Verithiathe honest score on any app
Updated July 2026 · real, multi-region App Store reviews
Head-to-head

Magic vs MTG Life Counter App

Magic 4.7★ · Free + IAP 40
Winner MTG Life Counter App
MTG Life Counter App 4.6★ · Free + IAP 85

MTG Life Counter App is the superior choice for tracking life totals and managing game states due to its reliability and extensive customization, while Magic struggles with critical login issues and a degraded search function.

Full reviews: Magic · MTG Life Counter App

Magic, the official companion app, is plagued by frequent login problems and a recent downgrade to its advanced card search, making it frustrating for many users. In contrast, MTG Life Counter App is highly praised for its robust and customizable life tracking features, including support for various game modes and commander damage, despite a few minor bugs.

Head to head

Features edge: MTG Life Counter AppR2R3R6R9
Magic Magic offers features for event registration, a card database, and life tracking, but users report issues with the event locator not displaying shops or events reliably, and a significant downgrade to the advanced card search functionality has removed key filtering options and made it less useful R2R3R6R9. Some users also note that the app's tournament features are clunky and less versatile compared to other platforms R10.
MTG Life Counter App MTG Life Counter App is lauded for its comprehensive life tracking, supporting multiple game modes like Commander, Planechase, and Archenemy, and easily tracking commander damage, poison, and monarch tokens R84R90R92. Users appreciate the ability to customize backgrounds with commander art and other images . However, some recent reviews indicate a bug where commander damage doesn't visually update until other life changes occur R51R53, and a few users report issues with the card search feature not working on iPads .
Ease of Use edge: MTG Life Counter AppR8R10R41R45
Magic Magic is criticized for clunky and unintuitive navigation, frequent lags, and a messy layout R8R10R41. Users find the process of registering for local games cumbersome due to redirects and mailing list sign-ups R8. The recent changes to the advanced search have made it difficult to narrow down card searches, requiring users to sift through many cards R45.
MTG Life Counter App MTG Life Counter App is consistently praised for being easy to use, intuitive, and having a clean, functional design R90. Users highlight its streamlined interface and the straightforward tracking of life totals and commander damage R53R84. However, some users note issues with screen cut-outs on certain iPhones and incorrect mana symbols/colors .
Reliability edge: MTG Life Counter AppR1R3R4R7
Magic Magic suffers from severe reliability issues, with numerous reports of users being unable to log in, even after reinstalling the app or resetting passwords R1R7R13R18. The app frequently crashes, gets stuck in loading loops, or fails to progress past the launch screen, sometimes requiring reinstallation R4. The event locator also often fails to display information correctly on the first attempt R3.
MTG Life Counter App MTG Life Counter App is generally considered reliable, with many users describing it as a stable and functional app . However, there are recent reports of a bug where commander damage visuals do not update immediately R51R53. Some users also experienced the app not working offline or requiring a minimum iOS version, which rendered it unusable on older devices .
Price/Value edge: MTG Life Counter AppR14R42R92R95
Magic Magic is a free app with in-app purchases, but users express dissatisfaction with its value due to persistent bugs, downgraded features, and frequent ads R14. Some users feel the app's quality does not justify its official status, especially given its mandatory use for some events R42.
MTG Life Counter App MTG Life Counter App is highly valued by users because it is free and offers extensive features without ads R92R95R96R101. Users are often surprised by the quality and feature set available at no cost, considering it superior to other paid or ad-supported alternatives R95R96.
Support tieR13R49R51R53
Magic Users of Magic report a lack of effective support, with critical login issues persisting even after updates were supposedly released to fix them R13. There is also a complaint about the absence of a direct way to report bugs or complaints to the development team within the app R49.
MTG Life Counter App Reviews for MTG Life Counter App do not explicitly mention user support experiences. However, the presence of reported bugs, such as the commander damage visual delay and card search issues on iPads, suggests that some users are experiencing problems that may require developer attention R51R53.
Pick Magic if

Pick Magic if you absolutely need the official companion app for event registration and integration with Wizards of the Coast services, and are willing to tolerate significant reliability issues and a degraded card search function R7.

Pick MTG Life Counter App if

Pick MTG Life Counter App if you primarily need a reliable, feature-rich, and highly customizable life counter for various Magic: The Gathering game modes, especially Commander, and appreciate a clean, ad-free experience R84R90R95R96.

Evidence note: The reviews for Magic are heavily skewed towards negative recent experiences, particularly concerning login failures and search functionality changes, which may impact its lifetime rating. MTG Life Counter App has a strong positive sentiment, with most negative reviews pointing to specific, often fixable, bugs rather than fundamental flaws.

Frequently asked

Does Magic have a reliable card search feature?
No, Magic's card search feature has been significantly downgraded in recent updates, with users reporting the removal of key advanced filtering options, making it less effective and harder to find specific cards R6R9R12R15.
Can I track commander damage with MTG Life Counter App?
Yes, MTG Life Counter App supports tracking commander damage, along with other counters like poison and monarch tokens, making it suitable for various game modes R84R90. However, some users have reported a recent bug where the visual update for commander damage is delayed until other life changes occur R51R53.
Are there login issues with the Magic app?
Yes, many users of the Magic app report persistent and critical login issues, where they are unable to log in despite using correct credentials, resetting passwords, or reinstalling the app R1R7R13R18. These issues have prevented users from participating in events and using core app functionalities R7.
Is MTG Life Counter App free and ad-free?
Yes, MTG Life Counter App is praised by users for being completely free and having no ads, despite offering a rich set of features and customization options R92R95R96R101.

What reviewers actually said

Built only from these 110 real reviews (foreign ones translated). Superscripts jump to the quote here. Apple has no per-review links, so [ref] opens that app's reviews on the App Store.

  1. [R2] Magic 4/5 · US Cards not in the system: Super convenient for deck building but I don’t understand why secret lair cards don’t show up in the database and some of the options in the advanced search don’t yield any results, such as rooms.
  2. [R3] Magic 3/5 · US Issue with locator: Every time I open the app and I go to the locator, nothing appears. I have to close the app and immediately reopen the app, go to the locator, and only then Will shops and events show up. Can you fix this?
  3. [R6] Magic 3/5 · US Restore Card Versions: Why in the world would you make the app have less functionality? I really miss seeing all versions of a card once I have looked it up. Bring that feature back. Also, in advance search allow users to quickly filter out digital only versions.
  4. [R9] Magic 3/5 · US Why: Hey uh I agree with the other person. The old advanced search was better than this new one. Please bring it back. If you do I will edit this review and give 5 stars
  5. [R8] Magic 5/5 · US Messy: Messy layout. Frequent redirects to websites, added to a mail list.. I just want to register for my local game.. why all the trickery?
  6. [R10] Magic 2/5 · US wish is was better: navigation is clunky and unintuitive, frequently lags out loading matches etc. could be great with some focus on the tournament / play features.
  7. [R41] Magic 4/5 · US Artifact- app, common 0️⃣: Works well for tracking games, and it’s essential for joining events at your local retailer, but it would be nice if it allowed you to tap & hold for life gain/loss rather than having to repeatedly tap for each point. And looking up cards is rather clunky, you can’t see both faces of dual-sided cards and the advanced search isn’t as easy as Scryfall or Archidekt.
  8. [R45] Magic 1/5 · US New search is trash: The old search functions were a lot better and easier to find keywords. This new search function makes it really hard to narrow down your search. What used to give about 80 searches now makes it to where you HAVE to sift through 2000 cards.
  9. [R1] Magic 2/5 · US I can’t log in: I’ve been using the app for years but it won’t let me log in now. I deleted and redownloaded the app and it is still broken
  10. [R4] Magic 1/5 · US Recognize Your Union: Wizards companion app is not a great app. Crashes a bit but the real issue is wizards of the coast would rather pay for union busters rather than invest into their work force
  11. [R7] Magic 1/5 · US Can’t Log In: I’m at the Regional Championship attempting to play side events and I cannot log in to the app. When I enter my username and password it very briefly loads and then nothing happens. This app ruined my day.
  12. [R14] Magic 4/5 · US Overall good: Good for keeping track of games and events but too many ads
  13. [R42] Magic 1/5 · US Badly designed app: Unfortunately, it’s mandatory to use this stupid app. It loses track of you, dropping you out at times. You also have to sign back in every couple of weeks.
  14. [R92] MTG Life Counter App 5/5 · US Seems great and completely free with no ads?: Love all the features. There’s counters for everything. There’s even a little monarch token you can drag to whichever player has the special hat.
  15. [R95] MTG Life Counter App 5/5 · US Best FREE commander app: My group used carbon for years until a friend insisted we try lotus. It’s free and NO ADS 😲 huge A+. All the features it provides, for the price you cannot beat it!
  16. [R13] Magic 1/5 · US Won’t let me login: I’ll type in my email and password, tap the login button, nothing happens. I’ve reset my password too, nothing changes and I always get the same result. There was supposed to be an update in order to fix it, got the update and nothing happened, login still doesn’t work.
  17. [R49] Magic 2/5 · US Advance Search Issues: App has completely nerfed the ability to use keyword search functions in the card advance search lookup. Additionally, app has literal ads for product but not a single way to report bugs or complaints directly to the development team.
  18. [R51] MTG Life Counter App 1/5 · US Bug makes this app nearly unusable…kinda: Recently it stopped working well. Whenever someone takes commander damage, the app doesn’t visually show the damage, until more damage or health is gained,lost. So what happens, player takes commander damage. Then we have to add 1 and subtract 1 of normal damage to get it to update. It’s such an inconvenient thing where I’m exploring another App. Reinstall
  19. [R53] MTG Life Counter App 3/5 · US New Bugs: Please update the app. It is great and very streamlined but there is a current issue with adding commander damage that doesn’t update until you change life totals manually.
  20. [R12] Magic 3/5 · US Please bring back the old advanced search options: I would give five stars but you actually made the advanced search function substantially worse with this new update. I don't understand removing the 'or' option, let alone removing the option to have multiple things selected on any one box. The worst change you made was to the rules text box itself. There are too many card effects in general for u
  21. [R15] Magic 3/5 · US New search function is subpar: I used to use this app daily. This recent update to the search functionality removed key features that allowed for custom search options. Now it's super basic and pretty useless. Bring back the custom search parameters.
  22. [R84] MTG Life Counter App 5/5 · US Best Life App I’ve Found: I love that this app supports so many features such as plane chase and arch enemy. Tracking Commander damage is easy as pie, and I love the death quotes that pops up when a player lose this game. I’ve also use this app to track points for other games.
  23. [R90] MTG Life Counter App 5/5 · US The Only Counter You Need: one of the best and most intuitive counters for any MTG game style you are playing! My group loved to use the commander counter settings, load our backgrounds with the commanders we are using, even toggle to different game modes if we are waiting something crazy for our game. This app packs so much and is ready-to-go for old and new MTG players alike!! This app needs to
  24. [R18] Magic 1/5 · US Cant log in: Still cant log in due to issues with the app. I can log in to every other service just fine even after multiple password resets
  25. [R96] MTG Life Counter App 5/5 · US Feature Rich and Elegantly Designed: Probably the only app I’ve found for an MTG life counter that is both fully featured and visually appealing. I don’t understand why this app is free.
  26. [R101] MTG Life Counter App 5/5 · US Best life total app: Doesn’t get any better than this, absolutely no ads and the best layouts available.

Synthesized from 110 recent App Store reviews · updated July 2026 · View on the App Store