Verithiathe honest score on any app
Updated July 2026 · real, multi-region App Store reviews
Head-to-head

Strong Workout Tracker Gym Log vs MyFitnessPal

Strong Workout Tracker Gym Log 4.9★ · Free + IAP 75
Winner Tie
MyFitnessPal 4.7★ · Free + IAP 70

Strong Workout Tracker is better for dedicated weightlifting and gym tracking, while MyFitnessPal excels at comprehensive calorie and macro tracking, despite recent UI issues.

Full reviews: Strong Workout Tracker Gym Log · MyFitnessPal

Strong Workout Tracker is lauded for its intuitive gym logging and progress tracking, particularly with its Apple Watch integration, though recent updates have introduced significant syncing bugs. MyFitnessPal remains a top choice for food and calorie tracking due to its extensive database, but recent UI changes and paywalling of features have frustrated many long-term users.

Head to head

Features and Functionality tieR2R6R8R17
Strong Workout Tracker Gym Log Strong is praised for its ability to track sets, repetitions, and weights, create custom workout templates, and monitor progress with graphs R2R8R17. Users appreciate the visual guides for exercises and the ease of planning workouts R35. However, some users note a limited exercise database and a lack of features like Strava integration or social sharing R6.
MyFitnessPal MyFitnessPal is highly valued for its extensive and accurate food database, making calorie and macro tracking effective . It also offers features like recipe importing and a GLP1 tracker . However, recent updates have removed or hidden features like copying individual food items, saving full days while separating meals, and free barcode scanning, which users find frustrating R61R73R79.
Ease of Use and Interface edge: Strong Workout Tracker Gym LogR2R3R30R35
Strong Workout Tracker Gym Log Strong is generally considered intuitive and easy to use for logging workouts, with perfectly positioned timers R2R35. However, some users find the UI stale and note issues with text entry lag R30. The free version is limited to 3 workout templates, which many find impractical R3R48R49R51.
MyFitnessPal MyFitnessPal has historically been easy to use for calorie tracking . However, recent UI updates have made the app less intuitive and harder to navigate, requiring more clicks for basic actions and making it difficult to see a full day's food or specific meal stats at a glance R69.
Reliability and Performance tieR1R4R7R9
Strong Workout Tracker Gym Log Strong has significant, long-standing, and frequent syncing issues between the Apple Watch and iPhone, leading to lost data, frozen timers, and general unreliability R1R7R9R10. Some users also report the app freezing and needing restarts R4.
MyFitnessPal MyFitnessPal users report frequent bugs, including being logged out, login issues, data not saving, and the app freezing R73. Recent updates have also caused issues with copying meals and completing the diary R61.
Price and Value tieR3R5R26R48
Strong Workout Tracker Gym Log Strong offers a free version that is considered generous and ad-free by some R26. However, the free version is limited to 3 workout templates, which many users find insufficient and pushes them towards the paid version R3R48R49R51. The lifetime membership is mentioned R5R49.
MyFitnessPal MyFitnessPal has a free tier that many users appreciate . However, several key features, such as barcode scanning, net carb tracking, and custom macro goals, have been moved behind a paywall, frustrating long-term users R64R73R79R97. The premium subscription is considered overpriced by some .
Customer Support and Updates tieR5R7R13R24
Strong Workout Tracker Gym Log Strong developers are noted for being quick with bug fixes by some R5, but others report zero help from the support team, receiving unhelpful advice like uninstalling and reinstalling R13. Many users feel the app is getting left behind, with slow updates and a focus on new features like widgets instead of fixing long-standing bugs R7R24.
MyFitnessPal MyFitnessPal's support is criticized for being slow and unhelpful, with users waiting weeks for responses or being unable to access their accounts despite having subscriptions R73. The app is frequently updated, but these updates often introduce new bugs, remove beloved features, or worsen the UI, leading to user frustration R61R67R69.
Pick Strong Workout Tracker Gym Log if

You are primarily focused on tracking gym workouts and weightlifting, appreciate a simple interface for logging sets and reps, and value progress visualization R2R8R17. You are willing to tolerate occasional Apple Watch syncing issues or primarily use the phone app R5.

Pick MyFitnessPal if

You need a comprehensive food and calorie tracking app with an extensive food database, and are willing to pay for premium features like barcode scanning and custom macro goals . You are comfortable adapting to frequent UI changes and potential bugs .

Evidence note: Both apps have a significant number of recent negative reviews related to bugs and UI changes. For Strong, the primary issue is Apple Watch syncing. For MyFitnessPal, it's the recent UI overhaul and paywalling of previously free features. The lifetime ratings for both apps are high, but recent sentiment suggests a decline in user satisfaction.

Frequently asked

Does Strong Workout Tracker sync with Apple Watch?
Strong Workout Tracker has Apple Watch compatibility, with some users praising it as the best Watch app R5, but many recent reviews highlight persistent and frustrating syncing issues between the Apple Watch and iPhone, leading to lost data and unreliable performance R1R7R10.
Is MyFitnessPal's barcode scanner free?
MyFitnessPal's barcode scanner, which used to be a free feature, is now behind a paywall, requiring a premium subscription R73R79R97R98.
How many free workout templates does Strong Workout Tracker offer?
Strong Workout Tracker's free version allows users to create and save only 3 workout templates, which many users find to be a significant limitation and a push towards the paid subscription R3R48R49R51.
What are the main complaints about MyFitnessPal's recent updates?
Recent MyFitnessPal updates have drawn complaints for making the UI less intuitive and harder to navigate, removing the ability to copy individual food items or save full days with separate meals, and moving previously free features like barcode scanning and net carb tracking behind a paywall R61R64R67R69.

What reviewers actually said

Built only from these 120 real reviews (foreign ones translated). Superscripts jump to the quote here. Apple has no per-review links, so [ref] opens that app's reviews on the App Store.

  1. [R2] Strong Workout Tracker Gym Log 5/5 · US My workout partner: I use this app in every single workout. I can’t remember the weights and repetitions and seeing them precisely allows me to see progress. I love the ability to create my own templates when I get too comfortable with my workout I create alternate templates to explore, newer types of exercise, like body, weights, or kettle balls, or any number of things.
  2. [R6] Strong Workout Tracker Gym Log 3/5 · US Strava integration: create workout app, but I really wish it had Strava integration. I want my workout to upload to Strava create workout app, but I really wish it had Strava integration. I want my workout to upload to Strava.
  3. [R8] Strong Workout Tracker Gym Log 5/5 · US Phenomenal: Nearly 700 workouts done using this app. Absolutely a beast at tracking sets. The graphs monitoring progress over time are super helpful as well. Definitely recommend!
  4. [R17] Strong Workout Tracker Gym Log 5/5 · US Fantastic workout partner: I’ve been using Strong for over two years. I now have a huge record of specific workouts and exercises and can see my progress. Super easy to plan workouts and record exercises.
  5. [R3] Strong Workout Tracker Gym Log 3/5 · US Hevy Free version better: Hevy app gives more options, insights and charts than this app. The free version is not sufficient and would need us to pay for it to be usable
  6. [R30] Strong Workout Tracker Gym Log 3/5 · US Laggy text entry: Used to work great, tried again recently and finding that nearly every time I enter in the weight or reps for an exercise it lags and I have to do it over.
  7. [R35] Strong Workout Tracker Gym Log 5/5 · US This app is awesome!!!: This is the third training app I switched to and this time I am extremely satisfied. What I love most about this app is the ease of entry. The timers are perfectly positioned and intuitive. It has all the exercises I need and good depictions of form. This app is so easy to use and I don’t have to think about it while I workout. The only nit I have, when doing exercises like
  8. [R1] Strong Workout Tracker Gym Log 1/5 · US It stinks now: It used to sync well with my watch. Not anymore. Almost useless.
  9. [R4] Strong Workout Tracker Gym Log 2/5 · US Buggy: Today is my first day working with this app. I’m entering custom exercises to build my first routine. The app has frozen several times and needed to be restarted.
  10. [R7] Strong Workout Tracker Gym Log 2/5 · US The workout app field is expanding rapidly and Strong is getting left behind.: I’m quickly finding that there’s no perfect workout app. There’s always a these things are great or improvements over this app…but…and the “but” is the key because it comes down to which app is offering the trade offs you’re willing to live without? My frustration with Strong is we are still dealing with syncing issue
  11. [R9] Strong Workout Tracker Gym Log 3/5 · US Good app; watch app unusable: The watch complication helpfully prevents you from accidentally pasting your password into the password field when you use the remote keyboard. So if you have a long complex password, stick with the phone. Disappointing.
  12. [R5] Strong Workout Tracker Gym Log 5/5 · US Best Workout Tracker: I have been using Strong daily since 2017 and because of its compatibility with my Apple Watch, I will go no where else. They have continued to develop the app and are quick with bug fixes. It has everything I can think of to track my workouts and progress. It is the main reason for me keeping my Apple Watch. I have the lifetime membership.
  13. [R26] Strong Workout Tracker Gym Log 5/5 · US Amazing for it being free: Been using it to track workouts for the past 3 years. Very intuitive interface and very generous for it being free. No ADs either which is a plus. Great history and tracking features as well
  14. [R48] Strong Workout Tracker Gym Log 3/5 · GB Why only 3 templates: This app was great. Super easy to use even alerted you when the timer was up when off the app. The app lets you make your split into individual templates (eg one template for a push workout). This was good until I realised you can only make 3 templates which was really impractical.
  15. [R13] Strong Workout Tracker Gym Log 1/5 · US Junk app: If you ever have to reach out to the developer team, know you’re in for zero help. This app has constant issues integrating with Apple Watch which, for a fitness app, renders it useless. Every time I reach out to support they just tell me to uninstall and reinstall the app. If that was going to work, don’t they think it would’ve worked the first time? They’re lazy and uninterested in mak
  16. [R24] Strong Workout Tracker Gym Log 3/5 · US A Former Great: I used Strong for years and it was a great app. Unfortunately the devs haven’t kept up with the times and recent sync issues with my Apple Watch have caused me to switch to a different app. Will it do the basics and do it well? Yeah. Are there much better, more feature rich workout apps? Also, yeah.
  17. [R10] Strong Workout Tracker Gym Log 2/5 · US Buggy, even with the paid version: This app is incredibly inconsistent, especially when it comes to syncing up to my Series 11, sometimes it absolutely refuses to communicate with the watch and vice versa. The timers between sets often freeze or don’t engage at all, it throws in random numbers for weight and reps into my workout templates and a large amount of my recorded sessions seem to disappea
  18. [R73] MyFitnessPal 1/5 · US This App Used to Be Good: I was a loyal user of MFP for years. Ever since the barcode scanner stopped being free, the app went downhill. I just renewed premium for $79.99 on 7/4/2026 and the custom calorie and macro goals I have input now multiple times in the app and on the website will not save. Conveniently, the tech support part of the website thinks my username and password are wrong when I j
  19. [R79] MyFitnessPal 1/5 · US Pay to scan!?: This is ridiculous, pay to scan labels!? Every app is free to scan except this one... it used to be free to scan. This is trash. That's so basic.
  20. [R97] MyFitnessPal 1/5 · US Paid barcode scanner: Cringe that you turned an old feature into a paid one. Luckily there’s other apps out there where it’s free.
  21. [R98] MyFitnessPal 4/5 · US Helpful App, Update eh: I loved MyFitnessPal, I’ve been a user for 6 years. I love how easy it is to search items and it used to be free to scan them too (shame to miss this feature now). The new update has left me a little confused as to wear to find things, like the full spread of each day in once glance.
  22. [R49] Strong Workout Tracker Gym Log 1/5 · US Mediocre UI: UI is mediocre. Only 3 free templates and a $99 lifetime license. Get a $1 notebook and a box of pens. Your iPhone already has a timer. App is free otherwise to see the prebuilt templates.
  23. [R51] Strong Workout Tracker Gym Log 3/5 · GB Good but: Would be nice if you could get more than 3 free workout templates before you had to pay
  24. [R61] MyFitnessPal 2/5 · US New update is terrible: The latest update no longer allows to copy and paste individual food items from the day before unless you’re willing to copy and paste everything from the meal. Super annoying to have the feature taken away. Also, the app still doesn’t track caffeine.
  25. [R64] MyFitnessPal 1/5 · US Requires money to show net carbs: Including dietary fiber in total carbs is misleading. The carb total shown is useless if it is not net carbs, for those who care about carbs.
  26. [R67] MyFitnessPal 2/5 · US No Longer Displays Previous Foods Logged: This app used to be great. I’ve been using it for years. However, recently, after they changed the interface, it no longer shows the most frequent foods so I have to search for the same food every time I want to log it. What used to take me a couple seconds, because I had built up a catalog of all the foods I eat regularly, now takes 10 times as long and t
  27. [R69] MyFitnessPal 3/5 · US Bad update - early June: I’ve been using MyFitnessPal for about two years, but the recent layout changes have made the app difficult to use. The interface is no longer intuitive, and I find myself spending extra time just trying to log my meals, when I’m already unmotivated to log my calories. Because of this, I would no longer recommend the app to others. One major issue is how meals are display

Synthesized from 120 recent App Store reviews · updated July 2026 · View on the App Store