Verithiathe honest score on any app
Updated July 2026 · real, multi-region App Store reviews
Head-to-head

High Seas Hero vs Idle Digging

High Seas Hero 4.8★ · Free + IAP 40
Winner Idle Digging
Idle Digging 4.6★ · Free + IAP · ⚠ stale 60

Idle Digging is a better choice for a casual idle game experience, despite its aggressive ad monetization, as High Seas Hero suffers from being an unsupported, pay-to-win game with misleading advertising.

Full reviews: High Seas Hero · Idle Digging

High Seas Hero, despite its high lifetime rating, is largely criticized as an unsupported, pay-to-win game with misleading ads and repetitive gameplay. Idle Digging, while also an idle clicker, is praised for its relaxing nature and fun, but is heavily criticized for its intrusive and often broken ad monetization, even after purchasing ad-free options.

Head to head

Features & Gameplay edge: Idle DiggingR2R12R13R15
High Seas Hero High Seas Hero is described as a 'clicking simulator' with endless upgrading and repetitive tasks, often feeling more like a chore than a game R12R13R15. Many users feel there is 'no gameplay' and it's just pressing buttons . Some enjoy the ship-to-plane combat and guild interactions R2R39R49.
Idle Digging Idle Digging is generally seen as a simple, relaxing, and addictive idle game . Users enjoy the core digging mechanic and find it a good time-killer . However, some find the miners too slow and wish for infinite energy .
Ease of Use & User Interface edge: Idle DiggingR15R18R39R49
High Seas Hero High Seas Hero has too many menus and hidden rewards, making it feel overstimulating and annoying R15R18. The persistent tutorial glove is a significant frustration for some users R18. Some newer players find the UI easy to understand, especially with guild help R39R49.
Idle Digging Idle Digging is described as simple and easy to play . No specific complaints about the UI were noted, though the constant ad pop-ups could be considered a UI issue .
Reliability & Performance tieR30R42R46R82
High Seas Hero High Seas Hero has issues with constant disconnections and freezing, even on good internet and phones R42R46. One user reported being logged out after an update and unable to log back in, losing all progress R30.
Idle Digging Some users of Idle Digging reported the game not letting them play after downloading R82. There are also reports of the game kicking players out continuously . Ad rewards sometimes don't last as long as they should or don't activate .
Price & Value (IAP/Ads) tieR4R6R7R8
High Seas Hero High Seas Hero is heavily criticized as a 'cash grab' and 'pay to win' game, where progression requires spending 'ungodly amounts of money' or '1000s of dollars' R4R7R10R36. Many feel it's not worth spending a dime R6 and that the economy is volatile, with developers nerfing premium content after purchase R7R26. Some users claim it's possible to get good without spending money, especially within a strong guild R8.
Idle Digging Idle Digging is plagued by an 'insane number of ads' and 'forced ads' that appear every minute or after every upgrade . Users are frustrated that even after paying for 'no ads' (e.g., $1.99, $2.99), they still receive ads, especially for boosts, or are forced to watch ads even when declining R63R66R67R70.
Support & Development edge: Idle DiggingR1R16R21R26
High Seas Hero High Seas Hero is widely considered unsupported and abandoned; the company has delisted it, moderators are absent, there are no updates or gift codes, and events are recycled R1R16R21R26. Support is reportedly handled by AI, providing no actual responses R26. Developers are accused of ignoring the community and making updates that set the game back .
Idle Digging Idle Digging has some content issues, with one user noting they completed all levels and have been awaiting more for 5 months . There are no specific mentions of direct developer support or community interaction in the reviews.
Pick High Seas Hero if

you are looking for a game with potential for social interaction in guilds and enjoy a competitive, albeit pay-to-win, environment, and are aware of the game's current unsupported status R8R39R49.

Pick Idle Digging if

you want a simple, relaxing, and addictive idle game to pass the time, and are willing to tolerate a high volume of ads or risk issues with ad-free purchases .

Evidence note: The lifetime ratings for High Seas Hero (4.8) are significantly higher than recent reviews suggest, indicating a decline in quality and support over time. Many recent reviews for High Seas Hero are 1-star, reflecting the current state of the game R1R4R7R10. Idle Digging's reviews show a consistent pattern of frustration with ads, even among those who enjoy the core gameplay.

Frequently asked

Are the games as advertised in their app store screenshots?
No, both High Seas Hero and Idle Digging are criticized for having misleading app store screenshots that do not accurately represent the actual gameplay R19R22R32R34.
Can you play these games without spending money?
For High Seas Hero, while some users claim it's possible to get good without spending money, especially within a strong guild, many others describe it as a 'cash grab' and 'pay to win' game where significant spending is necessary to progress beyond the initial stages R4R8R10R36. For Idle Digging, you can play without spending money, but you will be subjected to a very high volume of forced ads, even when declining ad offers for boosts R67.
Does paying for 'no ads' work in Idle Digging?
No, multiple users report that purchasing the 'no ads' option (e.g., for $1.99 or $2.99) in Idle Digging does not remove all ads; players still encounter forced ads or ads for boosts, even when declining them R63R66R67R70.

What reviewers actually said

Built only from these 120 real reviews (foreign ones translated). Superscripts jump to the quote here. Apple has no per-review links, so [ref] opens that app's reviews on the App Store.

  1. [R2] High Seas Hero 4/5 · US Cool game: I liked the ship to plane combat mechanics especially when they had the same mechanic
  2. [R12] High Seas Hero 3/5 · US Endless upgrading: Do you like endlessly upgrading stuff? Do you like tapping your screen a lot? Do you like not feeling accomplished ever? Like the days work is never fully complete? Do you like a game where you don’t actually play a game? Then this is the game for you!
  3. [R13] High Seas Hero 1/5 · US Click bait game: Looks like it would be similar to those bunker games and that’s what made me interested. But it’s literally just a clicking simulator with battle ships in the background. Like someone else here said, it’s literally just pressing ‘forge’ over and over I’m so tired of these guild games pretending they are something else.
  4. [R15] High Seas Hero 3/5 · US Way too Overstimulating: I played this game maybe a year ago, and i thought it was fun. I played it again recently and it’s just so many popups, not from ads, but from just so many things coming out. It gets so annoying to try and do everything at once. Feels more like a chore than a funny getaway.
  5. [R18] High Seas Hero 3/5 · US Okay: It’s a fine idle app. Two main complaints. They have way to many menus and each different one has rewards hidden away so you feel the need to open every page. Second, that annoying glove used to tell you where to click next NEVER GOES AWAY. It’s driving me crazy. I am almost about to delete the app because I’m sick of seeing that glove relentlessly tell me to tap somewhere I already know to
  6. [R39] High Seas Hero 5/5 · US Fun Game: Great game! Very interactive especially if you are in a great guild, everyone’s super helpful and the UI is easy to understand. There’s always something to do with all the content the devs push out!
  7. [R49] High Seas Hero 5/5 · US Fun game, great community: If the concept of spending time building an account, this game is for you. The game takes a little bit to grasp the nuances, so I suggest getting into a guild that will advise you on how to get stronger. The community is the best part of the game.
  8. [R30] High Seas Hero 1/5 · US New update: I forgot to update the game, and now I have been logged out of my account and can’t log back in. So I’m disappointed cause u had alot of things on my account, I really wish I could get it back.
  9. [R42] High Seas Hero 2/5 · US Fix the bug!!!!!!! I reinstalled the game twice but the problem didn't go away. The problem is that when you play, it constantly shows "waiting" and then "reconnecting." It's impossible to play. Otherwise, the game is very promising, like the "Mushrooms" game, the meaning is the same, but as a guy, I'd rather play your game. So I have to play Mushrooms. FIX IT!!!!!!!! And I'll change the rating too, but for now, two stars. · translated
  10. [R46] High Seas Hero 1/5 · US Question: Why does my app constantly reconnect to the internet and freeze? My phone is good, and my home internet is fast, so what's the problem? · translated
  11. [R82] Idle Digging 2/5 · US I mean: This game looks fun in all but when I downloaded it. It wouldn’t let me play like what?
  12. [R4] High Seas Hero 1/5 · US Cash grab: Don’t get into this game. It’s fun the first maybe half a day to day. Then the only way to get power is by spending an ungodly amount of money. It’s a cash grab
  13. [R6] High Seas Hero 3/5 · US Meh: It’s ok, it’s fun for a while but gets super boring and repetitive- like most games of this type. Not worth spending a dime on it though.
  14. [R7] High Seas Hero 1/5 · US Volatile economy and misleading: Played this game for a year and gave the devs a chance. Lots of breaking changes especially for players who invested money. I would be wary of putting too much effort into this game if you’re a new player
  15. [R8] High Seas Hero 5/5 · US Best game ever: I play on server 311 and I just wanna say best game ever only fun when u are locked in you can get good without spending money.. btw shoutout to (Dome) domain breakers. Best guild in the world
  16. [R1] High Seas Hero 1/5 · US Game is now unsupported: Company delisted game from their official website, they are instead focusing on Kingshot and Whiteout Survival. The company moderators have been absent for months. No more weekly gift codes. No more updates or news of updates. Complete silence. Same tired in game events recycled over and over. The game is obviously in maintenance mode.
  17. [R16] High Seas Hero 1/5 · US Dead scam: Played for almost a year it’s all fake no updates abusive to players . Everyone quit
  18. [R21] High Seas Hero 3/5 · GB Average game.: The release of new content is extremely slow, The odds on things like weapon and hero rolls are just completely untrue. Something at a 0.02% roll rate. Means it should drop 20 in every 1000 rolls. I’ve had items I’ve rolled 16,000 times and not get a single one. That’s not rng at that point it’s just a lie. I also dislike the fact this game is basically a hidden RTS game when the st
  19. [R26] High Seas Hero 1/5 · US They have forgotten us.: The devs of this game have completely given up on it. All they have done is nerf premium content once players have spent money. The majority of servers are dead, and they’ve done NOTHING to create a merger. They use AI for support so don’t expect an actual response. It’s sad really because a lot of people loved this game.
  20. [R19] High Seas Hero 2/5 · US Not as advertised: Game isn't the same as the pictures in the description. Gameplay is also generic and not really that engaging.
  21. [R22] High Seas Hero 1/5 · US Do NOT download. Total scam: Do not download this game. Previews are fake, most reviews are unreal and fake, this game is a pure scam.
  22. [R32] High Seas Hero 1/5 · US Misleading app store: The game started off well a year or so ago but each update eliminated non monetary systems to stay competitive. The updates are not what the ap store lists, the team is very very poor. Most systems, especially the ones that dont require money are maxed out and never updated, most systems are flat out broken. I dont even know what the screenshots show, its not in this game. Ov
  23. [R34] High Seas Hero 2/5 · US There is no digging: The app doesn’t look like the screenshots. It’s just an idle reward clicker.
  24. [R10] High Seas Hero 1/5 · US READ THIS!: Are you looking for a game to waste your entire pay check on? A game where everything you can do in one day takes 10 seconds and you don’t get stronger once so ever unless you spend 1000s of dollars? Play this game then. The top guilds are players using mommy and daddies money, and you can’t fight them unless you also spend a bunch of money. These types of games need be thrown into a p
  25. [R36] High Seas Hero 1/5 · US Pay to Win, Slot machine, AI Slop Scam: Another one of those “kingdom” games. You either take the micro-transactions route, spend ALL your money for maybe showing in the top 50 of the server for a week; Or you take the grind route, clicking button, spinning wheels over and over, until a player/bot 10x stronger than you, decides they don’t like you and vaporizes your base into oblivion within minut
  26. [R63] Idle Digging 3/5 · US Paid for no ads - still getting ads: Paid for no ads in 2 different ways and still getting ads. Annoying. Game is fun otherwise.
  27. [R66] Idle Digging 3/5 · US No Ads isn’t no ads: Don’t pay for no ads. You’ll still have to watch ads for the boosts. Games okay but no ads and still making you watch ads is too scammy
  28. [R67] Idle Digging 2/5 · US Ad-watching simulator: It’s basically an ad-watching simulator. Every time you want to do anything other than clicking it forces you to watch an ad. Even if you want to level up it says do you want to watch an ad to get 2x? You say no and it still gives an ad. This is every 30s of clicking. I also have no idea what the clicking even does because they seem to love at the same pace without clicking.
  29. [R70] Idle Digging 1/5 · US Broken Ad Purchase: Purchasing Ad-free doesn’t work so you are still forced to watch the ads.

Synthesized from 120 recent App Store reviews · updated July 2026 · View on the App Store