Verithiathe honest score on any app
Updated July 2026 · real, multi-region App Store reviews
Head-to-head

WKYT FirstAlert Weather vs Weather Underground

WKYT FirstAlert Weather 4.8★ · Free to download 70
Winner WKYT FirstAlert Weather
Weather Underground 3.9★ · Free + IAP · ⚠ stale 55

WKYT FirstAlert Weather is a better choice for users prioritizing local, accurate forecasts and radar, despite its ad-heavy experience, while Weather Underground struggles with stability and accuracy issues.

Full reviews: WKYT FirstAlert Weather · Weather Underground

WKYT FirstAlert Weather generally offers accurate local forecasts and radar, though it's heavily criticized for excessive ads and occasional glitches. Weather Underground, despite its long history and hyperlocal data, is plagued by frequent crashes, inaccurate data, and a less user-friendly experience.

Head to head

Features & Content tieR3R7R8R11
WKYT FirstAlert Weather WKYT FirstAlert Weather offers radar, hourly updates, and extended forecasts, with users appreciating its storm tracking capabilities R8R11. However, some features like lightning alerts are missing or non-functional R3, and the radar can be delayed or inaccurate compared to other apps R16. Users also note issues with video content, such as outdated forecasts and playback problems R7.
Weather Underground Weather Underground is praised for its real-time radar, hourly precipitation breakdowns, and the ability to connect personal weather stations for hyperlocal data . However, users frequently request future radar , complain about radar overlays obscuring information , and note missing features like widgets for iPhone R99R104R116 and the inability to sort favorite locations .
Ease of Use & User Experience tieR1R2R4R9
WKYT FirstAlert Weather Many users find WKYT FirstAlert Weather easy to use and appreciate its straightforward information R2R24. However, recent updates have made the app difficult to navigate for some R24, and the interface is described as generic . A significant number of complaints revolve around excessive ads that interrupt access to weather information R1R4R9R19.
Weather Underground Weather Underground is noted for its intuitive horizontal scrolling for daily and hourly forecasts and easy navigation R66. However, the app is frequently criticized for its cluttered radar display with temperature readings and for becoming less accessible for visually impaired users . Many users also report issues with the 'current location' feature not working correctly .
Reliability & Performance edge: WKYT FirstAlert WeatherR10R11R16R17
WKYT FirstAlert Weather WKYT FirstAlert Weather receives mixed reviews on accuracy, with some users praising it as the 'most accurate' R17 and 'dependable' , especially for local storm tracking R11. Conversely, many users report inaccurate radar R16, delayed data , and inconsistent forecasts . The app is also prone to crashing R10R21 and audio issues .
Weather Underground Weather Underground is highly praised by some for its accuracy, especially its hyperlocal data and real-time radar R65. However, a significant number of users report frequent app crashes and freezing R61R64R66R70. Many also experience issues with inaccurate forecasts, especially for rain and temperature R67R73R85.
Price & Value tieR1R4R9R15
WKYT FirstAlert Weather WKYT FirstAlert Weather is a free app, but users are frustrated by the overwhelming number of ads, which often precede critical weather information R1R4R9R19. Some ads are also considered inappropriate R15.
Weather Underground Weather Underground is a free app with in-app purchases, but users complain that many previously free features are now behind a paywall . The free version is considered 'unusable' due to excessive ads , and even paid users report still seeing ads . Some users also find the subscription model costly .
Customer Support & Updates tieR10R21R24R53
WKYT FirstAlert Weather Users report that WKYT FirstAlert Weather has not addressed long-standing issues, such as crashing, even after being contacted R10. Updates are sometimes seen as detrimental, causing the app to become unusable R21R24R53.
Weather Underground Weather Underground's support is described as non-existent, with users unable to submit bug reports due to technical issues R73. The app is also criticized for not receiving frequent updates or makeovers, leading to outdated features and persistent bugs .
Pick WKYT FirstAlert Weather if

Pick WKYT FirstAlert Weather if you prioritize accurate local forecasts and radar for storm tracking, and are willing to tolerate frequent ads to access free content R8R11R17.

Pick Weather Underground if

Pick Weather Underground if you value hyperlocal weather data from personal weather stations and detailed hourly precipitation forecasts, and are prepared to deal with frequent app crashes and potential inaccuracies R65.

Evidence note: Both apps have a significant number of negative reviews, particularly regarding app stability and accuracy. WKYT's high lifetime rating seems to be at odds with many recent negative reviews, suggesting a decline in user satisfaction. Weather Underground's lower lifetime rating is more consistent with its current user feedback.

Frequently asked

Are there many ads in WKYT FirstAlert Weather?
Yes, WKYT FirstAlert Weather has a significant number of ads, with users reporting that they often have to watch several minutes of ads before accessing weather information or alerts R1R4R9R19.
Is Weather Underground accurate?
Weather Underground's accuracy is mixed; some users find it highly accurate, especially for hyperlocal data from personal weather stations R65, while many others report frequent inaccuracies in rain forecasts, temperature readings, and radar R67R73R85.
Does Weather Underground crash frequently?
Yes, Weather Underground is frequently reported to crash, freeze, or glitch by many users across multiple devices, making it unusable at times R61R64R66R70.
Are there widgets for these apps?
WKYT FirstAlert Weather users report that there is no widget available for iPhone R50, while Weather Underground users also frequently request widgets for iPhone and note their absence R99R104R116.

What reviewers actually said

Built only from these 120 real reviews (foreign ones translated). Superscripts jump to the quote here. Apple has no per-review links, so [ref] opens that app's reviews on the App Store.

  1. [R3] WKYT FirstAlert Weather 3/5 · US Okay: I am using this app cause previous one meant for a state below me no longer works for me although it did up until like 2-3 months ago. So this one’s local but it’s not the best. No alert options for lightening. Somehow I get alerts on ai version of ai person talking about something, so turned off all alerts. Last few days was not showing anything on radar not ANYWHERE even when zoomed out to
  2. [R7] WKYT FirstAlert Weather 1/5 · US Junk: Nothing to see unless it’s a live schedule viewing. I am fine with watching editions from earlier in the day but using iPhone17 nothing ever plays except for the ads that when done just go to a blank screen. Reminds me of the app on firestick. Something has changed and I can’t watch previous newscasts anymore only small little clips? Who wants to do that day in and out. Lex18 has been more
  3. [R8] WKYT FirstAlert Weather 5/5 · US Great Weather Information: I really enjoy the great features. The Radar and the updates and hour by hour are really good.
  4. [R11] WKYT FirstAlert Weather 5/5 · US Weather watcher: I enjoy the weather app because I can check the weather any time of day or night. It’s also great for tracking storms.
  5. [R1] WKYT FirstAlert Weather 1/5 · US Keeps Getting Worse: Just got alert about upcoming forecast at 11:00 am. Turned on the app for 3 minutes of ads prior to 11:00. It’s 11:03 and still in ads/music mode. Just closed the app. Worthless would be giving undo credit.
  6. [R2] WKYT FirstAlert Weather 4/5 · US Great weather app: No nonsense info so far the best!
  7. [R4] WKYT FirstAlert Weather 1/5 · US Ads: So many ads I cannot get to the weather!!
  8. [R9] WKYT FirstAlert Weather 3/5 · US Too many ads: I want a weather forecast… but am forced to watch irrelevant ads.
  9. [R10] WKYT FirstAlert Weather 1/5 · US Glitching App: App is pretty much unusable 90% of time. As soon as you click on the app it will open and then glitch and go back to home screen within 5 seconds. My app is updated and actually experiences this glitch on multiple devices. I’ve reached out to WKYT Facebook page a year ago and they said they would pass it along to their IT team but the app is still doing it. I love WKYT weather and w
  10. [R16] WKYT FirstAlert Weather 1/5 · US Inaccurate Radar: Don’t trust the radar on this one. Very inaccurate in comparison to TWC.
  11. [R17] WKYT FirstAlert Weather 5/5 · US AWSOME: This app is good for telling you the most accurate weather forecast and will help you get dressed in the mornings.
  12. [R15] WKYT FirstAlert Weather 3/5 · US App works / Too many TEMU ads: The app itself functions as expected. However, I’m tired of seeing ads from whatever TEMU is with women’s breasts all over the place. It’s ridiculous! Please remove them.
  13. [R21] WKYT FirstAlert Weather 3/5 · US Bad update: I updated my app today and now it won’t open. I’ve done all the usual tricks and nothing works.
  14. [R24] WKYT FirstAlert Weather 3/5 · US Retract the update: I went to this app because it was easy to use after WLEX had updated there app. Now this one is terrible. It has been deleted
  15. [R53] WKYT FirstAlert Weather 1/5 · US Not a weather app anymore.: I used this app for years. Constant problems now since the last update. Going back to WLEX weather app.
  16. [R19] WKYT FirstAlert Weather 1/5 · US Don’t rely on this app: This app makes you watch a 20 second ad before you can even watch the alert that was just issued. If someone happened to open it when those 20 seconds mattered I guess WKYT and WYMT wouldn’t mind as long as they get their ad funding!
  17. [R65] Weather Underground 5/5 · US Best app: I have no idea what people are talking about when they say there are a lot of glitches. It’s extremely accurate and has never been wrong for me. It’s also very easy to hook up your weather station to and it helps weather be more accurate.
  18. [R67] Weather Underground 1/5 · US Worse app: It’s raining a lot and the app shows a sunny day LOL
  19. [R73] Weather Underground 1/5 · US Used to work now it is never accurate no support available: I used to rely exclusively on this app for my weather and temperature information. For the last month or so it has been showing that it is always 20 degrees less than the actual temperature. I tried to send a message to support but it will not allow me to upload the required screenshots for the report. If you aren’t able to upload the s
  20. [R85] Weather Underground 2/5 · US Totally worthless in Florida!: Predicts 100% chance of rain, then nothing. Predicts 15% chance of rain, and all hell breaks loose. Totally worthless when dealing with pop-up thunderstorms.
  21. [R61] Weather Underground 2/5 · US CRASHING: THIS APP CRASHES A LOT
  22. [R64] Weather Underground 1/5 · US Low Quality App: It crashes on a dime, and generally over nothing
  23. [R66] Weather Underground 3/5 · US Best weather app, Crashes like windows: I love the horizontal scrolling daily and hourly forecast layout. The natural and correct layout. Most weather apps get this wrong. Easy navigation. Great radar maps. It crashes more often than Windows!
  24. [R70] Weather Underground 1/5 · US Constant crashes: App constantly freezes and crashes. Has followed me for years across multiple phones. Fix the app.
  25. [R50] WKYT FirstAlert Weather 4/5 · US Love it but: Most accurate radar in my experience but I’ve just switch to iPhone and there’s no widget for iPhone. Miss the widget
  26. [R99] Weather Underground 3/5 · US Good not best: The closest weather station is 1/4 mile away. That's good. The not so good, weathet underground does not have a widget, you always have to open the app and go to the map, enlarge the map and find the closest weather station to get the closest temperature.
  27. [R104] Weather Underground 4/5 · US Favorite: Been my favorite for years. I don’t see much in the way of glitches, but I do want to put it in my iPhone 13 widgets and it never shows up on the widget list so I can’t put it in my widgets which would make it more useful. I have tried everything.
  28. [R116] Weather Underground 5/5 · US Love the app need widgets: It’s my favorite weather app. The week is displayed with highs and lows and a precipitation graph. Super helpful for planning the week and ski days in winter. Would like to see high wind alerts/notifications. Having precipitation alerts/notifications would be helpful for days commuting on motorcycle.

Synthesized from 120 recent App Store reviews · updated July 2026 · View on the App Store