Verithiathe honest score on any app
Updated July 2026 · real, multi-region App Store reviews
Head-to-head

FamilyAlbum vs PhotoCircle

FamilyAlbum 4.9★ · Free + IAP 70
Winner FamilyAlbum
PhotoCircle 4.9★ · Free to download 55

FamilyAlbum is better for long-term family photo sharing with print options, despite recent privacy concerns and print delivery issues, while PhotoCircle is a simpler choice for event-based sharing, but is heavily impacted by ads.

Full reviews: FamilyAlbum · PhotoCircle

FamilyAlbum excels as a private photo and video sharing platform for families, offering print services, but faces recent backlash over AI integration and print delivery problems. PhotoCircle provides a straightforward way to share photos for events, but its user experience is significantly hampered by intrusive ads and limited video functionality.

Head to head

Features & Functionality edge: FamilyAlbumR5R6R7R8
FamilyAlbum FamilyAlbum is praised for its ability to share photos and videos privately with family and friends, acting as a great alternative to social media R5R23. Users appreciate the ability to see daily updates from grandkids and other family members R8. The app also offers print services, including monthly free prints R8. However, recent updates have moved previously free features, like "on this day" slideshows and high-quality video uploads, behind a paywall R6R7R15. Some users also report issues with video uploads failing or disappearing .
PhotoCircle PhotoCircle is valued for its ease of sharing photos and videos for group events, vacations, and family gatherings . It offers unlimited storage and works well for sharing between Apple and Android devices . Users appreciate the ability to create separate circles for different occasions . However, the app has limitations, such as a short video limit and the inability to reply to comments or add multiple photos into one image . Some users also wish for direct printing or album creation within the app .
Ease of Use & Reliability edge: FamilyAlbumR2R3R4R9
FamilyAlbum FamilyAlbum is generally considered easy to use for sharing photos and videos . However, users report significant issues with ordered prints not being received R2R3R4R10. There are also complaints about the app's performance on iPad, with users experiencing crashes, poor formatting, and inability to view full pictures or comments . Some users also mention bugs with notification settings and failed photo uploads R9.
PhotoCircle PhotoCircle is described as easy to use for sharing photos . However, a major recurring issue is the app's unreliability due to intrusive and often unskippable ads that force users to restart the app R61R64R70. Some users also report the app stopping working even with a premium account , and issues with notifications . The app also has compatibility issues with older iOS versions, preventing some users from accessing their photos R63R113.
Privacy & Security edge: FamilyAlbumR1R13R23R25
FamilyAlbum FamilyAlbum was initially valued for its privacy features, allowing users to share photos with a select group without social media R23. However, recent privacy policy updates have caused significant alarm, with many users expressing outrage over the app's integration with AI company Anthropic for "enhanced search" R1R25R28R31. Users feel betrayed, especially concerning children's photos, and note that deleting data requires a premium account . There are also concerns about relatives being able to order prints of photos without explicit approval R13.
PhotoCircle PhotoCircle is generally seen as a private way to share photos within a group, especially for those avoiding social media . However, some users have reported malicious ads that attempt to trick them into thinking their phone has a virus , which raises security concerns. The app also includes binding arbitration in its terms, which some users find problematic . There are also reports of users being banned for no clear reason .
Price & Value edge: FamilyAlbumR6R7R15R19
FamilyAlbum FamilyAlbum offers a free version with in-app purchases and a premium subscription. While the free version allows sharing, many features, including high-quality video uploads and "on this day" recaps, are now paywalled R6R7R15. Users are frustrated by constant pop-ups and ads for paid versions and products, even for premium subscribers R6R19. The "free" monthly prints are often criticized for having shipping costs that make them more expensive than local printing options .
PhotoCircle PhotoCircle is free to download but heavily relies on ads, which are a major source of frustration for users R61R64R70. While there is a premium option to remove ads, some users note that this only applies to their own account, and other viewers still see ads . Some users also report being asked for payment info before downloading . The value is questioned by users who find it less functional than free alternatives like Google Photos R103.
Customer Support tieR4R10R42R49
FamilyAlbum FamilyAlbum users report poor customer service, particularly regarding issues with ordered prints. Multiple users mention being charged for prints but never receiving them, with no response from customer support for inquiries or refund requests R4R10R42R49. This lack of response leaves users feeling uncomfortable and concerned about the whereabouts of their personal photos R4.
PhotoCircle PhotoCircle users also report issues with customer support. One user stated they tried multiple times to get support for an app that stopped working, even with a premium account, but received no response . Another user mentioned being banned for no reason and requested an email to get their old account back, implying a lack of direct support .
Pick FamilyAlbum if

you want a dedicated, private space for long-term family photo and video sharing, are willing to pay for premium features, and understand the recent privacy policy changes regarding AI R5R8R23.

Pick PhotoCircle if

you need a simple, free way to share photos and short videos for specific events or temporary groups, and are prepared to tolerate frequent and sometimes inappropriate ads .

Evidence note: Recent negative reviews for FamilyAlbum heavily focus on the AI privacy issue, which skews the perception of its overall functionality and long-standing positive aspects. PhotoCircle's free-to-download model means many negative reviews stem from ad-related friction, which is a common trade-off for free apps.

Frequently asked

Does FamilyAlbum share my photos with AI companies?
Yes, FamilyAlbum recently updated its privacy policy to include integration with AI company Anthropic for "enhanced search," which has caused significant concern and outrage among users who previously valued the app for its privacy features R1R25R28R31.
Are there many ads in PhotoCircle?
Yes, PhotoCircle users report a significant number of intrusive, full-screen ads that often get stuck, are unskippable, and can be inappropriate, forcing users to restart the app to continue using it R61R64R70R72.
Can I order prints through FamilyAlbum?
Yes, FamilyAlbum offers print services and users can receive 11 free pictures every month for $3.99 shipping R8, but many users report significant issues with ordered photos not being received and poor customer service regarding these orders R2R3R4R10.
Does PhotoCircle work on desktop or iPad?
PhotoCircle is primarily designed for mobile use, with users reporting that it is not available for use on a computer, which limits accessibility for those who prefer larger screens R67R103. Additionally, recent updates require iOS 16.0, making it incompatible with older iPads and iPhones R63R113.

What reviewers actually said

Built only from these 120 real reviews (foreign ones translated). Superscripts jump to the quote here. Apple has no per-review links, so [ref] opens that app's reviews on the App Store.

  1. [R5] FamilyAlbum 5/5 · US Big fan!: What a great was to share pix without having to send to everyone individually or post everything on FB.
  2. [R6] FamilyAlbum 3/5 · US Increasingly a Money Grab: When we first started using this app, it was great! It was a wonderful way for us to privately share pictures with family and friends. Over the years, the pop ups and ads for products and paid versions of the app have gotten increasingly annoying. For me, the worst part is when they took away the already limited “on this day” slideshows to give you only one each day. I u
  3. [R7] FamilyAlbum 1/5 · US Money grab: Used to be a great app overall but recent updates have put previously free features behind paywalls. Like the “on this day” recaps. Seems a bit shady to try and make money by putting previously free features behind paywalls instead of adding new features and charging for those. People notice these kind of things. Truly hope they reverse this decision as I will do my part in letting peo
  4. [R8] FamilyAlbum 5/5 · US Best Family Album Ever: Great way to share photos and videos with family members and close friends. Love getting to see pictures and videos my grandkids daily. I also love the fact that I can get the 11 pictures every month for $ 3.99. there are usually so many good ones I end up getting more than my 11 every month.
  5. [R2] FamilyAlbum 4/5 · US Still waiting on ordered photos: Enjoy being able to see all the photos. I have had trouble receiving the photos I have ordered the last few months.
  6. [R3] FamilyAlbum 3/5 · US Love the app, but…: I love being able to share photos in the app with family, but I bought photos in April and May and I still have not received them. While sharing photos is awesome, if you want them printed, you’re better off ordering them through your local photo printing place like Walgreens or Walmart.
  7. [R4] FamilyAlbum 2/5 · US Worried: I love the app. I truly do but recently my orders have not showed up. My address is correct and yet the photos still say shipped but they never deliver. It scares me because I don't know where my photos are going and they are pictures of my children. I keep getting replacement free photos and they also don't show. I just feel super uncomfortable that I don't know where my personal photos
  8. [R9] FamilyAlbum 3/5 · US Needs multiple uploads: Need to upload multiple times for pictures to get in there. States that upload failed 😣
  9. [R1] FamilyAlbum 1/5 · US added ai into the mix: why can’t we just enjoy sharing photos without the use of ai to protect our children from ai & to have clean WATER for them! AI is not more important than our children. we dont need to search for photos that’s what our eyes are for 😵‍💫
  10. [R13] FamilyAlbum 1/5 · US Not fully secure: I love the idea of this app as I have some relatives who will post pictures without my permission. However these same relatives were able to buy hard copy print outs of my pictures without out my approval even when I turned off reminders so the people stopped getting emails regarding them. The app doesn’t even inform you that someone you shared pictures with through them bought y
  11. [R23] FamilyAlbum 5/5 · US Exceptional: I have absolutely loved having this app and being able to still share my children with friends and family! We love privacy and this app is wonderful. I do wish you could load videos without paying BUT still a win.
  12. [R25] FamilyAlbum 1/5 · US Sharing my private photos with AI companies: It is a sick and twisted betrayal to take private, intimate photos intended for family only and sell them to an AI company (Anthropic). The whole selling point of this app was to share baby photos with family exclusively to shelter them from prying eyes. Evil, evil, evil company. Beware
  13. [R15] FamilyAlbum 3/5 · US Taking away features: I’ve loved this app for the past three years, especially the “on this day” feature. But I updated the app and that feature has been taken away unless I pay, which is ridiculous.
  14. [R19] FamilyAlbum 2/5 · US Pop ups every use: The main functionality is good. But even with the paid app, every time I open the app they try to upsell something else. It’s beyond aggravating.
  15. [R10] FamilyAlbum 1/5 · US Don’t order pictures: I ordered some pictures and was charged but never received.
  16. [R42] FamilyAlbum 3/5 · GB Great for photo sharing but don’t order prints: Brilliant app for sharing photo’s of our newborn with the family but print & album ordering not as successful. I ordered a set of prints & an album nearly 2 months ago and have not received them. Didn’t realise, before I ordered that they come from China. I’ve tried to contact twice to find out where they are & request a refund but have had no resp
  17. [R49] FamilyAlbum 1/5 · US Poor customer service: I have made two purchases from the store. The second one came with a cracked handle. I sent multiple emails with no response from customer support. I will never purchase from them again. The sad thing is the cups with photos are very cute.
  18. [R28] FamilyAlbum 1/5 · US Deceptive privacy policy update sends to AI: We used this app for years specifically because they weren’t harvesting/training on *childrens photos*. It was aimed as being private. They recently started sharing - I assume - photos with Anthropic as a footnote in their privacy policy update for “enhanced search”. No thanks.
  19. [R31] FamilyAlbum 1/5 · US Would rate zero: Added AI under Anthropics in the new privacy policy. Disgusting. Obviously doesn’t understand the majority of their audience or care about protecting children from AI.
  20. [R61] PhotoCircle 2/5 · US Too many Ads: Ads pop up too many times. Sometimes you can’t get out without killing the app and restarting.
  21. [R64] PhotoCircle 1/5 · US Hardly usable: So many ads that it is hard to even use it.
  22. [R70] PhotoCircle 1/5 · US Ads, ads everywhere: Unable to skip ads, ads get stuck on and never end. Only way to get out of the ads is to force quit the app. Not worth it
  23. [R72] PhotoCircle 3/5 · US Ads are a killer: They’re always inappropriate and stuff
  24. [R63] PhotoCircle 3/5 · US Love it, but…: I was using this right? And it was so nice being able to see the photos. But now I can’t anymore cuz I have to have IOS16.0 and I can’t go that far guys… I know this is a just me issue, but what id like to understand is why it requires such an update? It worked perfectly for me before. I thank you for taking the time to read this.
  25. [R67] PhotoCircle 1/5 · US Only good for cell phone?: I just paid for this app so I would have flexibility for my group to download each others photos. After paying, I found out that the app is not available for use on a computer! What’s that about? My older eyes struggle to see images clearly on a cell phone. What a waste of my $10.00!
  26. [R103] PhotoCircle 2/5 · US Nothing Original: Got the premium version of this app to run on desktop to have my business submit photos to be displayed on a big board at an event party in a slideshow fashion. The app doesn’t have this functionality - this is just a less functional Google Photos - which is what I had to go to after downloading all the photos. I don’t see the point of this app.
  27. [R113] PhotoCircle 1/5 · GB Now requires iOS 16. My old tablet maxed out at 15+: This app has upgraded beyond my ability to use it on my iPad. The forced update won’t run so I have no other option but to uninstall. Why not leave a copy of the old app available, with security caveats, or whatever? Or make a web version; I use other former apps on Safari, e.g. eBay, AirBNB, now my old tablet isn’t supported by the app.

Synthesized from 120 recent App Store reviews · updated July 2026 · View on the App Store