Verithiathe honest score on any app
Updated July 2026 · real, multi-region App Store reviews
Head-to-head

iCollect Video Games vs Tracker Network Stats

iCollect Video Games 4.6★ · Free + IAP 70
Winner iCollect Video Games
Tracker Network Stats 4.7★ · Free to download 40

For managing personal game collections, iCollect Video Games is the better choice despite its paywall, while Tracker Network Stats is plagued by ads and bugs, making its website a superior alternative.

Full reviews: iCollect Video Games · Tracker Network Stats

iCollect Video Games excels at cataloging personal game collections with features like barcode scanning and wishlists, though it has a significant paywall after 15 games. Tracker Network Stats, while useful for competitive players, is heavily criticized for excessive ads, frequent bugs, and login issues, with many users recommending its website over the app.

Head to head

Features edge: iCollect Video GamesR2R6R8R11
iCollect Video Games iCollect Video Games offers robust features for cataloging, including barcode scanning, wishlists, and extensive customization for game entries, which users appreciate for managing large collections R2R8R11R21. Some users desire more advanced organization options like folders or platform-specific counts R6.
Tracker Network Stats Tracker Network Stats provides real-time game statistics, leaderboards, and event tracking for various games . However, users report missing data for older seasons, inaccurate stats, and lack of support for newer game titles .
Ease of Use edge: iCollect Video GamesR1R2R20R26
iCollect Video Games Users generally find iCollect Video Games easy and intuitive to use, especially for scanning and adding games R2R26. However, some recent reviews mention issues with the 'add' button not working and the app restarting when switching screens R1R20.
Tracker Network Stats Tracker Network Stats is widely criticized for being difficult to use due to frequent freezing, loading issues, and persistent login/account linking problems . Many users suggest using the website instead due to the app's poor performance R61R67R78.
Reliability tieR1R9R21R25
iCollect Video Games iCollect Video Games has significant reliability issues, particularly after recent updates or changes in ownership. Many users report losing their entire collections, missing cover art, or data disappearing R9R25R28R31. Some users also note general slowness and bugs R1R21.
Tracker Network Stats Tracker Network Stats is highly unreliable, with numerous reports of bugs, freezing, and features not working. Users frequently encounter issues with account linking, stats not updating, and ads breaking the app .
Price/Value edge: iCollect Video GamesR3R4R7R10
iCollect Video Games iCollect Video Games is criticized for its deceptive "free" label, as it imposes a strict 15-game limit before requiring a $30 one-time payment for unlimited use R3R4R7R13. Some long-time users who previously paid less or had full access feel cheated by the new pricing structure or lost purchases R10R25.
Tracker Network Stats Tracker Network Stats is free to download but heavily monetized with an overwhelming number of ads that frequently interrupt usage and can make the app unusable R61R63R67R78. Some features or full stats are also paywalled .
Support edge: iCollect Video GamesR5R25R31R50
iCollect Video Games Some users of iCollect Video Games report positive experiences with support, stating that problems were fixed after emailing them R5. However, others complain about a lack of notice regarding app changes or lost collections, and no feedback from the company after multiple emails R25R31R50.
Tracker Network Stats Reviews for Tracker Network Stats do not provide specific feedback on direct customer support interactions. However, the prevalence of persistent bugs, login issues, and unaddressed ad problems suggests a lack of effective support or development response to user complaints .
Pick iCollect Video Games if

You want a dedicated app to catalog your physical video game collection, appreciate barcode scanning and customization, and are willing to pay a one-time fee of $30 after the initial 15 free games R2R3.

Pick Tracker Network Stats if

You are a competitive gamer who needs to track stats for specific games like Fortnite or Rocket League, and you are prepared to deal with a high volume of ads and potential bugs, or you plan to primarily use the associated website .

Evidence note: iCollect Video Games has a smaller number of reviews, and a significant portion of its negative feedback is related to its pricing model and data loss issues following updates or ownership changes. Tracker Network Stats has a much larger review base, with overwhelmingly negative recent reviews focused on ads and bugs, often recommending the website over the app.

Frequently asked

Is iCollect Video Games truly free?
No, iCollect Video Games is not truly free; it allows you to add only 15 games before hitting a paywall, requiring a $30 one-time payment for unlimited use R3R4R7R13.
Does Tracker Network Stats have a lot of ads?
Yes, Tracker Network Stats has a significant problem with excessive and intrusive ads, with users reporting multiple 30-second ads per minute, ads that break the app, and many recommending using the website instead R61R63R67R78.
Can I transfer my collection if I previously used a different version of iCollect Video Games?
Many users report issues with transferring collections, with some stating that their entire collections were deleted or not recognized after updates or changes in app ownership, leading to frustration and lost data R9R25R28R31.

What reviewers actually said

Built only from these 120 real reviews (foreign ones translated). Superscripts jump to the quote here. Apple has no per-review links, so [ref] opens that app's reviews on the App Store.

  1. [R2] iCollect Video Games 5/5 · US Super good: It scan it and then it Get connected, but you can also search it
  2. [R6] iCollect Video Games 3/5 · US FOLDERS: I really liked the app but I think it should have an option to separate the games into different folders, sega genesis with sega genesis, Nintendo with nintendo and not all games together in just one list.
  3. [R8] iCollect Video Games 5/5 · US Great tool to keep track of my games: Works great. I especially love the wishlist and searching for games is super easy. Keep up the great work!
  4. [R11] iCollect Video Games 5/5 · US Great 4 Saving Games!: This app is great for saving the games I have and adding games to my wish list! The only thing I wish they had was a better search bar and a select item. ☺️👍🏽
  5. [R1] iCollect Video Games 2/5 · US “Add” button not working.: I like this app. I’ve been using it for years. I just got a new collection of games so I thought I would add them to the app and update my existing collection, but I can’t because the “+” button at the top left isn’t working.
  6. [R20] iCollect Video Games 5/5 · US Great 👌: But When I fill out the form incompletely and go to the browser to search for a photo, When I return, the software is restarted and I have to fill out the form again.
  7. [R26] iCollect Video Games 5/5 · US So cool: Excellent way to keep track of all the games you own! The biggest part though will be remembering to enter in the new games I get!
  8. [R9] iCollect Video Games 3/5 · US Old version was better: Since the new version, I’ve lost most of the cover art pictures. And other info is gone. Now I have to spend hours fixing everything that was perfect before it was changed to this new company. My wanted list is missing all the info but the title.
  9. [R21] iCollect Video Games 3/5 · US Has Great Potential - Quite Buggy: Love the layout and the bookshelf appearance. Really is a nice touch. A+ for the huge database, barcode scan, metadata editing, etc. Lots of customization for each title which is great if you collect rare limited and special editions of your favorite games. Uploading custom cover art is MUCH APPRECIATED. However, after paying $5.99, it does have more bugs than I
  10. [R25] iCollect Video Games 1/5 · US Why not allow me to transfer my collection from Collectors???: I would consider purchasing (even though I Purchased Full access from the app they cancelled) but only if I could transfer the collection I put in in over several years. It’s really short sited to expect me to spend hours re entering stuff I already put into your previous app. I never received any notice and I’m certain they have my
  11. [R3] iCollect Video Games 3/5 · US Nice limited experience, too expensive for me.: So I download this app and in the description it states: large collections require a fee to make unlimited. So large collections are 16 games? If I only had 15 games, I think I could remember them all. Disappointed to start scanning in my collection to find out it’s $30. My 5 minute brief experience, I like the app. But $30 is personally too s
  12. [R4] iCollect Video Games 1/5 · US $30 Payment Required: I was eager to start cataloging which video games I owned, and scanning the bar codes on the back made it seem so easy… that is, until you try to add a 16th game into the app. Then you are hit with a $30 paywall with no alternative. Such a disappointment. I really wish the App Store wouldn’t allow apps like this to even be considered “free” because it isn’t, it’s thirty dolla
  13. [R7] iCollect Video Games 2/5 · US Hidden Fee: Amazing app except for the fact that there was no warning of a 15 game limit. $30 is outrageous!
  14. [R10] iCollect Video Games 1/5 · US I bought it: I bought this app years ago.. just now started using it again and it told me I can only upload 15 games then wants me to pay $29.99 I bought this app years ago for $10… bid I just lose my money or what?
  15. [R5] iCollect Video Games 5/5 · US Have used for over 10 years.: I have thousands of titles that I wouldn’t be able to keep track of otherwise. I own the Games, Movies, and Books collections of the app. The few problems I’ve had over the years have all been fixed after sending them an email.
  16. [R31] iCollect Video Games 1/5 · US They Deleted my Collection: They moved to this app and Deleted my SortiApps Collection without providing any notice. They had my email address. Why not email me to let me know?
  17. [R50] iCollect Video Games 4/5 · US Sort it! Video game app: This is a great app when it works. This app has deleted hundreds of games on 4 different times. Wasted hundreds of hours inputting data. I have emailed company over a dozen times...NO FEEDBACK! If you have only a few games. Go ahead and use. Serious game collection collectors beware. John H
  18. [R13] iCollect Video Games 1/5 · US Always a subscription: You can only store 15 games and then they want you to buy more space…..
  19. [R61] Tracker Network Stats 1/5 · US Horrendous: Unless you want 2 ads every time you switch screens, pay for premium. It’s not their data to sell and they’re hyper monetizing it. Don’t download just use the website
  20. [R63] Tracker Network Stats 3/5 · US Too many Ads: 30 second ad twice in 90 seconds made me come here to say cmon this is ridiculous
  21. [R67] Tracker Network Stats 1/5 · US ads make it unusable: just stick to the website version.
  22. [R78] Tracker Network Stats 3/5 · US Stopped working: I used this app for Rocket League for a very long time and it was pretty helpful, but over time it has gotten worse and worse. The ads become more and more unbearable. They didn’t even used to have ads. Also, the app doesn’t work at all now and nothing loads. Don’t use the app, just use it in a browser.
  23. [R28] iCollect Video Games 1/5 · US Not worth my time: I added my whole collection to this app. Tracking it was nice. I could scan a barcode or do it manually when I got a new game. Well logged in today and 90% of my collection isn’t showing up 🤷‍♂️ uhh what the heck. Well I’m not adding it all back in. That would take hours. Guess I’ll find a new app

Synthesized from 120 recent App Store reviews · updated July 2026 · View on the App Store