Verithiathe honest score on any app
Updated July 2026 · real, multi-region App Store reviews
Head-to-head

Idle Magic Academy vs Idle Heroes

Idle Magic Academy 4.8★ · Free + IAP 75
Winner Idle Magic Academy
Idle Heroes 4.8★ · Free + IAP 65

Idle Magic Academy is the better choice for players seeking a charming, Harry Potter-inspired idle game with responsive developers, while Idle Heroes caters to those who enjoy a more traditional, long-running idle RPG with frequent updates.

Full reviews: Idle Magic Academy · Idle Heroes

Idle Magic Academy offers an engaging, magic-themed idle experience, though players frequently report running out of new content and encountering bugs. Idle Heroes, while having a larger player base and frequent updates, faces criticism for its pay-to-win mechanics and issues with account management.

Head to head

Content & Progression tieR2R3R7R8
Idle Magic Academy Many players praise Idle Magic Academy's initial gameplay, finding it fun and addictive, especially for fans of magic or Harry Potter R17. However, a significant number of reviews highlight a lack of new content, with players reaching the end of available maps and waiting for updates for months R2R3R8R11. Some also find certain levels, like Winter Land, to be too difficult or slow to progress through R7.
Idle Heroes Idle Heroes is noted for having frequent updates that keep the game fun . Players appreciate the long-term engagement, with some playing for years . However, some users find the game becomes boring after a few months due to slow progression and a perceived pay-to-win structure, especially after level 100 R69.
Reliability & Bugs edge: Idle Magic AcademyR1R4R6R9
Idle Magic Academy Idle Magic Academy users frequently report app crashes, especially after reaching certain levels or updates R1R4R6. Some also experience glitches with specific game elements, such as shops not generating money or ads not loading for bonuses R9. However, developers are noted for being responsive and fixing issues R36R37.
Idle Heroes Idle Heroes has reports of the app not loading even with good connectivity and issues with accounts being lost or inaccessible after periods of inactivity R59R71. One user also reported a sign-up error with unreadable symbols . Some users also mention the app offloading itself, requiring a re-download .
Monetization & Value edge: Idle Magic AcademyR9R13R30R39
Idle Magic Academy Idle Magic Academy is free with in-app purchases. Players consider buying the ad-free option but are hesitant due to glitches and a lack of content R9R13R39. Some who purchased ad-free noted receiving fewer rewards R30. There's also a concern about the lack of account binding to safeguard purchases R13.
Idle Heroes Idle Heroes is frequently criticized as being 'pay to win' R51R69. Users feel constantly prompted for money in almost every menu R56. While some claim it's not strictly pay-to-win due to available codes and that VIP players are only slightly faster , the sentiment of needing to spend to keep up is strong R51R69.
Support & Account Management edge: Idle Magic AcademyR13R36R37R57
Idle Magic Academy Idle Magic Academy is praised for its responsive developers who fix reported issues R36R37. However, there's a notable lack of in-game support and no option for account binding to save progress across devices R13.
Idle Heroes Idle Heroes has severe issues with account management, with users reporting permanent bans after requesting refunds R57R60 and accounts disappearing after periods of inactivity R59R71. There is no mention of responsive developer support in the reviews.
Overall Experience & Engagement tieR2R7R14R17
Idle Magic Academy Idle Magic Academy is highly addictive and enjoyable for many, especially those who like magic or Harry Potter themes R17. The graphics are also appreciated . However, the game can become boring and tedious once content runs out R2R7R14.
Idle Heroes Idle Heroes is described as addictive and very fun by many players . The graphics are also highlighted as good . However, some find it boring or too slow without spending money .
Pick Idle Magic Academy if

You enjoy magic-themed idle games, appreciate responsive developers who fix bugs, and prefer a game with less aggressive monetization, even if it means waiting for new content R17R36.

Pick Idle Heroes if

You prefer a long-running idle RPG with frequent updates, are comfortable with a 'pay-to-win' element, and enjoy collecting heroes and engaging in a game that can be played for years .

Evidence note: Idle Magic Academy has fewer reviews but a higher proportion of detailed feedback, especially regarding content limitations and bugs. Idle Heroes has a much larger volume of reviews, with many being very short and less descriptive, making it harder to extract specific insights beyond general sentiment and common complaints about monetization and account issues.

Frequently asked

Does Idle Magic Academy have enough content?
Many players report that Idle Magic Academy is fun and addictive initially, but they frequently reach the end of available content and maps, leading to boredom while waiting for updates that can take months R2R3R8R11.
Is Idle Heroes a pay-to-win game?
Many users describe Idle Heroes as 'pay to win,' especially if you want to keep up with the meta or progress faster after reaching higher levels R51R69. The game is noted for frequently asking for money in various menus R56.
Are there account issues with Idle Heroes?
Yes, several users report significant account issues with Idle Heroes, including accounts being permanently banned after requesting refunds for in-app purchases, and accounts disappearing or becoming inaccessible after periods of not playing R57R59R60R71.
Does Idle Magic Academy have good developer support?
Idle Magic Academy's developers are noted for being responsive and fixing reported issues, with some users praising them for addressing bugs after leaving reviews R36R37. However, there is no in-game support or account binding feature R13.

What reviewers actually said

Built only from these 100 real reviews (foreign ones translated). Superscripts jump to the quote here. Apple has no per-review links, so [ref] opens that app's reviews on the App Store.

  1. [R2] Idle Magic Academy 4/5 · GB When is the new maps going to be added?: I gave this game a 4/5 because you can only go so far before you are doing the same thing over and over. It’s a fun game and super easy to play but sadly it gets a bit boring and tedious after a while when you can’t progress. There is a new map called Shadow isles but it’s not loading and has been there for a while now, is there going to be any updates on
  2. [R3] Idle Magic Academy 3/5 · GB A lot fun but needs updating more often: I’ve had a lot of fun with this game but I’ve reached max and unlocked almost everything and have so many resources that are going unused. When is the 5th area being unlocked and please add plenty of updates or new things to use Holy Water/Orange Gems on
  3. [R7] Idle Magic Academy 1/5 · GB ?: Gra beznadziejna. O ile dwa poerwsze poziomy były ok, to trzeci poziom jest nie do przejścia. Nikt nie będzie spędzał długich tygodni, przyciskając w kółko dwa mniejsca, aby uzbierać na jeden element. Sala Wizard equipment zawsze po odpaleniu gry jest pusta, potem musze czekać pół godziny, aż napełni się uczniami. Co mam robić w tym czasie? W tej grze nie ma absolutnie nic do roboty. Absolutn
  4. [R8] Idle Magic Academy 5/5 · GB When is the last school open?: I’ve been playing this game for a long time and have maxed out everything on the first 4 maps and it’s been great. But for the longest time I’ve just gone into the game to see if the last map is open yet because I can’t do anything else. It’s a really cool game, perfect little idle adventure, but I am so ready for the last map!
  5. [R1] Idle Magic Academy 1/5 · GB Turning off: Bit disappointed get to a certain level and then when ever it loads up it crashes and the app closes tried reinstalling and still does the same after a certain level in game
  6. [R4] Idle Magic Academy 1/5 · GB Awful: I never really leave negative reviews but having said that, this game deserves it. I have no idea if this is a good game or not as every time I try and open the app, it crashes straight away. I have had it installed for three days and it keeps on doing the same thing.
  7. [R6] Idle Magic Academy 3/5 · GB I did love it but No longer works: App doesn’t open since the last update
  8. [R9] Idle Magic Academy 3/5 · GB Ad free: Was thinking of buying ad free but game ha a lot of glitches and can’t zoom in and out. Other than that good game I guess.
  9. [R13] Idle Magic Academy 1/5 · GB Essential updates?: Was about to make purchases but there is no way to safeguard them as no save progress to another device. Why is there no account binding? Also no support within game. Please don’t expect players to purchase packs until this is remedied.
  10. [R30] Idle Magic Academy 4/5 · GB Good game: Only been playing for a day but i am addicted. Its the first apple game i have purchased something inside the app. I did it so didnt have to keep watching ads to get money but since buying this i have had less rewards which is disappointing.
  11. [R39] Idle Magic Academy 4/5 · GB Great idle game but……: I wish they would add more things to do at the magic forest. You pay £8.99 for no ads and then it all goes pretty quickly from there and leaves you with nothing else to do just watch your money grow
  12. [R36] Idle Magic Academy 5/5 · GB Fab game, responsive developers!: Really good game! Cant wait to continue playing!! Would highly recommend 😁 Previously updated the game after playing for a while, unfortunately is kept freezing! Left a review saying my issue, developers have fixed the issue & let me know! Fantastic! I don't leave many reviews as most don't reply or listen to issues, so was nice to see 👍🏻 Perfect, keep up the go
  13. [R37] Idle Magic Academy 5/5 · GB The game doesn't work. ☹️ / It works! 🤗: After the last update V1.7, the game stopped loading. ☹️ Update: Thank you! With version 1.8, the game works again! 🤗 · translated
  14. [R57] Idle Heroes 1/5 · GB Game cancelled due to refund: Played this game for years and bought a add on pack and it didn’t seem to do what it promised so I requested a refund due to my rights of withdrawal. Refund processed and funnily enough the following day I have been denied access to my account. Very concerning and I will be reporting to Apple
  15. [R14] Idle Magic Academy 4/5 · GB Good/fun but…: I’ve basically done all there is to do, there’s nothing left and the last update was 3 months ago, any new content planned or should I just uninstall lol
  16. [R17] Idle Magic Academy 5/5 · GB Best idle game ever: I’ve played so many idle games but this was my favourite because I love things to do with magic or Harry Potter.I got so good in 5 minutes and also it’s very fun and exciting.I recommend this game to people who like Harry Potter and wizard movies or magic.
  17. [R11] Idle Magic Academy 5/5 · GB When will the last school on the map be added?: Really like this game. It’s by far the best idle game that I have played. But I am now on the last map and unlocked pretty much all that I can and when I looked at the map the next level just says Update coming soon and has been like that for months now. Please can you tell me when the next update will be so that I can finally move on to the last sch
  18. [R51] Idle Heroes 2/5 · GB Pay 2 win: Disgustingly pay 2 win if you want to keep up with the meta.
  19. [R56] Idle Heroes 3/5 · GB Okay I guess.: It's a good game, don't get me wrong, but I'd like it more if your money wasn't being asked for wherever you go. I would mind if it was in one menu but it's in almost every single one. It's fine if you somehow ignore it.
  20. [R69] Idle Heroes 2/5 · GB Less than Meh: Started it, it was fun but after a few months it got boring because it was okay to win. After level 100 progress slows down a lot and is mainly about pay2win
  21. [R59] Idle Heroes 3/5 · GB Good game but one problem: I had many accounts that were some how just GONE after not playing for a while so that just seems kinda stupid, I want my account back.
  22. [R60] Idle Heroes 2/5 · GB Amazing until…: So I played this game for a while and I absolutely loved it. I was a f2P player and never spent money on mobile games. Then I asked my parents for a 4.99 pack and they said yes but later on as I hadn’t behaved they refunded the pack and I only found out the next morning a refund equals a permanent ban. If the devs read this please can I have my account back and change I not to a
  23. [R71] Idle Heroes 4/5 · GB Great game !: Amazing game, I really did love playing until i Lost my account !! i dont know what happened but i tried logging back in and i couldn’t get my account back :/ and i forgot my password too

Synthesized from 100 recent App Store reviews · updated July 2026 · View on the App Store