Prodigy Math Game vs Math Puzzle Games
Choose Math Puzzle Games for fewer ads and a more straightforward experience.
While both apps offer math-related gameplay, Math Puzzle Games generally provides a smoother experience with fewer complaints about ads compared to Prodigy Math Game's heavy reliance on membership and ads. Prodigy users often express frustration over paywalls and glitches, while Math Puzzle Games users appreciate the challenge despite ad interruptions.
Head to head
You prefer a game with more educational features and don't mind a paywall.
You want a simpler, ad-supported game that focuses on quick math puzzles.
Evidence note: Prodigy Math Game has a significant number of negative reviews regarding its monetization strategy, while Math Puzzle Games' complaints are mostly centered around ads.
Frequently asked
What reviewers actually said
Built only from these 120 real reviews (foreign ones translated). Superscripts jump to the quote here. Apple has no per-review links, so [ref] opens that app's reviews on the App Store.
- [R4] Prodigy Math Game Why Prodigy is No Longer Fun: I used to play this game free version and get annoyed about the “get our membership” and be jealous of my friends who had them. I never asked my parents because I knew the answer would be no or pay yourself and I didn’t want to pay so I never did and stoped playing for a while then I came back a year later all of my ela prodigy gone and get our better memberships and
- [R11] Prodigy Math Game There’s one Problem It’s just not fair: The game is pay to win and basically you need to grind so hard for good stuff while members can easily get stuff a lot easier plus they don’t have a limitation unlike non members and evolving stays and magic coins are kinda hard to get.
- [R61] Math Puzzle Games Not impressed: Too many damn ads!!!! No way to earn hints thus this game is overloaded with ads!! What a way to ruin a good game for keeping your brain sharp. Bye- bye.
- [R62] Math Puzzle Games All around: It’s great for brushing up math skills, and problem solving!
- [R9] Prodigy Math Game Kept having to log back in and lost all my data: This is a good app in all, but every time I opened the app it would not save my username in I saved it many times. Eventually it charged my mother for the membership and then eventually logged me out and I could not log back in, and lost all my data.👎🏾
- [R40] Prodigy Math Game Money grab: You literally can’t even play in the current season event without a membership. ANYTHING regarding upgrading pets to make progress in the game costs magicoin which is extremely difficult to obtain without a membership (which they have LEVELS to by the way) and they started making you watch ADS after EVERY BATTLE. This used to be a great educational tool for kids to have fun and learn m
- [R63] Math Puzzle Games Too many ads: The game itself is good! unfortunately there’s an obnoxious amount of ads on it that come up every time you move onto a new level and they’re about a minute or two each long.
- [R74] Math Puzzle Games Fun math puzzle BUT too many ads: Ads before and after every game. It’s a great way to train your brain but can only play one game before getting hit with an ad that you can’t get out of. So that’s annoying. I may delete and find something similar.
- [R48] Prodigy Math Game Good but buggy: Very buggy. Frequent issues like overlays popping up with the close X missing so you can’t close and have to kill the app. Or making progress and being told have gained a new spell, but then it’s not showing when you enter a battle. Other bugs through too, so quite frustrating to play in earnest.
- [R60] Prodigy Math Game Buggy: The idea of this game is great but it constantly crashes on Apple products. I’ve tried Mac, iPhone and iPad and every single one has him logged out regularly because of a white screen. It’s frustrating that it doesn’t save the username so he has to enter his username every time it crashes too ( capitals included so he gets it wrong every time and is upset). When his friends are online they
- [R75] Math Puzzle Games Great game but…..: The game is great. However, there’s a current glitch that doesn’t record your daily puzzle completion. In the app, there’s no way to access help or customer support. The customer support on this page just takes you to the game. Annoying and frustrating!!!
- [R117] Math Puzzle Games Is there a bug?: I only downloaded this a few days ago but there seem to be issues. The game, when you finally get to it is fine, however, if you make the mistake of watching a video for 30 coins, afterwards you get stuck on a screen that just says ‘Claim Rewards - 30 coins’ (screenshot available) but doesn’t let you get back to the next game. I had to close the game and reopen, which meant I had
- [R1] Prodigy Math Game Paywalls: It’s fun but to have an actually good time you have to pay for a stupid membership. Also it hits you with an ad every time you try to do something. I also keep getting stuck in some screens because I clocked off of a ad. This made me lose progress and made me unhappy
- [R25] Prodigy Math Game Prodigy Math Scam For Kids: I’ve tried to write reviews so long about why this game sucks, that my phone crashed. There are so many reasons why not to download it. The basic are, you used to have a good game, dedicated to making something boring fun. Then developers got greedy, and TECHNICALLY, you don’t have to pay to play. But TECHNICALLY, 90% of stuff now costs money, or requires money in order
- [R64] Math Puzzle Games Great Game, Awful Ads: There’s an ad after every single puzzle. And to get rid of ads it’s $7.99. Absolutely unreal.
- [R105] Math Puzzle Games Ads: It's fun but it has too many ads and if you wanna pay to get rid of them it's 8 dollars! The ads are pretty annoying it makes me not want to play anymore or find a different game with less ads
- [R54] Prodigy Math Game No support response: We have issues with the app not tracking usage. Sent email to support and never heard back. The end. Old review: On iPad 7th Gen iOS 13.2 the latest app keeps hanging at a point where you need to choose a spell. It doesn’t hang fully coz you can toggle back to home screen for 10 seconds and go back in - then it works but then the sound is off. But then you can toggle one more
Synthesized from 120 recent App Store reviews · updated July 2026 · View on the App Store