognize if you’re the driver or passenger. And if you’re driving a work vehicle you have to edit it manually for every single trip. And it can use up a lot of battery running in the background. I would much rather use the small Bluetooth devices that other insure
  7. [R9] USAA DriveSafe 3/5 · US Invasion of privacy?: The idea of the app is not bad. Unfortunately, it tracks every location precisely that you visit. There is no way for you to indicate that your passenger, or a child may have been using your phone while you were driving. This comes back in a review of your driving habits. My safe driving score is compromised because my passenger chose to put an address into our GPS whi
  8. [R12] USAA DriveSafe 3/5 · US Discount: I’ve had issues getting the app to work correctly. The location always & app update keep on not working properly. I’ve deleted & reloaded but it doesn’t change.
  9. [R15] USAA DriveSafe 3/5 · US Slow Service: It keeps stalling when trying to review trips.
  10. [R27] USAA DriveSafe 3/5 · US Not the first time.: I can’t use the app anymore. It has worked fine and recorded my trips up to this point, besides a similar event around a year ago. Today I find it logged me out of the app and once I logged back in, it asked me to turn on accessibility to a “Motion and Fitness” setting that my phone does not have. I’ve looked and searched for it in the past and still can’t find it to this day.
  11. [R29] USAA DriveSafe 4/5 · US Unreliable: The app consistently rates me as the driver when I am a passenger, and for example, on two occasions, my wife as the driver has tapped the brakes and pulled to the side of the road to give way to emergency vehicles, and the app has not only registered me as the driver, which I later corrected, but lowered our rating significantly because of "harsh breaking." Also, the app went off-line
  12. [R39] USAA DriveSafe 3/5 · US Can’t recognize when I am a passenger: While I enjoy the discount I receive, this app is a source of anxiety because it can never tell when I am a passenger, so I have to remember to go through my trips and painstakingly mark them, or I will be penalized. The harsh braking detection is absurdly oversensitive.
  13. [R55] USAA DriveSafe 1/5 · US Driver discount: The program is flawed. Going from a 30%discount to 26% to 1% with zero touches???? My phone stays I my purse. There is no way that I have access to it.
  14. [R61] State Farm® 1/5 · US Needs a lot of improvement: This app is absolutely slow and not functioning well especially the chat feature. You always have to restart the chat with new person and it gets logged out all of sudden and get disconnected in the middle of the conversation.
  15. [R31] USAA DriveSafe 1/5 · US Wrong policy discounts: I want to know why my percentage savings has suddenly gone from 97 or 98% to the low 80s when I’ve had no trip incidents.
  16. [R81] State Farm® 3/5 · US Data trackers love this app: The fact that you have to have location services always on means that this app is following your every movement not something that I like to sign up for if they would change this as well as the fact that it uses your phones, Geo and accelerometer makes it very difficult to get a perfect score. Matter fact I drive a van that has cargo and typically leave plenty of room
  17. [R120] State Farm® 1/5 · US Battery hog: App itself is okay but it’s a huge battery hog with drive safe and save. Averaging 27% per day.

Synthesized from 120 recent App Store reviews · updated July 2026 · View on the App Store