Verithiathe honest score on any app
Updated July 2026 · real, multi-region App Store reviews
Head-to-head

Ashley Madison Discreet Dating vs Instinct

Ashley Madison Discreet Dating 4.0★ · Free + IAP 30
Winner Instinct
Instinct 4.9★ · Free + IAP 40

Instinct has a slight edge due to its higher lifetime rating and some users finding success, but both apps are heavily criticized for fake profiles, high costs, and poor value.

Full reviews: Ashley Madison Discreet Dating · Instinct

Both Ashley Madison Discreet Dating and Instinct face significant user complaints regarding fake profiles, bots, and excessive costs to interact. While Instinct boasts a higher lifetime rating, its recent reviews mirror Ashley Madison's issues, suggesting neither offers a consistently positive dating app experience.

Head to head

Features tieR6R8R13R15
Ashley Madison Discreet Dating Ashley Madison users appreciate the app's intent and simple layout, with some finding success in meeting people R6R8R13. However, many complain about the limited options and the inability to change profile pictures R15.
Instinct Instinct is described as streamlined and easy to use, with some users finding it effective for hookups and getting matches . However, a significant limitation is the inability to choose multiple gender preferences .
Ease of Use tieR8R9R12R13
Ashley Madison Discreet Dating Ashley Madison is generally considered easy to set up and use, with a minimal layout R8R13. However, some users report login issues and problems with sorting and notification coherence R9R12.
Instinct Instinct is praised for being streamlined and easy to use, with a simple setup process . However, some users report difficulties sending messages or signing in, and issues with the app wanting them to re-sign up .
Reliability tieR1R3R4R6
Ashley Madison Discreet Dating Ashley Madison users frequently report issues with fake profiles, bots, and scammers, which make up a large percentage of accounts R1R3R4R6. Users also mention glitches with photos and features .
Instinct Instinct users also report widespread issues with fake profiles, AI profiles, and scammers R67R70R76R80. Some users experience a lack of local profiles, running out of people to swipe on, and issues with likes refreshing .
Price/Value tieR1R7R10R13
Ashley Madison Discreet Dating Ashley Madison is widely criticized for being extremely expensive, with users needing to pay for credits to send messages, which can quickly add up R1R7R10R13. Many feel it's not worth the money due to the prevalence of fake profiles and scammers R1R13R16.
Instinct Instinct users frequently complain about having to pay to see who likes them or to send messages, with some calling it a money grab or scam R76. Users feel the subscription prices are too high and not worth it, especially when there are few real local profiles .
Support tieR10R24R28R31
Ashley Madison Discreet Dating Ashley Madison users report that support is nonexistent or unhelpful, with the app being unwilling to credit reported accounts and doing nothing to address scammers R10R24R28R31.
Instinct Instinct users mention a lack of customer service or email support .
Pick Ashley Madison Discreet Dating if

Pick Ashley Madison Discreet Dating if you are specifically looking for discreet encounters, are aware of the high costs and prevalence of fake profiles, and are willing to navigate these challenges R6R13.

Pick Instinct if

Pick Instinct if you are looking for a streamlined dating app experience, are open to paying for features, and are hopeful of finding matches despite the reported issues with fake profiles and limited local users .

Evidence note: Both apps have a significant number of negative reviews, primarily focusing on fake profiles, bots, and high costs. Instinct's higher lifetime rating appears to be influenced by requests for 5-star ratings in exchange for credits or swipes . Ashley Madison's reviews are consistently negative regarding value for money and the presence of scammers.

Frequently asked

Is Ashley Madison Discreet Dating worth the cost?
Many users find Ashley Madison Discreet Dating to be ridiculously overpriced and not worth the money, with costs for credits to send messages quickly adding up to hundreds of dollars, especially given the high number of fake profiles and scammers R1R7R13R16.
Are there many fake profiles on Instinct?
Yes, many Instinct users report a significant presence of fake profiles, AI profiles, and scammers, with some claiming that these accounts are used to encourage users to pay for features and connections that are not real R67R70R76R80.
Can you use Ashley Madison Discreet Dating for free?
While Ashley Madison Discreet Dating is listed as Free + IAP, users report that you cannot send messages or talk to people without purchasing credits, with minimum payments starting around $80 R7R16R25R55.

What reviewers actually said

Built only from these 120 real reviews (foreign ones translated). Superscripts jump to the quote here. Apple has no per-review links, so [ref] opens that app's reviews on the App Store.

  1. [R6] Ashley Madison Discreet Dating 3/5 · US Glitches: To be honest, there are so many fake profiles. The intent is wonderful and there are some real profiles that turn out great! Still recommend this app/site as the BEST overall Adult Playground 🤫
  2. [R8] Ashley Madison Discreet Dating 4/5 · US Experience: I am now experiencing it and it wasn’t hard to get my profile done
  3. [R13] Ashley Madison Discreet Dating 2/5 · US All for a price: The app itself is easy to use with a very minimal layout. The service is ridiculously overpriced. Almost $300 in and all the connections I’ve made have turned out to be escorts or scammers. They have ruined Ashley Madison. Does Ashley Madison care? Probably not when they get $$. If anyone were to report the accounts you’ll have nobody on Ashley Madison in all of central Texas. I g
  4. [R15] Ashley Madison Discreet Dating 3/5 · US More options: Not a lot of people on the app. You can find what you looking for but options will be limited.
  5. [R9] Ashley Madison Discreet Dating 3/5 · US Not Sure Yet: It’s really too early to tell as I’ve had a horrible experience, but also a couple decent ones. My biggest issue is that the app doesn’t seem to want to log me in which is frustrating.
  6. [R12] Ashley Madison Discreet Dating 3/5 · US Viewing.: The sorting and messaging notification are out of kilter. They don’t sort in any coherent order and is so difficult for the last few months. Plus the fakes are coming out. In droves
  7. [R1] Ashley Madison Discreet Dating 1/5 · US Tired of bots: Too expensive and keep making it more expensive and mostly bots on the site. The site is not worth the money.
  8. [R3] Ashley Madison Discreet Dating 3/5 · US Fake profiles abound: I’ve 60-70% catfishing.
  9. [R4] Ashley Madison Discreet Dating 1/5 · US Scammers: Scammers and bot using your credits, stick to Feeld
  10. [R7] Ashley Madison Discreet Dating 1/5 · US Have to pay to message people: You can’t even talk to people on this app without making a payment for credits. Minimum is $80🙄
  11. [R10] Ashley Madison Discreet Dating 2/5 · US Declining App: Prices continue to increase. ‘Bots’ that cause you to burn credits and scam artist are very active attempting to gain information to use against. AM unwilling to credit reported accounts. Additionally, those bad accounts disappear before you are able to report.
  12. [R24] Ashley Madison Discreet Dating 3/5 · US Half scammers: Am needs to do a better job at weeding out these scammers and fake accounts. They use up your credits and am rarely refunds them back
  13. [R28] Ashley Madison Discreet Dating 1/5 · US Complete garbage: Am has declined below worthless over the recent years. 95% of profiles are fake. Even some of the verified profiles are fake. If most of the stats section is ask me, they are fake. I’m cautiously burning up my last bit of credits and will never return to this completely fake app. Support is nonexistent and does absolutely nothing besides giving false responses
  14. [R31] Ashley Madison Discreet Dating 1/5 · US Too many fake, scam profiles: Unfortunately Ashley Madison does not monitor or protect the legitimate users even when a scam profile is brought to their attention. All profiles should be REQUIRED to verify they are who they say they are. All I can say is legitimate, real individuals beware and navigate cautiously!
  15. [R16] Ashley Madison Discreet Dating 1/5 · US Credit System is Bull: It costs at least a dollar every time you want to send a single message. Not start a chat, send ONE message. So unless you can get off the app real fast, you’re going to be dumping way too much money into this for it to be worth it. And no, there are no free credits to minimize the insane, overpriced, expenses. $0.30 a credit and at least 5 credits a message. It is NOT worth
  16. [R67] Instinct 1/5 · US Terrible: Fake 5 stars in return of given credits! Terrible app
  17. [R70] Instinct 1/5 · US It’s a scam: Don’t waste your time. There aren’t any real people on there.
  18. [R76] Instinct 1/5 · US Scam: Many AI profiles to keep you paying more fees just to see messages and make connections that are fake. Too expensive and money gouging on people trying to make real connections.
  19. [R80] Instinct 1/5 · US Scam! Everyone is 100’s of miles away! They’re paid .10 per word they write to you. It’s fake!: Horrible!
  20. [R25] Ashley Madison Discreet Dating 2/5 · US Premium & Credits: Imo the premium trial should include at least 50 tokens or credits. Users only get a few messages for back and forth before the credits dry up and that’s almost $90 bucks for a few chats
  21. [R55] Ashley Madison Discreet Dating 1/5 · US Too expensive: Paid for a subscription and still can’t send messages. Too expensive for my liking

Synthesized from 120 recent App Store reviews · updated July 2026 · View on the App Store