Verithiathe honest score on any app
Updated July 2026 · real, multi-region App Store reviews
Head-to-head

BookBuddy vs Fable

BookBuddy 4.8★ · Free + IAP 75
Winner Tie
Fable 4.8★ · Free + IAP 70

BookBuddy is better for users primarily focused on cataloging and managing their personal book collections, while Fable excels as a social platform for discovering books and engaging with other readers.

Full reviews: BookBuddy · Fable

BookBuddy offers robust features for organizing personal libraries, including barcode scanning and loan tracking, but has a strict free tier limit. Fable provides a Goodreads-like social experience with book clubs and reading streaks, though it struggles with technical glitches and content availability.

Head to head

Cataloging and Inventory Management edge: BookBuddyR1R2R5R11
BookBuddy BookBuddy is highly praised for its ability to scan barcodes and ISBNs, automatically uploading book data and covers, which saves significant time for users with large collections R2R5R11. Users appreciate features like tracking loaned books, adding personal tags, and sorting options . However, some users report issues with scanning older or indie books, requiring manual input R1R12R16.
Fable Fable users primarily focus on tracking their reading progress and lists . While it allows importing from Goodreads, this process is often buggy, creating duplicates or missing data R85R100. Users also complain about the inability to add indie or less common books, limiting its utility as a comprehensive cataloging tool .
Social and Community Features edge: FableR15R19R62R63
BookBuddy BookBuddy is primarily a personal inventory tool with very limited social features. Users occasionally request features like family sharing R15R19 but the app is not designed for community interaction.
Fable Fable is highly valued for its social aspects, allowing users to connect with other readers, join virtual book clubs, and share opinions R62. Users enjoy discovering new reads through community recommendations . However, some users report issues with friend requests and book club functionality R63, and a significant number complain about political content and bullying in the social feed R73R88R91R118.
Ease of Use and User Interface edge: BookBuddyR3R5R9R14
BookBuddy BookBuddy is generally considered easy to use and intuitive for cataloging books R3R5. However, some users find certain features clunky, like manual sort order R9 or creating series R14, and some mention the aesthetic could be improved . Font scaling issues are also noted .
Fable Fable's UI/UX is often praised as fabulous and modern R62. Despite this, many users report significant glitches, bugs, and clunky interactions, such as issues with adding friends, marking books as read, stats not loading, and notifications not working R63. There are also complaints about poor accessibility options, specifically the inability to change font size .
Reliability and Performance edge: BookBuddyR1R7R12R16
BookBuddy BookBuddy generally performs reliably for its core function of cataloging, though some users experience issues with scanning accuracy, especially for older or indie books R1R12R16. A critical concern is data loss, with some users reporting that added books are erased after updates R42. There are also reports of paid features not working post-purchase R7.
Fable Fable is frequently criticized for its unreliability, with numerous reports of glitches, bugs, and performance issues. These include syncing problems with Goodreads R61R85R100, reviews being erased , stats pages not loading , notifications failing , and books being duplicated or miscounted R85R100. Some users also get stuck in reader mode or experience app crashes .
Price and Value edge: BookBuddyR4R6R7R10
BookBuddy BookBuddy offers a free tier limited to 50 books, which many users find frustrating and consider a "money grab" R4R6R21. The lifetime premium version costs $10 R7R10R11, which many paying users consider a good value for organizing large libraries R11. However, some paying users are disappointed with the features offered for the price .
Fable Fable is free with in-app purchases (Fable+). Users express frustration with paywalls for advanced stats and features, viewing it as a "money grab" . Some users question the value of the paid options given the app's glitches . The app also has unskippable video ads that are disliked .
Customer Support tieR42R54R61R76
BookBuddy BookBuddy reviews mention limited support options R54 and some users report that customer service responses do not resolve issues, particularly regarding data loss R42.
Fable Fable users frequently report poor customer service, describing it as unhelpful, dismissive, and having an "attitude" R61R76. Some users struggle to find ways to contact support for bug reporting .
Pick BookBuddy if

you want a reliable, easy-to-use app primarily for cataloging your personal book collection, tracking loans, and avoiding duplicate purchases, especially if you have a large library and are willing to pay a one-time fee for unlimited entries R2R11.

Pick Fable if

you are looking for a social media-like experience for readers, enjoy joining book clubs, tracking reading streaks, and discovering new books through community interaction, and are willing to overlook occasional glitches and content limitations R62.

Evidence note: BookBuddy's reviews are heavily skewed towards its cataloging features and the free-to-paid transition. Fable's reviews highlight its social features and frequent technical issues. The lifetime ratings are similar, but recent negative reviews for Fable suggest a decline in user experience due to bugs and content moderation issues.

Frequently asked

What is the book limit for BookBuddy's free version?
BookBuddy's free version allows you to add up to 50 books before requiring a one-time payment for unlimited entries R4R6R11R21.
Can Fable import data from Goodreads?
Yes, Fable offers a feature to import data from Goodreads, but many users report that this process is buggy, often resulting in duplicate entries, missing books, or corrupted stats R61R85R100.
Does BookBuddy support family sharing for paid features?
No, BookBuddy does not currently support family sharing for paid features, meaning each family member needs to pay and scan their own library to access the information R15R19.
Are there issues with Fable's social feed content?
Yes, several Fable users have expressed strong dissatisfaction with the social feed, citing an abundance of political content, bullying, and harassment, which they feel detracts from the app's purpose as a book community R73R88R91R118.

What reviewers actually said

Built only from these 120 real reviews (foreign ones translated). Superscripts jump to the quote here. Apple has no per-review links, so [ref] opens that app's reviews on the App Store.

  1. [R1] BookBuddy 2/5 · US Disappointed: I originally wanted a different app. The one I wanted does not show up on Apple App Store. This was top of the list as a close related app. Was disappointed that half my books I scanned. I had to go back and enter in manually anyways save yourself the time in trouble and just get Handy library from Google.
  2. [R2] BookBuddy 5/5 · US The best book inventory app: BookBuddy is a wonderful app and it allows for me to maintain a clean inventory for all of the books I own. Once in a while I need to manually add in a book that it doesn’t recognize, but it’s an easy task to do. I highly recommend the app.
  3. [R5] BookBuddy 5/5 · US Love this app: I’ve been using this for a couple years now. Very easy to use. I have had maybe a handful not scan and need manual input. I will say I wish I could also track my book sub boxes with this! It would be so much easier
  4. [R11] BookBuddy 5/5 · US FANTASTIC APP: I love this app - I can scan barcodes or enter ISBNs in manually, take photos of covers that don’t automatically apply, and even keep track of which books I’ve leant out. First 50 books are free to scan, then a one time and lifetime price for $10. I’m using this to keep track of my 300+ books and as evidence for any insurance needs!
  5. [R15] BookBuddy 3/5 · US Family Sharing Feature Need: The app should be configured to better support libraries of families
  6. [R19] BookBuddy 1/5 · US Can’t share with my spouse: My husband has paid for the service and has scanned our library. But when I download the app to access OUR library, it wants me to pay and scan in everything again! Why do I need to pay $20 and then scan for both of us to access the same information! You need a household option!
  7. [R62] Fable 5/5 · US Goodreads Be Damned: Such a superior app, it cannot be overstated. EVERY reader should use Fable. I only wish it was easier to find newer reads, but the UI/UX is just fabulous for tracking your own reading and that of your friends.
  8. [R63] Fable 3/5 · US Glitches: Can’t add friends easily, when share profile it takes them to web browser/make an account. Accidentally marked a book as read and it keep saying that I read it on my stats when I even removed the whole book from my information. Also annoying how when swipe back on book groups it takes you all the way back to search results of group have to click arrow instead. Bad glitches!
  9. [R3] BookBuddy 3/5 · US Love it! But have request for change 🤍: I have been using this for years and absolutely love it!! So many awesome features and easy to use! I do ask for 2 things to be changed/updated - 1. Please add the ability to search by personal tags 2. Please add multiple tag categories that can be personalized - for example, I would love to have Topic Tags, Person Tags, Timeframe Tags so that I can go th
  10. [R9] BookBuddy 3/5 · US Seems nice enough: Update: so there is the workaround but it’s not as slick as you’d expect: you have to switch to list view, change the order and then go back to cover view. Seems nice enough, was hoping it would allow drag and drop for manual sort order in the thumbnail view. It’s great that you can sort by lots of criteria, but my moods on what to read next shift and I’d like to sort and reso
  11. [R14] BookBuddy 4/5 · US Great App: I definitely would recommend this app for anyone looking to catalog their books and track their collections. My only complaint would be that I have to manually create and add books to the “series” filter. This can be frustrating when you have large book series or a lot of different series. It would be nice if it would automatically gather this information online and create them for you.
  12. [R7] BookBuddy 2/5 · US Confused: I do love this app, I paid the $10 for a lifetime membership. It’s not correct on which month I read the books in. It stopped editing in April
  13. [R12] BookBuddy 3/5 · US Ok I guess: Was super excited for this after it was recommended by a friend. It does alot of things I wish goodreads did. However, there’s practically no indie author books on here. I tried various methods and keywords to try and add books to my shelves and so many indie authors just don’t show up. Even worse is I paid $6 to be able to add more than 20 books only to discover this afterwards and th
  14. [R16] BookBuddy 1/5 · US Not for Older Books: I collect vintage paperbacks 1975-1995 and this app does not work with those UPC codes. It only works with new books with ISBN codes on modern books.
  15. [R4] BookBuddy 2/5 · US book limit: only let me add 50
  16. [R6] BookBuddy 3/5 · US I don’t really know: App seemed great at first, however after adding 50 books to my shelf I was hit with a fee if I wanted to add any more books.
  17. [R10] BookBuddy 1/5 · US Very good: You can buy it outright instead of a subscription. Annoying number of in-app alerts. Update: it is asking for a review every time I complete an action in the app. I’ve updated my review to reflect this, as it renders the app unusable
  18. [R42] BookBuddy 1/5 · US AVOID!!! DELETES ADDED BOOKS: I have complained about this for years and it continues to happen. I am meticulous with my books. Added the correct cover. Record the box. Add isbn numbers etc and over and over books I have added are just erased. I have over 1500 books but this app is worthless, the response from customer service does nothing… it seems like each update removes data. Looking elsewhe
  19. [R54] BookBuddy 2/5 · GB Fidgety: It’s too easy to create duplicates and too difficult to remove them. The support option is too limited.
  20. [R61] Fable 1/5 · US Stopped syncing: 1 star because I bright it to their attention and they dismissed me as it was just busy and needed more time to sync. It stopped syncing with goodreads about a week ago. It doesn’t have you in to goodreads, it just has the syncing page that says 2-3 mins, and then it doesn’t sync. It’s not that serious, but it’s the way I was blown off and dismissed when reporting a bug. Also, the
  21. [R76] Fable 1/5 · US Terrible Customer Service: If you have any issues with the app and submit a request, expect to be met with little help and attitude from the customer services representatives.
  22. [R21] BookBuddy 3/5 · GB God but has some faults: This is a great app to log books in and reminds you who you have lenses your book to but I have about 150 books and it only lets me log 50 unless you pay for the premium package. Great app but not quite right for me.
  23. [R85] Fable 1/5 · US I wanted to like this app but it’s a waste of time.: Things were working decently until I tried to use the import Goodreads feature and sync my data. Well it turns out that COMPLETELY messed up my entire page by making duplicates of every book and review, and somehow messing up my stats by adding random numbers. I tried fixing it by deleting the import and that did nothing, so I tried deleting all
  24. [R100] Fable 2/5 · US Butchered my goodreads imports: I don't even have that extensive of goodreads data but the import was completely messed up. Books from my want to read marked as read, weird place holder books in my library instead of the actual book, books missing, 5 of the same custom list with one book from the list in it? I probably won't be using this app.
  25. [R73] Fable 1/5 · US Used to be great.: This app was amazing a year ago. Sadly now politics has taken over. You can’t scroll your feed without reading hyper political content. Reading the app description you’d think you’d be in good company for rambunctious literary debates/reviews. Nope. You’ll have to read about topics from ICE and the existential threat of climate change. There are countless apps/groups that are a
  26. [R88] Fable 1/5 · US Disappointingly hateful: I wanted to like this app. Even tried a month of premium to see the extra features, I was so excited! Goodreads can be a bit dull after so many years so I was looking for an alternative. I was immediately impressed. A whole app for book lovers?! With added features for TV and movies. Dream come true! But like with every app with a social media aspect, the hate I starte
  27. [R91] Fable 1/5 · US Bullying & Harassment: I was bullied & harassed on this site. Fable appears to condone this behavior. Very poor service.
  28. [R118] Fable 1/5 · US Woke Trash App: This app is run by a bunch of shills paid by the smut Romantasy publishers. Bug-ridden app with one of the worst social media implementations out there. They bust people for responding negatively to overtly Leftist and racist (against Whites) posts, punishing the responders instead of the original poster. Tired of seeing the worst people in the Feed. I didn’t sign up for this trash

Synthesized from 120 recent App Store reviews · updated July 2026 · View on the App Store