onWater alternatives
onWater users often seek alternatives due to frequent upgrade prompts, subscription issues, and buggy features. Alternatives like Fishbrain and Fishing Points offer different strengths, from community catch logs to detailed forecasts, catering to varied angler needs.
Why users look for alternatives to onWater
- Many users find the free version of onWater to be largely useless, with constant pop-ups and prompts to upgrade, making it difficult to even try the app.R1R4R7R23
- Users report significant issues with subscriptions, including being charged full price despite discounts, unexpected annual charges after free trials, and a lack of value for the money.R10R19R31R41
- Several features are described as buggy or inaccurate, such as the measurement tool, boat ramp locations, river mile measuring, and the alarm for approaching take-outs.R3R6R41
- Some users experience technical problems like the app crashing constantly, inability to log in or sign up, and the app not opening at all.R6R13R16
- The app is criticized for lacking detailed fishing information, especially for certain regions or fish species, with some users stating it's just a map with zero fish information or that it's not good for saltwater fishing.R15R21R25R33
The alternatives
Fishbrain is highly regarded as a 'cheat code' for fishing, with users praising its accurate BiteTime feature and the ability to view logged catches in specific spots R52. It helps anglers catch more fish and achieve personal bests R55.
Better for: Fishbrain is better for anglers who want to leverage community-logged catches and an accurate bite time forecast to improve their success, especially those looking to level up their fishing game R52R55. However, many of its best features are behind a paywall, costing around $155-$170 per year, and some users find the map poorly designed R53R54.
Head-to-head: onWater vs FishbrainFishbox is helpful for beginners, teaching them a lot and keeping them aware of the best times to fish . It offers great information, though some users note it needs refining in user experience R70.
Better for: Fishbox suits beginner anglers who appreciate guidance on fishing times and general information . However, many features, including fishing forecasts and spots, are now behind a subscription, and some users report issues with signing in or a lack of information for coastal fishing R67R68R71.
Head-to-head: onWater vs FishboxFishing Points is praised for its weather and fish activity forecasts, which help users know when to go fishing, and it does not constantly remind users to buy premium R80R83. It's also useful for logging catches and offers fish identification .
Better for: Fishing Points is ideal for anglers who prioritize accurate weather, fish activity, and tide information to plan their trips R80R83. It's also good for those who want to log their catches without constant pressure to upgrade R80. However, some users find it expensive, with many features locked behind a paywall, and report issues with depth charts R79R82.
Head-to-head: onWater vs Fishing PointsFishAngler is considered a great app for fishing, with users appreciating its accuracy, especially for weather and prime fishing times . It also allows users to talk to other anglers and track catches and fishing spots .
Better for: FishAngler is best for anglers who value community interaction, accurate weather and prime fishing time forecasts, and the ability to track their catches and spots . However, recent updates have placed seeing other people's catches behind a paywall, and some users report issues with crashing, signing in, and high annual costs of $80 R93R96R98R99.
Head-to-head: onWater vs FishAnglerFishing Spots is an amazing app that helps users find new fishing spots, even with its free version R115. It was previously praised for showing 'peak feeding times' and being useful for moon phase hunting and fishing R112.
Better for: Fishing Spots is suitable for anglers primarily looking to discover new fishing locations, especially those who appreciate a functional free tier R115. However, recent updates have moved features like peak feeding times and forecasts behind a paywall, making the app less user-friendly and leading to user frustration R112R114. Some users also report login issues R107.
Head-to-head: onWater vs Fishing SpotsYou should stick with onWater if you find its specific tools for monitoring stream conditions, recording route lines, tracking distances, and its journal option valuable for trip planning and logging key facts about spots . It is also highly recommended by some for exploring new fishing spots and learning about stream information, species, and locality .
Evidence note: No alternatives had too-thin evidence.
Frequently asked
What are the common complaints about onWater?
Is onWater worth the subscription cost?
What reviewers actually said
Built only from these 120 real reviews (foreign ones translated). Superscripts jump to the quote here. Apple has no per-review links, so [ref] opens that app's reviews on the App Store.
- [R1] onWater Useless: This app is useless as a free version. Just about every click it wants me to upgrade. Deleted it after two days.
- [R4] onWater Garbage: Can’t even try the app. As soon as you click on it it’s like a pop-up every one second.
- [R7] onWater Too many adds: Adds pop up constantly trying to get you to pay for upgrades. Deleted
- [R23] onWater Upgrade spam: Every time i click on something i get prompted to upgrade. Seems like all they care about is money.
- [R10] onWater Pointless: I signed up for OnWater and thought I had canceled my subscription, only to find out I was charged for a full year. While that was frustrating, the bigger issue is that the app simply isn’t worth the money. The most useful feature is locating nearby boat ramps. Beyond that, there isn’t much value that can’t be found for free through other fishing apps, state resources, weather services,
- [R19] onWater Charged full price on 50% off: I downloaded it and got the pop up to use for free, get premium, or pro. Premium was 49.99 per year and was too much for just getting the app but a pop up offered a one time 50% off coupon then 49.99 next year so I took it but my card shows it was charged the full price with tax of 51.91. Very very disappointed in this fraudulent bait and switch tactic. The contact u
- [R31] onWater Thief’s: Click on free trial and they still charged me for the year right away. What part of free trial is so hard. App sucks and was garbage. Worthless app and garbage people for the tricks to get you to try it and charge for it
- [R41] onWater Don’t do it: Not worth the money. Currently on year two of subscription hoping for improvements. The boat ramps aren’t accurate. River mile measuring feature isn’t accurate. Alarm for approaching take out doesn’t work. Not sure why I’m paying for anymore.
- [R3] onWater Pretty disappointed in measurement feature: You pay alot for this app and the one thing I need it for, measurement feature, is super buggy and rarely works. I’d change to a 5 star if this was fixed.
- [R6] onWater Great idea, poor execution: App crashes constantly while exploring the map and checking locations offered.
- [R13] onWater Can’t login or signup?: I was advertised this add on Facebook, I do a lot of fishing and thought I’d give it a chance. App downloaded fine, but if I try to login or register it just goes right back to the login page and the login buttons won’t work to Sign in with Apple or Google. The app is broken or something. It’s not my internet connection, or my phone, or anything like that, the app just simp
- [R16] onWater Fish: I can’t even get the app to open up.
- [R15] onWater Complaint: They need to have a thing where you’re able to show where the fish are what the fish are biting and how much the fish weigh
- [R21] onWater Useless: This is the most useless app I’ve ever seen. It literally is just a map with zero information about fish.
- [R25] onWater Would’ve gave it no stars if I could downloaded for high hopes but this app literally sucks most: Would’ve gave it no stars if I could downloaded for high hopes but this app literally sucks most of the body’s of water everywhere don’t have anything , and for 89 dollars a year this is pointless just use Fishbrain , shows you everything everywhere
- [R33] onWater No good for Florida: I fish the Indian River. This app must be just for freshwater fish. I don’t see ANYTHING like catch available. Save your money. I wish I could get a refund.
- [R52] Fishbrain Insane app: I shocked how good this app is it basically is a cheat code and has really helped me level up my game. Their BiteTime is actually very accurate and I’ve caught many more fish in days when the bitetime is high. Plus I love the fact you can check what people have logged in certain spots. This definitely deserves 5 stars.
- [R53] Fishbrain Good but pay to get most things: It is good but if you are going to travel you would need the pro witch is 170$ per year and it only tells you stuff on bluegill so you can’t look at bass or catfish without pro
- [R54] Fishbrain Everything is a paywall: Useless app unless you pay for the subscription
- [R55] Fishbrain App review: Great app helping me catch fish
- [R67] Fishbox Used to prefer this over Fishbrain: I’ve had this app for about a year if not a little longer, and loved it because of the fishing forecast it showed, now all of a sudden everything even where to go fishing is behind a subscription. It seemed like this happened overnight because I’ve even used these features this summer. I liked the forecast feature so much I used this over Fishbrain but reading o
- [R68] Fishbox Eh. Would not rebuy this app: Probably better for freshwater people. No one on the coast uses it, or logs catches. Has terrible ‘insight’ for coastal anglers, and doesn’t even have enough proper options for world famous local fish like striped bass, bluefish, tuna, Black Sea bass, etc. Like for selecting bait. Or where/when to fish. Very little saltwater info, will be politely asking for my $35
- [R70] Fishbox Great info needs refining: Great info and good enough to keep my premium subscription (for now) but need refining to UX
- [R71] Fishbox Bad: I tried signing in about 30 times it never let me sign in because apparently it couldn’t verify the verification code. I don’t know why it’s just stupid and I would not recommend buying this.
- [R79] Fishing Points Not what I was looking for: Don’t be like me and pay for a year to find out it’s not worth the money and doesn’t give proper depths and charts
- [R80] Fishing Points It’s good: The weather and fish activity make it very easy to know when to go fishing and I don’t need to spend money unless I want premium and they are never reminding me to buy premium its a very good app In general too.
- [R82] Fishing Points Pay to use: Not worth your time or money. Everything is locked behind a paywall.
- [R83] Fishing Points The best: This is the best app I’ve used and is really close to be 100 percent accurate
- [R93] FishAngler Terrible support: Talk about trash. These people claim to support veterans but when a vet accidentally was charged for a full year 59.99 for their app they wouldn’t even offer a refund after it was immediately deleted and u used. No customer service. They just blamed Apple. Apple isn’t the owner of the company. They are. They are a joke. Shame on you
- [R96] FishAngler Day 6 of trying to get past the sign in page: Cant sign in. Infinite loading screen. Fix it. Is this app abandoned or something?
- [R98] FishAngler My app keeps crashing: I can’t log in
- [R99] FishAngler Paywalls have ruined FishAngler: After years of contributing and using FishAngler as a community tool for anglers all over the world, the March 2026 update that paywalls seeing other peoples catches has killed the app for me. FishAngler still allows you to log your catches but now they own that data and sell it to other users as a ‘premium’ feature. I’m very sad to be deleting all my data and the
- [R107] Fishing Spots Junk. Don’t bother.: Can’t even get past the login screen. Tried signing up/logging in through Google, Apple, and then even tried to make a new account through my email. Every time it locks up or says authentication failed, even trying to make a new account. Gave up and deleted.
- [R112] Fishing Spots Could’ve been better: Was a great app Used to be able to see “peak feeding times” for free now they’ve updated the app and you have to be apart of their subscription
- [R114] Fishing Spots Now you gotta pay for a simple forecast: This was a fine & dandy app. Was able to check best feeding times for fish but now they’ve locked it behind a paywall. The forecast is confusing and not user friendly anymore. They’ve done got greedy and now this app sucks.
- [R115] Fishing Spots Amazing app: Even without paying it helps alot if you need to find new fishing spots
- [R12] onWater Yet Another Fishing App: Effectively useless free tier, when comparing premium offerings to other big players like Fishbrain, it’s hard to justify the similar cost. Either needs a different pricing model or something immediately differentiating it from other apps in this space. Essentially, it’s hard to see how this will help anyone catch more fish than competitors offerings.
- [R27] onWater Rug pull subscription: Have been a “premium” member since December and suddenly there are “Pro” features which are unavailable. In December there was no designation and Premium was the highest level subscription until it wasn’t. Wish i kept TroutRoutes. No i’m stuck in the annoying mid tier.
- [R34] onWater Great Service From Will: I emailed the team about a problem with the purchase function of the app. I had built a customized Abel reel through the onWater Blue Line design offering. Once I got to the purchase function it kept dumping me onto the Mayfly main page. Will answered quickly, investigated the issue, and performed an update to the app. He told me how to receive the update and it worke
- [R48] onWater Amazing resource!: onWater is an amazing resource for my fly fishing adventures. The guys are also super helpful and attentive to any messages on the app. Highly recommend onWater!
Synthesized from 120 recent App Store reviews · updated July 2026 · View on the App Store