Verithiathe honest score on any app
Updated July 2026 · real, multi-region App Store reviews
Head-to-head

Prodigy Math Game vs Epic

Prodigy Math Game 4.8★ · Free to download 45
Winner Epic
Epic 4.7★ · Free + IAP 60

Epic is a better choice for families seeking a broad digital library, despite its subscription model, while Prodigy Math Game struggles with aggressive monetization and technical issues that hinder its educational value.

Full reviews: Prodigy Math Game · Epic

Prodigy Math Game, while praised for making math fun, is heavily criticized for its aggressive paywalls, glitches, and forcing non-members into a disadvantaged experience. Epic, a digital reading platform, offers a vast library but faces similar complaints about its subscription model and occasional login issues, though its educational value is generally well-received.

Head to head

Educational Value edge: EpicR2R5R12R16
Prodigy Math Game Prodigy Math Game is appreciated for making math learning enjoyable and engaging, with users noting it helps with focus and teaches concepts like fractions R2R5R12. However, some find the math too easy for older grades or feel it's just a game with minimal educational content R16.
Epic Epic is widely praised for being an excellent educational tool that encourages reading and learning, offering a vast selection of books and even science videos . Users highlight its benefit for kids starting to read and its diverse content.
Monetization & Free Tier Experience tieR1R3R4R6
Prodigy Math Game Prodigy Math Game is heavily criticized for its aggressive pay-to-win model, with numerous users feeling that a membership is essential for a good experience, access to better pets, and progression R1R3R4R6. Non-members often feel limited, badgered by ads for memberships, and disadvantaged R1R4R6.
Epic Epic faces significant backlash for its subscription-based model, with many users feeling misled as the app is advertised as free but requires payment to access most content beyond previews R61R63R67R70. The free trial or school access is often contrasted with the paid home experience.
Reliability & Performance tieR1R3R9R19
Prodigy Math Game Prodigy Math Game users report frequent glitches, lag, and freezing, especially during battles R1R3. There are also significant issues with account management, including losing progress, not saving login information, and being logged out R9R19. Some users also note problems with updates not applying or changes in game style being unwelcome .
Epic Epic users experience issues with logging in, with the app frequently asking for credentials or stating no account exists despite having one R63. Some report books being cut off or not having full stories . There are also complaints about double charges and difficulty with subscription cancellations R85R109.
Content & Features edge: EpicR5R8R10R12
Prodigy Math Game Prodigy Math Game offers a fun, game-like experience with pets, battles, and quests, which keeps kids engaged R5R8R12. However, some users dislike recent updates, changes to game mechanics like pet leveling, the use of AI voices, and the removal of certain features R10.
Epic Epic boasts a wide variety of books, including popular series, and offers features like read-alongs and science videos . Users appreciate the breadth of content but some wish for more badges or specific books to be added . There are also complaints about forced reading times and restrictions on reading outside school hours .
Customer Support tieR40R60R85R109
Prodigy Math Game One user reported sending an email to support regarding usage tracking issues and never receiving a response R60. Another parent described a 'scam-level billing practice' with a year-long subscription renewal that charged them despite cancellation, with no indication of resolution through support R40.
Epic Epic support is criticized for pointing users back to Apple for refund requests instead of resolving double billing issues on their end R85. One user reported persistent attempts to charge them $85 even after removing the app and canceling the subscription R109.
Pick Prodigy Math Game if

you are looking for a game-based math learning tool and are willing to pay for a membership to unlock its full potential, or if your child's school uses it and provides access to the full features R8R12.

Pick Epic if

you want a vast digital library of books and educational videos for children and are prepared to pay for a subscription, especially if your child enjoys reading on devices .

Evidence note: Both apps receive significant criticism regarding their monetization strategies, with many users feeling that the 'free' aspect is misleading. The evidence for customer support is limited for both, with only a few reviews mentioning specific interactions or lack thereof.

Frequently asked

Is Prodigy Math Game truly free?
Prodigy Math Game is free to download and play, but many users report that the free version is severely limited, with essential features, better pets, and progression locked behind expensive memberships, making it feel like a 'pay-to-win' game R1R3R4R6.
Does Epic require a subscription?
Epic requires a subscription for full access to its library outside of school hours or a limited free trial; many users are frustrated that the app is advertised as free but then demands payment to read most books R61R63R67R70.
Are there technical issues with Prodigy Math Game?
Yes, users frequently report glitches, lag, freezing during battles, and problems with account management such as not saving login information, losing progress, and being logged out R1R3R9R19.

What reviewers actually said

Built only from these 120 real reviews (foreign ones translated). Superscripts jump to the quote here. Apple has no per-review links, so [ref] opens that app's reviews on the App Store.

  1. [R2] Prodigy Math Game 5/5 · US Great: It’s helping me learn better and I kinda teaches not to go that fast🫥
  2. [R5] Prodigy Math Game 5/5 · US It’s a good game to play: I love how it is a have fun and learn game u might like it
  3. [R12] Prodigy Math Game 3/5 · US Very fun: Prodigy has kept me busy for hours plus it’s very good for the mind and it teaches you like fractions and if you’re like in first grade or something. And if you’re in a school, you can get your password from your laptop at school or if you’re homeschool, you can download Prodigy and you can make up a name and if you’re at school, you just hook it up to your phone or tablet at home and th
  4. [R16] Prodigy Math Game 1/5 · US Gamified addictive trash: Title says it all. For kids who are good at math it’s just games with like 126+234=360 coming up every 15 min. Otherwise it’s completely trashy addictive games. I am in shock that schools opt into buying this for their curriculums. No wonder the US elementary education is in the toilet.
  5. [R1] Prodigy Math Game 2/5 · US Paywalls: It’s fun but to have an actually good time you have to pay for a stupid membership. Also it hits you with an ad every time you try to do something. I also keep getting stuck in some screens because I clocked off of a ad. This made me lose progress and made me unhappy
  6. [R3] Prodigy Math Game 3/5 · US Review: Glitchy and your character is very weak if you don’t get the membership but fun
  7. [R4] Prodigy Math Game 1/5 · US Why Prodigy is No Longer Fun: I used to play this game free version and get annoyed about the “get our membership” and be jealous of my friends who had them. I never asked my parents because I knew the answer would be no or pay yourself and I didn’t want to pay so I never did and stoped playing for a while then I came back a year later all of my ela prodigy gone and get our better memberships and
  8. [R6] Prodigy Math Game 3/5 · US Fun… but not.: This game has helped me focus on math a lot, but here are the issues. There are 3 ranks of memberships with different prices, which are expensive. If you don’t have any of the memberships, you get to have boring pets and a weaker team. This is really frustrating to me. The other thing having to do with this is that this is a kids game. This is a kids game, targeted towards kids,
  9. [R9] Prodigy Math Game 3/5 · US Kept having to log back in and lost all my data: This is a good app in all, but every time I opened the app it would not save my username in I saved it many times. Eventually it charged my mother for the membership and then eventually logged me out and I could not log back in, and lost all my data.👎🏾
  10. [R19] Prodigy Math Game 2/5 · US About my review: I loved it at the start, but then I had to be a member for everything basically. Then when I tried to log back in it’s like “Do you have an account or would you like to make an account” I already had one for me, but it wanted me to put in a code but I forgot it. So i lost A LOT of progress. If your going to make a game where you have to sign up save it. I dont understand why it do
  11. [R8] Prodigy Math Game 5/5 · US Teach tec: I love this in the classroom. It’s fun to do tournaments all Friday long win win situations
  12. [R10] Prodigy Math Game 1/5 · US Restore the Battle Arena: Bring back the battle arena or else
  13. [R40] Prodigy Math Game 1/5 · US DO NOT PURCHASE: Parent, here. App as a whole is fine. However, I got the notification of its YEAR-long subscription renewal on the day it renewed. Cancelled, but was still charged for the entire up coming year. The app stating it will end June 20, 2027. NOT OK. This is a scam-level billing practice.
  14. [R60] Prodigy Math Game 3/5 · GB No support response: We have issues with the app not tracking usage. Sent email to support and never heard back. The end. Old review: On iPad 7th Gen iOS 13.2 the latest app keeps hanging at a point where you need to choose a spell. It doesn’t hang fully coz you can toggle back to home screen for 10 seconds and go back in - then it works but then the sound is off. But then you can toggle one more
  15. [R85] Epic 2/5 · US Double charges: My kid genuinely loves Epic for the read-along books and craft videos, so I wanted this to work. But the billing has been a constant headache. For months I was charged twice for the same monthly subscription. Every time I caught it, I had to go request a refund through Apple myself. Epic support just pointed me back to Apple instead of fixing anything on their end. I finally bough
  16. [R109] Epic 1/5 · US Stop charging me: Please stop trying to charge me! I even removed the app from my phone. Never renewed or anything. I don’t even have you under my subscriptions, but you still continue trying to charge me $85. Please stop. Thank you.
  17. [R61] Epic 1/5 · US Not free: Subscription based. Only get book previews free. Be careful signing up it’s sneaky about subscribing.
  18. [R63] Epic 3/5 · US Amazing but one thing.: I love epic and they have great books for younger and older kids but one thing when you sign in you have to get a subscription. I had signed up and agreed with terms and stuff but yet it still told me it would only show previews of the books, even though I already got the subscription I keep doing it but it still does the same thing. It might be just me either way if it is
  19. [R67] Epic 1/5 · US Epic is NOT epic at all!: Epic is NOT epic at all! It doesn’t work when you try to get an account, try to get the “epic family” and it doesn’t let you read any books! It only lets you read five/5 pages of a book and then never lets you read anything else! I only had this app for about 30 seconds before it wouldn’t let me read anymore! 5 words: DO NOT GET THIS APP!
  20. [R70] Epic 1/5 · US BLUH: So bad im a amazing reader reader but when I got this app I deleted it because you,have to pay to use the app thats why i gave i star

Synthesized from 120 recent App Store reviews · updated July 2026 · View on the App Store