Verithiathe honest score on any app
Updated July 2026 · real, multi-region App Store reviews
Head-to-head

iCollect Video Games vs iCollect Everything

iCollect Video Games 4.6★ · Free + IAP 65
Winner iCollect Everything
iCollect Everything 4.6★ · Free + IAP 75

iCollect Everything is the better choice for serious collectors due to its broader scope and generally more stable performance, despite both apps facing similar issues with pricing and past data loss.

Full reviews: iCollect Video Games · iCollect Everything

Both iCollect Video Games and iCollect Everything offer barcode scanning and collection management, but iCollect Everything stands out with its ability to catalog diverse item types and a more robust feature set for serious collectors. However, both apps are criticized for high paywalls and occasional data loss issues.

Head to head

Features and Scope edge: iCollect EverythingR2R6R8R11
iCollect Video Games iCollect Video Games is praised for its barcode scanning, wishlist, and customization options for game entries, including custom cover art R2R8R11R21. However, users desire more organization options like folders for different consoles and better integration with pricing data R6.
iCollect Everything iCollect Everything offers a much broader scope, allowing users to catalog various items like action figures, books, movies, and even create custom categories . It also features barcode scanning and value estimates, though some find the value estimates inaccurate . Users appreciate the ability to add detailed information and photos .
Ease of Use tieR1R2R26R32
iCollect Video Games Users generally find iCollect Video Games easy and intuitive to use, with quick barcode scanning and simple cataloging R2R26R32. Some recent reviews, however, report issues with the 'add' button not working and slow loading times R1.
iCollect Everything iCollect Everything is often described as easy to use, with a simple design and quick barcode scanning . The bulk scan feature is also appreciated for adding large collections . However, some users report the barcode scanner being unreliable or not adding information .
Reliability and Stability tieR1R9R20R21
iCollect Video Games iCollect Video Games has significant issues with data loss, with multiple users reporting their entire collections disappearing after updates or without explanation R31. There are also reports of bugs like cover art missing, features not working, and the app crashing or running slowly R1R9R20R21.
iCollect Everything iCollect Everything also suffers from reliability issues, including collections disappearing, constant loading problems, and the app being inaccessible when servers are down . Some users report the app becoming unusable after updates .
Price and Value tieR3R4R7R10
iCollect Video Games iCollect Video Games is heavily criticized for its pricing model. It's advertised as free but imposes a strict limit (typically 15 games) before requiring a $30 one-time payment R3R4R7R13. Some long-time users feel ripped off, having paid less previously or losing their purchase after updates R10R25R52R58. There are also complaints about additional fees for features or smaller purchases .
iCollect Everything iCollect Everything also faces strong criticism for its pricing. It has a limit of 15-30 items before requiring payment, with subscriptions ranging from $30 to $100 R66R67R72R73. Users are frustrated by multiple tiers of payment, including an initial purchase, an 'upgrade to pro' for additional features, and recurring yearly fees, feeling it's a bait-and-switch .
Customer Support tieR5R25R31R50
iCollect Video Games Some long-term users of iCollect Video Games report positive experiences, stating that problems were fixed after emailing support R5. However, other users complain about a lack of response from the company after losing data R50 and no notice about app changes or deleted collections R25R31R58.
iCollect Everything iCollect Everything has mixed reviews for support. Some users received quick and clear responses from developers . However, many others report zero customer service, with no response to issues like disappearing collections or problems with purchases .
Pick iCollect Video Games if

You are a video game collector with a smaller collection (under 15 games) and are comfortable with the $30 paywall for unlimited entries R3R4. You prioritize a simple, game-specific interface and don't mind potential bugs or data loss R2.

Pick iCollect Everything if

You collect a wide variety of items beyond just video games, such as books, movies, action figures, or sports cards, and need a single app to manage them all . You are willing to pay a higher, potentially multi-tiered fee for comprehensive collection management and value estimates .

Evidence note: Both apps have a significant number of negative reviews related to pricing and data loss, which skews recent sentiment. The free-to-paid model creates friction for non-paying users who hit limits, while paid users often express satisfaction with the core functionality despite the cost. Many negative reviews for both apps stem from the transition to new ownership/app versions, leading to lost data and re-purchase requirements for existing users.

Frequently asked

What is the item limit before I have to pay for iCollect Video Games?
iCollect Video Games allows you to add up to 15 games for free before requiring a $30 one-time payment for unlimited entries R3R4R7R13.
Does iCollect Everything have a free version?
iCollect Everything is advertised as free but limits users to 15-30 items before requiring a purchase, with subscription options ranging from $30 to $100 for unlimited access R66R67R72R73.
Can I transfer my collection from an older iCollect app to a new one?
Users of both apps have reported issues with transferring collections from older versions or previous apps (like SortiApps), often resulting in lost data and the need to re-enter items or re-purchase features R25R31R52R58.

What reviewers actually said

Built only from these 120 real reviews (foreign ones translated). Superscripts jump to the quote here. Apple has no per-review links, so [ref] opens that app's reviews on the App Store.

  1. [R2] iCollect Video Games 5/5 · US Super good: It scan it and then it Get connected, but you can also search it
  2. [R6] iCollect Video Games 3/5 · US FOLDERS: I really liked the app but I think it should have an option to separate the games into different folders, sega genesis with sega genesis, Nintendo with nintendo and not all games together in just one list.
  3. [R8] iCollect Video Games 5/5 · US Great tool to keep track of my games: Works great. I especially love the wishlist and searching for games is super easy. Keep up the great work!
  4. [R11] iCollect Video Games 5/5 · US Great 4 Saving Games!: This app is great for saving the games I have and adding games to my wish list! The only thing I wish they had was a better search bar and a select item. ☺️👍🏽
  5. [R1] iCollect Video Games 2/5 · US “Add” button not working.: I like this app. I’ve been using it for years. I just got a new collection of games so I thought I would add them to the app and update my existing collection, but I can’t because the “+” button at the top left isn’t working.
  6. [R26] iCollect Video Games 5/5 · US So cool: Excellent way to keep track of all the games you own! The biggest part though will be remembering to enter in the new games I get!
  7. [R32] iCollect Video Games 5/5 · US Great organizer: Great app! It’s been organizing my games list very well. Love the barcode scanning features
  8. [R9] iCollect Video Games 3/5 · US Old version was better: Since the new version, I’ve lost most of the cover art pictures. And other info is gone. Now I have to spend hours fixing everything that was perfect before it was changed to this new company. My wanted list is missing all the info but the title.
  9. [R20] iCollect Video Games 5/5 · US Great 👌: But When I fill out the form incompletely and go to the browser to search for a photo, When I return, the software is restarted and I have to fill out the form again.
  10. [R21] iCollect Video Games 3/5 · US Has Great Potential - Quite Buggy: Love the layout and the bookshelf appearance. Really is a nice touch. A+ for the huge database, barcode scan, metadata editing, etc. Lots of customization for each title which is great if you collect rare limited and special editions of your favorite games. Uploading custom cover art is MUCH APPRECIATED. However, after paying $5.99, it does have more bugs than I
  11. [R3] iCollect Video Games 3/5 · US Nice limited experience, too expensive for me.: So I download this app and in the description it states: large collections require a fee to make unlimited. So large collections are 16 games? If I only had 15 games, I think I could remember them all. Disappointed to start scanning in my collection to find out it’s $30. My 5 minute brief experience, I like the app. But $30 is personally too s
  12. [R4] iCollect Video Games 1/5 · US $30 Payment Required: I was eager to start cataloging which video games I owned, and scanning the bar codes on the back made it seem so easy… that is, until you try to add a 16th game into the app. Then you are hit with a $30 paywall with no alternative. Such a disappointment. I really wish the App Store wouldn’t allow apps like this to even be considered “free” because it isn’t, it’s thirty dolla
  13. [R7] iCollect Video Games 2/5 · US Hidden Fee: Amazing app except for the fact that there was no warning of a 15 game limit. $30 is outrageous!
  14. [R10] iCollect Video Games 1/5 · US I bought it: I bought this app years ago.. just now started using it again and it told me I can only upload 15 games then wants me to pay $29.99 I bought this app years ago for $10… bid I just lose my money or what?
  15. [R5] iCollect Video Games 5/5 · US Have used for over 10 years.: I have thousands of titles that I wouldn’t be able to keep track of otherwise. I own the Games, Movies, and Books collections of the app. The few problems I’ve had over the years have all been fixed after sending them an email.
  16. [R25] iCollect Video Games 1/5 · US Why not allow me to transfer my collection from Collectors???: I would consider purchasing (even though I Purchased Full access from the app they cancelled) but only if I could transfer the collection I put in in over several years. It’s really short sited to expect me to spend hours re entering stuff I already put into your previous app. I never received any notice and I’m certain they have my
  17. [R31] iCollect Video Games 1/5 · US They Deleted my Collection: They moved to this app and Deleted my SortiApps Collection without providing any notice. They had my email address. Why not email me to let me know?
  18. [R50] iCollect Video Games 4/5 · US Sort it! Video game app: This is a great app when it works. This app has deleted hundreds of games on 4 different times. Wasted hundreds of hours inputting data. I have emailed company over a dozen times...NO FEEDBACK! If you have only a few games. Go ahead and use. Serious game collection collectors beware. John H
  19. [R13] iCollect Video Games 1/5 · US Always a subscription: You can only store 15 games and then they want you to buy more space…..
  20. [R66] iCollect Everything 3/5 · US LIMITED: not a bad app overall but unfortunately it’s not really free. It only gives you about 30 scans before it makes you pay for “unlimited access” and of course the subscriptions range from $40 to $100.
  21. [R67] iCollect Everything 1/5 · US Mehhh: I was looking for an app to keep track of my Black Series figures and Funko pop collection and this app was in all of my google searches labeled as FREE. Which it is NOT. you only get 15 scans until you have to buy a membership or upgrade. The price isn’t even reasonable. The cheap option is like $30. I’m sorry, I’m not paying $30 for something I can do in my Notes app. The pricing o
  22. [R72] iCollect Everything 3/5 · US Good but… not actually free: Looks like a free app, has really good customization- but you can only do up to 15 of an item before you have to pay :(
  23. [R73] iCollect Everything 1/5 · US 30 Movie Limit: It needs to be made abundantly clear that you cannot add more than 30 movies to a collection. I would not have downloaded this app had I known that. After 30 movies, you have to pay to add any more items. I personally think a 30 item limit for a collection app called "I Collect Everything" is absurd.
  24. [R52] iCollect Video Games 1/5 · US Don’t buy!: This app is always having issues, logging me out/not letting me log back in, camera scan not working etc. Now that it’s been bought out from I sort it, it’s telling me I’ve never purchased the app and is trying to make me re-purchase the app. Don’t waste your time. This app has caused me more headache than anything.
  25. [R58] iCollect Video Games 1/5 · US New ownership ruined the app: An update changed the name to iCollect and erased my entire collection. Hours of organizing and scanning wasted. Absolutely awful experience, would not recommend this. I guess I just wasted money paying for the previous app as well. Very shady dealings.

Synthesized from 120 recent App Store reviews · updated July 2026 · View on the App Store