Black Deck vs Yu-Gi-Oh! Master Duel
Choose Yu-Gi-Oh! Master Duel for a more polished experience and better gameplay mechanics.
Yu-Gi-Oh! Master Duel offers a more engaging and balanced gameplay experience, despite some complaints about matchmaking and long turns. Black Deck, while fun for some, suffers from aggressive monetization and frequent loading issues that detract from the overall enjoyment.
Head to head
you prefer a game with a casual start and are okay with aggressive monetization.
you want a more traditional card game experience with better overall stability and features.
Evidence note: The evidence is somewhat one-sided, with more negative feedback on Black Deck's monetization and reliability compared to Yu-Gi-Oh! Master Duel's gameplay issues.
Frequently asked
Is Black Deck free to play?
What reviewers actually said
Built only from these 100 real reviews (foreign ones translated). Superscripts jump to the quote here. Apple has no per-review links, so [ref] opens that app's reviews on the App Store.
- [R1] Black Deck Packs and more packs: Unfortunately you spend more time pressing the 'x' button on packs that are repeatedly thrown in your face than you do playing the card game. Every change of screen there is a pack thrown at you and it's not as though they're all different packs. They're the same pack. If I didn't buy it the first time I'm probably not going to the 3rd, 4th or even 10th time!!!!!!!!!! What a
- [R10] Black Deck Good idea, poor execution: Doesn’t explain things properly , poor tutorial. Doesn’t explain how the events properly , and is the only game to pop more ads than Mech Arena. And that’s saying something.
- [R57] Yu-Gi-Oh! Master Duel Need a lot of money: If you want a good deck you will need to put down a few hundred to play this. If you want a specific deck you will need to put in £500+ You need a good deck for this as match making is just you getting place against people who have good decks and the odd new person and there is no in between.
- [R53] Yu-Gi-Oh! Master Duel Too many “special summons”: The game allows players to summon as much as they want and is just generally a boring experience sitting waiting for 10mins for someone to play their turn and even sometimes during your turn using draw cards or effect from graveyard, i don’t play meta but that’s who you are going to be set up with 99.99% of the time. The app is amazing but Yugioh the game is basically a
- [R2] Black Deck kinda addictive: lowkey seen this game on an instagram reel advert, thought it looked cool so I gave it a go. Was easy to get the hang of. Barely progressed and can’t wait to keep playing.
- [R59] Yu-Gi-Oh! Master Duel Not beginner friendly at all: So I would imagine this is good if you know what you’re doing as there’s customisation, additional decks etc. Unfortunately I am not one of those people. I got taught how to play it a good few years ago when a colleague brought in some decks to help pass a night shift, and I thoroughly enjoyed it and wanted to try it again although it’s been so long now I don’t real
- [R60] Yu-Gi-Oh! Master Duel Pointless: New player and trying to get my head around this. Lose 5 out of 5 and in the first turn. What’s the point. Get a monster n trap destroyed n then all 8k Life points in one turn! Deleted ✌️
- [R70] Yu-Gi-Oh! Master Duel Great game, hard to understand at first: I originally posted quite a negative review, I take it back and apologies. It’s quite hard to understand at first, being thrown into it with a limited tutorial and basically being forced to kinda learn as u lose, once i bought the origins of the galaxy pack, i’ve managed to understand alot of the mechanics and the game is quite alot of fun now, a win streak
- [R4] Black Deck Great Game but….: My advice to you is find a different game to play, don’t get emotionally invested in this on it will only disappoint. I have been playing this game faithfully for about a year now and have thoroughly enjoyed it. I even subscribed to a modest upgrade membership but I’ll be cancelling that. recently it has began to frequently fail to load and disconnects during fights. I can’t e
- [R13] Black Deck Great game, terrible update: I love this game and have spent lots of time in it. So it's really disappointing that the latest update (at 24 September 2024) is really buggy. Takes an age to load, then in game randomly crashes or freezes. Sometimes catches up with itself but if not have to close and reopen so back to incredibly slow loading.
- [R56] Yu-Gi-Oh! Master Duel Good game bad glitches: I would call this a good game I had lots of op decks but after a week of playing everything reset and I lost everything I had and every time I try to play again the data download doesn’t go up from 0
- [R61] Yu-Gi-Oh! Master Duel We need a quick mode!: Is a really good game but tbh be boring when we are waiting for 15 minutes your opponent to finish his main 1 and to finish. There we can see he have 300 seconds and that second look like never count nothing. Lets have a Quick Mode for us classic player who finish our turn for 10 sec haha. Let it be an mode when your time is 60 second included with our setting cards and foe
- [R3] Black Deck Game is alright so so: I enjoy the game it’s just jeez lower the prices a bit on micro transactions it’s like 17.99 and up price wise on everything in the shop.. and for 10 summons in the treasure tower it’s like 50.00 bucks game has potential if you’re a millionaire
- [R37] Black Deck Pay to win: Cash grab avoid
- [R78] Yu-Gi-Oh! Master Duel My go to TCG: A very fun but complex TCG it translates the mechanics amazingly and the events are fun Very F2P friendly and fast match making The current loaner decks in ranked is an incredible idea and the new solo duels to give a quick layout of the gameplan was a great idea Obviously maxx c is an issue but it’s based more on the OCG there no changing that Bit too much rarity bumping hal
- [R21] Black Deck Great game: Not been able to get onto the game for over a week now and have emailed them twice with no response
- [R46] Black Deck Support?: Game server just keeps losing network connection for the last 2 days. The support button doesn’t work. I’m going to have to give up with this game for now because it’s unplayable
- [R26] Black Deck Great support team: My son had issue with app loading and support team replied so quickly to resolve it - thanks Kate
- [R71] Yu-Gi-Oh! Master Duel No way to recover your data from a broken device in 2024!!!: So I played the game at release for about a year and then took a break for awhile, unfortunately my old device (iPhone) that I started the account on was broken in this time, fast forward to today and I can’t transfer my save game data from my old device. I’m signed into the same game center account as it’s the same one I’ve always had,
- [R6] Black Deck Good game. Ridiculous in-game add on purchase prices: This game would be perfect if they sorted the favourite card issue and they didn’t charge stupids amounts for in game purchase add on. They Charge like £40 for 5 rare items, for items to upgrade is like £29.99 for 10 crystals which you can earn easily, it’s insane. Everything is massively over priced. You would Make more money by charging a fai
- [R34] Black Deck Pay to play: Don’t touch this game if you want to make any sort of progress with out spending any money. The in game transactions are insanely overpriced and get you little to no progress. You are basically gambling real money for cards with little to no chance of any improvement. Really only recommended this game for people who don’t care about spending a few thousand pounds to play the game
Synthesized from 100 recent App Store reviews · updated July 2026 · View on the App Store