Verithiathe honest score on any app
Updated July 2026 · real, multi-region App Store reviews
Head-to-head

Maine State Credit Union vs Navy Federal Credit Union

Maine State Credit Union 4.8★ · Free to download 60
Winner Navy Federal Credit Union
Navy Federal Credit Union 4.9★ · Free to download 75

Navy Federal Credit Union (NFCU) is the stronger choice due to its broader feature set and generally positive user experience, despite frequent maintenance issues, while Maine State Credit Union (MSCU) struggles with fundamental app stability and login problems.

Full reviews: Maine State Credit Union · Navy Federal Credit Union

Navy Federal Credit Union's app offers a comprehensive banking experience with generally positive feedback on features and ease of use, though it is frequently plagued by maintenance downtime. Maine State Credit Union's app, while praised by some for simplicity, faces significant issues with login, stability, and displaying basic account information after updates.

Head to head

Features & Functionality edge: Navy Federal Credit UnionR2R6R9R11
Maine State Credit Union Maine State Credit Union users appreciate the ability to manage all accounts, perform simple transfers, and make deposits, with some noting the convenience of opening accounts within the app R2. However, recent updates have caused issues like the inability to see total balances or specific club account names, forcing users to resort to web browsers R9R11. Mobile deposit functionality is also inconsistent R6.
Navy Federal Credit Union Navy Federal Credit Union's app is praised for easy navigation, account transitions, money movement, and access to bank statements . Recent updates have improved credit card points display . Users desire features like a memo option for transfers, dark mode, and a home screen widget . Some features, like savings goals and rewards search, have become buggy or less user-friendly after updates .
Ease of Use & Navigation tieR1R2R4R6
Maine State Credit Union Some Maine State Credit Union users find the app easy to learn and navigate, calling it user-friendly R2. Conversely, many recent reviews highlight significant difficulties with navigation, signing in, and being forced to change passwords frequently R1R4. The app is described as temperamental, sometimes requiring users to log in via the web R6.
Navy Federal Credit Union Navy Federal Credit Union's app is generally considered easy to use with a clear interface . However, users report issues with the app freezing, locking up, or not loading, making it inaccessible . The 'switch user' feature is unreliable , and some display issues make parts of the screen inaccessible on certain iPhones .
Reliability & Performance tieR1R4R7R24
Maine State Credit Union Maine State Credit Union's app has significant reliability issues, with users frequently locked out or unable to sign in R1R7. Updates are often cited as making the app worse, leading to constant password resets and requiring multiple hoops to jump through R1R4. The app periodically fails to load or provide account information R24.
Navy Federal Credit Union Navy Federal Credit Union's app is frequently criticized for constant and lengthy maintenance periods, often occurring at inconvenient times, which prevents users from accessing their accounts or making transfers R33R35R39. Users also report the app freezing, locking up, or not loading at all . Specific functions like mobile deposits and credit card payments also experience errors R78R88.
Customer Support & Communication edge: Maine State Credit UnionR5R8R14R16
Maine State Credit Union While the app itself has issues, Maine State Credit Union's in-person staff are frequently praised for being helpful, well-trained, and providing great service R5R8R16R18. There are no specific app-related support comments, but the credit union's overall service is highly regarded R14.
Navy Federal Credit Union Navy Federal Credit Union users report difficulties reaching live agents via chat and long wait times when calling customer service . Some users have experienced issues with credit card notifications not being received, which customer service has been unable to resolve . The app also lacks warnings for maintenance or upcoming payments R35.
Price & Value tieR14R18R20R27
Maine State Credit Union Maine State Credit Union is appreciated for offering good savings rates, an ultra-low rate credit card, and no ATM fees R14R18. Users value the long-term relationship and dependable service from the institution R14R20R27.
Navy Federal Credit Union Navy Federal Credit Union is considered by some to be the 'best bank and app ever' with competitive rates . However, there are no specific mentions of app-related pricing or value beyond the general banking services.
Pick Maine State Credit Union if

You prioritize strong in-person customer service and competitive rates for loans and savings, and are willing to tolerate an app with significant login and display issues R5R14R18R20.

Pick Navy Federal Credit Union if

You need a comprehensive banking app with a wide range of features for managing accounts, transfers, and credit cards, and are prepared to deal with frequent maintenance downtime and occasional app glitches R33.

Evidence note: Maine State Credit Union has significantly fewer reviews than Navy Federal Credit Union, leading to less comprehensive evidence for some dimensions. Both apps are free to download, so there is no free-vs-paid asymmetry.

Frequently asked

Why does the Maine State Credit Union app get low ratings despite a high lifetime average?
Recent updates to the Maine State Credit Union app have introduced significant issues, including difficulties with signing in, constant password resets, inability to view account balances, and general instability, leading to many recent 1-star reviews that skew the perception of its current performance R1R4R7R11.
Is the Navy Federal Credit Union app often unavailable?
Yes, the Navy Federal Credit Union app is frequently under maintenance, with users reporting it being unavailable for hours or at inconvenient times, which prevents access to accounts and services R33R35R39R42.
Can I make mobile deposits with these apps?
Maine State Credit Union's app offers mobile deposit, but users report it can be inconsistent R6. Navy Federal Credit Union also has mobile deposit, but some users have experienced issues with the feature freezing or not recognizing clear photos after recent updates R78R88.

What reviewers actually said

Built only from these 92 real reviews (foreign ones translated). Superscripts jump to the quote here. Apple has no per-review links, so [ref] opens that app's reviews on the App Store.

  1. [R2] Maine State Credit Union 5/5 · US All you need.: All my accounts are easy to get around too. Transfers are simple. Interface is easy to learn. Perfect banking app.
  2. [R6] Maine State Credit Union 3/5 · US Temperamental: This app is temperamental. Sometimes it works well and other times I need to use the web to log in. The mobile deposit feature isn’t consistent either.
  3. [R9] Maine State Credit Union 2/5 · US Fine, not a great as it could be: Okay app, I can see my balances and transactions. However, I have multiple club accounts set up but none of the names show so that I can make transfers to/from specific accounts. Because of this I usually have to go on my web browser to their online banking, which is annoying.
  4. [R11] Maine State Credit Union 1/5 · US Can't see my balance anymore: I like the new update except for one huge issue, the account balance isn't there. Please fix!
  5. [R1] Maine State Credit Union 1/5 · US Was great, now is terrible: They always update their app, and every time it’s harder to use, navigate and even sign in. I’m forced to change passwords because they insist I do because they want to update and make the app worse. I’m asked to confirm my account every other time I try to sign in. Literally every update makes me want to change banks. So many hoops to jump through just to see my accoun
  6. [R4] Maine State Credit Union 2/5 · US Maine Credit Union: Constant updates and I am always resetting my password. I’m not really convinced that the app is worth having. I have no trouble with the Credit Union, itself.
  7. [R7] Maine State Credit Union 1/5 · US Locked out.: Whenever I try to login to my account it says I’m locked out so I follow the steps to unlock it and it allows me to access my account online but I’m still locked out on the app.
  8. [R24] Maine State Credit Union 4/5 · US Frustrating: It works great when it actually loads, but periodically it goes thru phases of not loading anything which makes banking difficult when ur app won’t load and u only have 2 locations..
  9. [R5] Maine State Credit Union 5/5 · US Great financial institution!: All the workers there are very helpful and well-trained. Great member satisfaction here!
  10. [R8] Maine State Credit Union 5/5 · US Great service: Hopefully they let me open my account back open when I had lost my job for three months
  11. [R14] Maine State Credit Union 5/5 · US Trust, convenience & service: I’ve been with Maine State Credit Union since it was Maine State Employees Credit Union in 1987. Ive had home, car and personal loans with them over the years. The process for those has always been efficient and easy. My credit card with them has an ultra low rate which can’t be beat anywhere. The no ATM fees is a plus as well and I can usually find a CU ATM. I have
  12. [R16] Maine State Credit Union 5/5 · US Great banking.: Everybody was very helpful and did their best to get me seen as quickly as possible.
  13. [R18] Maine State Credit Union 5/5 · US Good place: Good savings rates and friendly staff.
  14. [R20] Maine State Credit Union 5/5 · US Review: MSCU has been like a family member to me always professional knowledgeable and makes sure your questions and needs are met going on 40 years🌻🌻🌻
  15. [R27] Maine State Credit Union 5/5 · US MSCU Provides my banking needs: Long term friendly and dependable service to all accounts, all the time. MSCU is competent and I am confident in them .
  16. [R33] Navy Federal Credit Union 2/5 · US Always under maintenance: WHYYYY is this app constantly under maintenance? I try to open in and half the time I can't even check my account or transfer money because they're "conducting scheduled maintenance." I've never dealt with a banking app or any app like this where it's always undergoing some sort of service, like this is so frequent that it has irritated me enough to the point of writing a
  17. [R35] Navy Federal Credit Union 3/5 · US The Maintenance shut down is annoying: Eveytime I need to get into my bank I gotta worry if it in maintenance or not like at least give me a warning
  18. [R39] Navy Federal Credit Union 1/5 · US The app is trash: It shouldn’t ever take 6 plus hours for a “ schedule maintenance” it’s ridiculous at this point
  19. [R42] Navy Federal Credit Union 1/5 · US Maintenance times: Maintenance times take too long when I need to acces my account the most
  20. [R78] Navy Federal Credit Union 1/5 · US Can’t do mobile deposits anymore: Since a recent update (I believe 2026.6.1) I’m no longer able to do mobile deposits. When I take a picture of the front of the check, the entire screen turns white and just stays there frozen. I’ve tried turning off auto capture, flash, restarting app, restarting phone, my phone has the latest iOS update, everything. The bug is in the app.
  21. [R88] Navy Federal Credit Union 4/5 · US pretty great: fix the mobile deposit there shouldn’t be no reason that i take the best photos of my life with my phone and it still says blurry even though i literally just cleaned my camera before taking the photo and have perfect lighting… example im dealing with this issue now and i’m right now im next to my window with the light on and it’s still saying blurry.

Synthesized from 92 recent App Store reviews · updated July 2026 · View on the App Store