Verithiathe honest score on any app
Updated July 2026 · real, multi-region App Store reviews
Head-to-head

stoic. mental health journal vs Reflectly

stoic. mental health journal 4.8★ · Free + IAP 80
Winner stoic. mental health journal
Reflectly 4.6★ · Free + IAP 70

Stoic. mental health journal is generally preferred for its comprehensive features and effectiveness in promoting mental well-being, despite some recent user frustration with its free tier and subscription pushes.

Full reviews: stoic. mental health journal · Reflectly

Stoic. mental health journal offers a robust set of tools for journaling, reflection, and meditation, with many users praising its positive impact on their mental health and consistency. Reflectly's reviews are not provided, so a direct comparison of user sentiment is limited, but Stoic's recent negative reviews highlight issues with its free version and aggressive monetization.

Head to head

Features and Content edge: stoic. mental health journalR1R8R9R18
stoic. mental health journal Stoic. is praised for its comprehensive features, including daily intentions, reflections, meditation timers, prompts, and customization options R8. Users find it helpful for ADHD, mood regulation, and addiction recovery R18. However, some recent reviews note the removal of widgets and the addition of 'AI slop' R1. Some users also desire more diverse prompts and additional features like fun tests or mood rings R9.
Reflectly No reviews for Reflectly were provided, so a comparison of its features and content based on user feedback is not possible.
Ease of Use and User Experience edge: stoic. mental health journalR3R5R8R10
stoic. mental health journal Many users find Stoic. to be simple, easy to understand, and navigate, helping them maintain a consistent journaling practice R5R8. It's described as a 'seamless and friendly approach' R5. However, some users find the app overwhelming due to 'too many ideas' and constant pushes to upgrade R3R10. First-time users report being hit with popups, paywalls, and rating requests constantly within the first few minutes R10.
Reflectly No reviews for Reflectly were provided, so a comparison of its ease of use and user experience based on user feedback is not possible.
Reliability and Performance edge: stoic. mental health journalR17R22R43R45
stoic. mental health journal Long-term users report that Stoic. has improved over the years and is a reliable tool R22R43. Recent updates have quickly fixed launch bugs and other issues R45R48. However, one user noted that the desktop version for Windows does not do much and doesn't sync well R17.
Reflectly No reviews for Reflectly were provided, so a comparison of its reliability and performance based on user feedback is not possible.
Price and Value tieR1R6R7R10
stoic. mental health journal Stoic. offers a free version, but many users express frustration that it has become too basic and not worthwhile unless upgrading to premium R6R7. There are complaints about constant subscription prompts and features being locked behind a paywall R1R7R10. Some users feel it's unethical to charge for mental health tools . One user reported being charged $100 after a trial and being denied a refund R12. Despite this, some users find value in the premium version and appreciate that many features are still available for free .
Reflectly No reviews for Reflectly were provided, so a comparison of its price and value based on user feedback is not possible.
Support and Ethics tieR4R12R16R48
stoic. mental health journal Stoic. has received praise for its support team and quick developer responses to issues R48R49. However, there are serious concerns about the app's ethics, including not allowing account deletion R4, denying refunds for unwanted subscriptions R12, and the AI being biased and discriminatory towards LGBTQ users R16.
Reflectly No reviews for Reflectly were provided, so a comparison of its support and ethics based on user feedback is not possible.
Pick stoic. mental health journal if

You are looking for a comprehensive journaling and mental health app with a wide range of features for reflection, intention setting, and meditation, and you are willing to pay for a premium subscription to unlock its full potential . You value an app that can help with consistency in journaling, ADHD, or mood regulation R18.

Pick Reflectly if

Reflectly's reviews are not available, so it's not possible to recommend it based on user feedback.

Evidence note: The comparison is heavily skewed towards Stoic. mental health journal as no user reviews were provided for Reflectly. Therefore, all 'B_take' sections state that no reviews were available, and 'edge' decisions are based solely on Stoic.'s user feedback.

Frequently asked

Is Stoic. mental health journal truly free to use?
Stoic. mental health journal offers a free version, but many users report that it is now very basic and not worthwhile unless upgrading to a premium subscription R6R7. Many features are locked behind a paywall, and users frequently encounter prompts to subscribe R1R7R10.
Does Stoic. mental health journal offer good support?
Stoic. mental health journal has received praise for its support team and developers who quickly respond to and fix issues R48R49. However, some users have reported negative experiences, such as being denied refunds for unwanted subscriptions R12.
Are there any concerns about Stoic. mental health journal's AI features?
Yes, some users have expressed significant concerns about Stoic. mental health journal's AI, with one review stating it is 'biased and bad for LGBTQ users' and 'discriminatory' R16.

What reviewers actually said

Built only from these 50 real reviews (foreign ones translated). Superscripts jump to the quote here. Apple has no per-review links, so [ref] opens that app's reviews on the App Store.

  1. [R1] stoic. mental health journal 1/5 · US Removed Functionality, added AI slop: Deleted many widgets (namely the quote widget), added AI slop integration and locked other features behind paywall.
  2. [R8] stoic. mental health journal 5/5 · US Simple and powerful: Great tool for daily intentions and reflections. Love the customization.
  3. [R9] stoic. mental health journal 3/5 · US Good app. Prompts repeat.: I like the app. It does encourage me to be more diligent with my journaling. It would be nice if the prompts didn’t repeat so often.
  4. [R18] stoic. mental health journal 5/5 · US Best journaling for ADHD: This helps me to stay on track with journaling and checking in with myself and how I feel. It makes it an easy task and gives me a win each time I complete an entry. It makes it feel attainable and then helps me feel better.
  5. [R3] stoic. mental health journal 3/5 · US Could be great: I want to like this app but there is so much going on that it’s overwhelming. Too many ideas, exploration page, create your own template but it’s not really a template and let’s not forget the constant push to upgrade to “premium”. I do think it has useful features but I can’t get past all of the other stuff. I just want to document my feelings in a journal and have better de-stres
  6. [R5] stoic. mental health journal 5/5 · US Great app!: I am grateful for this app. It is a great partner in maintaining a consistent journal. Improving mental health takes time and energy, and this app is a seamless and friendly approach to that lifelong pursuit.
  7. [R10] stoic. mental health journal 1/5 · US Subscription Spam Kills UX: As a first-time user who just wanted to learn more about and explore the app, the first five or ten minutes with it was awful and frustrating. I just wanted to see the interface and determine whether or not I might like it. Instead, I got hit with a bunch of popups, subscription paywalls, rating requests, and more *constantly* within the first five minutes, to the
  8. [R17] stoic. mental health journal 5/5 · US Love it: I just wish the desktop version for windows was decent. It doesn’t do much of anything and doesn’t really sync well
  9. [R22] stoic. mental health journal 4/5 · US Only one thing holding back from 5⭐️: Okay, I’ve had this app for a little over 3 years. And it’s incredible. I remember wanting to be able to write down what I was actually thinking/feeling; However, it has become some so much more than just a hobby or way to organize my thoughts ( though it’s pretty good for those too). I use stoic so much and it’s so freaking good. I feel better every time
  10. [R43] stoic. mental health journal 5/5 · US The one and only: Been using for literal years, not a single complaint, does everything I need it to and more, gives quotes and offers nice prompts for reflection, if this app ever shut down genuinely don’t know what I would do ❤️ been using since 2022
  11. [R45] stoic. mental health journal 5/5 · US The app was quickly updated!: Thank you for promptly updating the app!
  12. [R6] stoic. mental health journal 3/5 · US Free Version ain’t it: I had this many years ago and the free version was still great! It’s frustrating how it now is so basic and not worthwhile unless you have premium.
  13. [R7] stoic. mental health journal 1/5 · US All about the $: I was under the impression I could use what I felt necessary and each time a new prompt showed up, the end result was signing up for a subscription. If you don’t decline the prompts (even the simple questions you think are designed to help you), I the next page is something else asking for money. I checked this app out for my kid but I will not suggest it for him.
  14. [R4] stoic. mental health journal 2/5 · US The app locks you in: Doesn’t let you delete your account
  15. [R12] stoic. mental health journal 1/5 · US Did not want to extend trial. Does not give refunds.: I wanted to try it out. I never used the app. They charged me $100 and will not give a refund. They say oh it’s not our fault because Apple handles al the billing. We can’t do anything about it. That is BS, unethical and terrible business practice.
  16. [R16] stoic. mental health journal 1/5 · US AI is biased and bad for LGBTQ users: The AI is horrible for LGBTQ users. An app all about journaling, where LGBTQ users often need it more, shouldn’t be discriminatory towards them. This is the last thing I want to be seeing in my journal, and it’s horrible for your mental health unless you’re a straight white Christian.
  17. [R48] stoic. mental health journal 5/5 · US Last update FIXED everything: Quick response by the developer to resolve an issue in the prior update!
  18. [R49] stoic. mental health journal 5/5 · US Love this app: Great app! Great support team!

Synthesized from 50 recent App Store reviews · updated July 2026 · View on the App Store