Verithiathe honest score on any app
Updated July 2026 · real, multi-region App Store reviews
Head-to-head

Magic vs EA SPORTS FC™ 26 Companion

Magic 4.7★ · Free + IAP 75
Winner Magic
EA SPORTS FC™ 26 Companion 3.4★ · Free + IAP 35

Choose Magic for a more reliable experience despite some flaws.

Full reviews: Magic · EA SPORTS FC™ 26 Companion

Magic has a higher overall rating and offers more consistent functionality, although it has its share of login issues. EA SPORTS FC™ 26 Companion struggles significantly with user access and reliability, leading to a lower satisfaction level among its users.

Head to head

features edge: MagicR2R11R12R55
Magic Users appreciate Magic's deck-building convenience and event tracking, but they express frustration about missing card data and search functionality R2R11R12.
EA SPORTS FC™ 26 Companion EA SPORTS FC™ 26 Companion users enjoy features like squad management and card packs, but many find the app's functionality severely lacking, often unable to access key features like the transfer market R55R60.
ease of use edge: MagicR10R3R14R51
Magic Magic users report clunky navigation and frequent login issues, but some find it manageable for tracking games R10R3R14.
EA SPORTS FC™ 26 Companion EA SPORTS FC™ 26 Companion users frequently complain about login problems and app bugs, making it difficult to use effectively R51.
reliability edge: MagicR1R7R16R60
Magic Magic has faced criticism for login failures and crashes, but users still find it usable during events R1R7R16.
EA SPORTS FC™ 26 Companion EA SPORTS FC™ 26 Companion users report frequent crashes and inability to log in, leading to a frustrating experience overall R60.
price/value edge: MagicR5R19R64R92
Magic Magic offers a free tier with in-app purchases, which many users find reasonable for the features provided R5R19.
EA SPORTS FC™ 26 Companion EA SPORTS FC™ 26 Companion is also free with in-app purchases, but users often feel they are not getting value for their time and money due to the app's issues R64R92.
support edge: MagicR4R12R51R62
Magic Magic users have noted a lack of responsiveness to feature requests and bugs, but some still find the app enjoyable R4R12.
EA SPORTS FC™ 26 Companion EA SPORTS FC™ 26 Companion users express frustration over poor support and unresolved issues, leading to dissatisfaction R51R62.
Pick Magic if

you want a more reliable app for tracking games and events, despite some navigation issues.

Pick EA SPORTS FC™ 26 Companion if

you are a dedicated player of the EA SPORTS FC series and are willing to deal with significant app issues.

Evidence note: Magic's reviews indicate a mix of usability and reliability issues, but overall, users still find it functional. EA SPORTS FC™ 26 Companion has a higher volume of critical reviews, particularly regarding its login and functionality problems.

Frequently asked

Which app is better for tracking card games?
Magic is better for tracking card games, with a lifetime rating of 4.69 compared to EA SPORTS FC™ 26 Companion's 3.38, indicating higher user satisfaction and reliability despite some complaints about navigation and login issues.

What reviewers actually said

Built only from these 100 real reviews (foreign ones translated). Superscripts jump to the quote here. Apple has no per-review links, so [ref] opens that app's reviews on the App Store.

  1. [R2] Magic 4/5 · US Cards not in the system: Super convenient for deck building but I don’t understand why secret lair cards don’t show up in the database and some of the options in the advanced search don’t yield any results, such as rooms.
  2. [R11] Magic 5/5 · US Good app could be better: I would like to see this app used primarily for all tournaments (big or small) and provide more usability and functionality. Many other tournaments use melee and other apps that are a bit better and more versatile.
  3. [R12] Magic 3/5 · US Please bring back the old advanced search options: I would give five stars but you actually made the advanced search function substantially worse with this new update. I don't understand removing the 'or' option, let alone removing the option to have multiple things selected on any one box. The worst change you made was to the rules text box itself. There are too many card effects in general for u
  4. [R55] EA SPORTS FC™ 26 Companion 5/5 · US At least in this app I am actually able to get in and see how my players are selling, SBC, and EVOS: Fun.👍
  5. [R10] Magic 2/5 · US wish is was better: navigation is clunky and unintuitive, frequently lags out loading matches etc. could be great with some focus on the tournament / play features.
  6. [R3] Magic 3/5 · US Issue with locator: Every time I open the app and I go to the locator, nothing appears. I have to close the app and immediately reopen the app, go to the locator, and only then Will shops and events show up. Can you fix this?
  7. [R14] Magic 4/5 · US Overall good: Good for keeping track of games and events but too many ads
  8. [R51] EA SPORTS FC™ 26 Companion 1/5 · US Just awful: I can’t ever log into my web app even if I sign out of my console and it will constantly tell me I’m signed in when I’m not. Their communication and actual help sucks. They literally don’t care because they have the same problem for months and don’t do anything about it
  9. [R1] Magic 2/5 · US I can’t log in: I’ve been using the app for years but it won’t let me log in now. I deleted and redownloaded the app and it is still broken
  10. [R7] Magic 1/5 · US Can’t Log In: I’m at the Regional Championship attempting to play side events and I cannot log in to the app. When I enter my username and password it very briefly loads and then nothing happens. This app ruined my day.
  11. [R16] Magic 1/5 · US Barely able to use it: Every time I try to launch the app after participating in my first In person event the app opens into the Play tab and goes into loops trying to load the last match of the event, might be unable to participate in future events if it’s not fixed.
  12. [R60] EA SPORTS FC™ 26 Companion 1/5 · US App is broken: the whole app is bugged out this app is not worth it
  13. [R5] Magic 5/5 · US Yuva: Was really fun staff and owners are always nice
  14. [R19] Magic 5/5 · US Works fine: Works fine
  15. [R64] EA SPORTS FC™ 26 Companion 1/5 · US Dishonest Company: I still cannot access the Ultimate Team account on Web or Companion App, even though I have completed all requirements listed by EA. Not only that, but in order to complete these prerequisites, I had to play the game for so long that the Steam platform would no longer let me ask for a refund. This seems like fraudulent behavior to me.
  16. [R92] EA SPORTS FC™ 26 Companion 1/5 · US Been playing non stop for over 5 months: I’ve been playing non stop and it seems like it’s impossible to pack any cards other than from packs in store. I’ve done over 1000 sbc and yet to pull a decent card. Sad sad sad that they want you to spend money to keep up with players that do
  17. [R4] Magic 1/5 · US Recognize Your Union: Wizards companion app is not a great app. Crashes a bit but the real issue is wizards of the coast would rather pay for union busters rather than invest into their work force
  18. [R62] EA SPORTS FC™ 26 Companion 1/5 · US Not able to login: I tried everything to login and make an account on this app it wouldn’t let me so now I just gave up after having this app for about 2 years wasted of money

Synthesized from 100 recent App Store reviews · updated July 2026 · View on the App Store