Verithiathe honest score on any app
Updated July 2026 · real, multi-region App Store reviews
Head-to-head

Pregnancy Baby Tracker vs BabyCenter Pregnancy Tracker

Pregnancy Baby Tracker 4.9★ · Free to download 65
Winner BabyCenter Pregnancy Tracker
BabyCenter Pregnancy Tracker 4.9★ · Free to download 85

BabyCenter Pregnancy Tracker is the stronger choice for comprehensive, reliable pregnancy and postpartum tracking, despite some ad concerns, while Pregnancy Baby Tracker struggles with buggy post-pregnancy features and controversial community moderation.

Full reviews: Pregnancy Baby Tracker · BabyCenter Pregnancy Tracker

BabyCenter Pregnancy Tracker offers extensive, reliable information and tracking features for both pregnancy and postpartum, with a highly praised community. Pregnancy Baby Tracker provides good pregnancy information but is hampered by buggy baby tracking, controversial community moderation, and some users reporting data selling.

Head to head

Features and Information edge: BabyCenter Pregnancy TrackerR1R2R8R12
Pregnancy Baby Tracker Pregnancy Baby Tracker is praised for its informative content, including articles, videos, and weekly updates on baby's growth, with various size comparisons R2. Users appreciate the ability to track pregnancy experiences and health, and some find the 3D fetus pictures amazing R8. However, some users find the information presentation frustrating, preferring articles over videos, and dislike the unrealistic fetus pictures in later versions R1R12. The app also offers registry options and freebies, though some users report not receiving them .
BabyCenter Pregnancy Tracker BabyCenter Pregnancy Tracker is highly valued for being informative, providing daily tips, weekly updates, and extensive information for both pregnancy and postpartum . Users appreciate the ability to track symptoms, baby's size with comparisons, and access articles and community groups . It also offers features like a name shuffle, contraction timing, and even helps find baby classes . Many users have used it for multiple pregnancies and children, highlighting its long-term utility R62.
Ease of Use and Reliability tieR3R6R18R23
Pregnancy Baby Tracker The pregnancy tracking side of Pregnancy Baby Tracker is generally considered easy to use R3. However, the baby tracker, for logging feedings and diapers, is frequently described as buggy and unusable, with glitches that reset recorded information R3R6. Some users also report issues with country options and address editing, suggesting it might be USA-centric R18R23.
BabyCenter Pregnancy Tracker BabyCenter Pregnancy Tracker is generally found easy to use and navigate, with users appreciating its accessibility . However, a significant number of users report being constantly logged out, requiring frequent re-login, which diminishes convenience . Some also find the app confusing or less intuitive than it used to be , and a few experience errors or features not loading .
Community and Support edge: BabyCenter Pregnancy TrackerR2R4R40R51
Pregnancy Baby Tracker Pregnancy Baby Tracker offers discussion boards and a community for connecting with other expecting moms R2R40R51. However, there are serious concerns about community moderation, with users reporting that moderators delete posts and comments that don't align with their views, leading to accusations of a 'toxic app' R4.
BabyCenter Pregnancy Tracker BabyCenter Pregnancy Tracker provides groups where users can converse and share experiences . The community aspect is generally well-received, offering support and advice from other parents .
Price and Value tieR9R10R36R53
Pregnancy Baby Tracker Pregnancy Baby Tracker is free to download and offers a lot of information without ads, which many users appreciate R36R53. However, some information is behind a paid subscription, which users find counterintuitive for 'free information' R9. There are also reports of the app selling user data, leading to unwanted baby formula samples after miscarriage, which is a significant ethical concern R10.
BabyCenter Pregnancy Tracker BabyCenter Pregnancy Tracker is a free app that offers many benefits, including tracking, tips, articles, and coupons, surprising users with its value . However, a common complaint is the presence of too many ads, which can detract from the user experience .
Content Controversies edge: Pregnancy Baby TrackerR7R13R16R19
Pregnancy Baby Tracker Pregnancy Baby Tracker faces significant criticism for its content. Users report the app recommending 'cry it out' (CIO) sleep training for babies as young as 4 months, with some calling it 'child abuse' and 'unethical advice' R13R16R19. There are also complaints about the app's recommendation of the COVID 'vaccine' for pregnant women, with users citing a lack of safety studies R7. Additionally, some users dislike the 'excessively saccharine' narration in videos and the 'dehumanizing' terminology like 'baby to be' R7.
BabyCenter Pregnancy Tracker BabyCenter Pregnancy Tracker has been criticized for not being inclusive enough, particularly for those with front-facing placentas who don't feel movement as much, leading to potentially 'hard hitting' messages about movement importance . Some users also note that the app doesn't allow input of ovulation dates, making calendar tracking inaccurate for them .
Pick Pregnancy Baby Tracker if

you are looking for a free app primarily for pregnancy tracking and information, appreciate varied size comparisons, and don't plan to use the baby tracking features post-birth R36.

Pick BabyCenter Pregnancy Tracker if

you want a comprehensive, informative app for both pregnancy and postpartum, value a supportive community, and are willing to tolerate occasional ads and login issues for a free, feature-rich experience R62.

Evidence note: While both apps have high lifetime ratings, recent negative reviews for Pregnancy Baby Tracker highlight significant issues with its baby tracking functionality, community moderation, and controversial content, which are not as prevalent in BabyCenter's recent reviews. The free nature of both apps means some negativity for BabyCenter stems from ad presence, a common trade-off for free services.

Frequently asked

Which app is better for tracking my baby after birth?
BabyCenter Pregnancy Tracker is generally better for tracking your baby after birth, as users praise its continued updates and information for children's milestones R62R88, whereas Pregnancy Baby Tracker's baby tracking features are widely reported as buggy and unusable R3R6.
Do these apps have community features?
Yes, both apps have community features; Pregnancy Baby Tracker offers discussion boards R2R40R51, but has received criticism for moderators deleting posts R4, while BabyCenter Pregnancy Tracker provides groups for connecting with other parents .
Are there any concerns about data privacy or controversial advice?
Yes, Pregnancy Baby Tracker has significant concerns, with users reporting their data being sold, leading to unwanted samples after miscarriage R10, and the app actively promoting controversial 'cry it out' sleep training methods R13R16R19 and recommending the COVID 'vaccine' for pregnant women without safety studies R7. BabyCenter Pregnancy Tracker has fewer such concerns, though some users find its content not inclusive enough regarding movement tracking .

What reviewers actually said

Built only from these 120 real reviews (foreign ones translated). Superscripts jump to the quote here. Apple has no per-review links, so [ref] opens that app's reviews on the App Store.

  1. [R1] Pregnancy Baby Tracker 1/5 · US Frustrating: It’s frustrating that I don’t have any information to read everything is just a video. Lacks information. Will have to find a new app.
  2. [R2] Pregnancy Baby Tracker 5/5 · US Informative!: Not just a great tracker but informative too! Love the discussion boards as well!
  3. [R8] Pregnancy Baby Tracker 5/5 · US my most used app during pregnancy: I loved this app because I was able to use it as a diary for my baby once she is born and it also helped me track my pregnancy experience and health.
  4. [R12] Pregnancy Baby Tracker 3/5 · US I dislike the unrealistic fetus pictures: My first pregnancy I enjoyed the scientifically accurate pictures of what my child looked like at every stage. Even the early ones where my baby looked like a little alien. But this second pregnancy I noticed they changed the pictures to have the fetus look like a fully formed human baby even in the early weeks. It’s freaking me out, a fetus just doesn’t l
  5. [R3] Pregnancy Baby Tracker 3/5 · US Great Pregnancy Info, Baby Tracker Too Buggy to Use: I give the pregnancy tracker side of this app 4 stars. It’s easy to use and has a ton of helpful articles. (The article search could be better, but you figure out its quirks quickly.) Unfortunately, the baby tracker, which you will need once baby arrives to log your endless feedings and diapers, is buggy to the point of being unusable. Use this
  6. [R6] Pregnancy Baby Tracker 3/5 · US It's okay: glitchy tracker: Ok the information they provide is pretty good. It really helped me understand what's going on during pregnancy. However, the tracker sucks. It glitches A LOT. Especially to add nursing time manually, it resets whatever I recorded when I touch either date, time, or nursing time. It really frustrates me with already exhausted and sleep deprived body. So for learning a
  7. [R18] Pregnancy Baby Tracker 3/5 · GB No country option: I tried to choose my country but there is is no option and without that it doesn’t work
  8. [R23] Pregnancy Baby Tracker 3/5 · GB Unable to edit my address: I am in the UK and I can’t seem to change my address, is this supposed to work for people living in the USA only?
  9. [R4] Pregnancy Baby Tracker 1/5 · US This App is TOXIC!: I’ve seen other reviews stating the same issue about the moderators deleting people’s posts/comments if they don’t align with “the views of the moderators “ I have just become a victim of this toxic app. I had a different opinion about a subject in the community, non of my comments regarding my opinion were inappropriate, yet all of my comments were deleted! I’ve seen some very
  10. [R40] Pregnancy Baby Tracker 5/5 · US Love love love this app!: Everything about this app is amazing, as a FTM, all of the tips, the community boards, and helpful advice, it’s been my go to during every point of my pregnancy!
  11. [R51] Pregnancy Baby Tracker 5/5 · US 2nd time using: Has really helped in tracking pregnancy and giving insight on symptoms, dos and don’ts. Also great community to connect with other expecting moms.
  12. [R9] Pregnancy Baby Tracker 3/5 · US A Providers review, more affordable subscriptions: The information as easily accessible with AI search, the searchable Free information comes with a paid subscriptions, which doesn’t make sense because you’re charging people for free information essentially. I do like your products the battery die fast in the body temperature thermometer and they did not last long, but I would still recommend this
  13. [R10] Pregnancy Baby Tracker 1/5 · US Sells your data: I started using this app when I found out I was pregnant. I miscarried and now I am receiving free samples of baby formula. Feels like I’m being punched in the face whenever I get the mail. They must have sold my name and address to these companies. What a terrible company.
  14. [R36] Pregnancy Baby Tracker 5/5 · US Amazing and free: Finally a free app that helps you learn about your pregnancy week by week with daily tips, loved it!
  15. [R53] Pregnancy Baby Tracker 5/5 · US Love the app: Really good app for free!!
  16. [R7] Pregnancy Baby Tracker 1/5 · US Unethical Advice and Inaccurate Terminology: I was willing to look beyond the continuous dehumanization of my child with the whole “baby to be” garbage after I sent feedback correcting their wording. But when an app for pregnant women recommends getting the COVID “vaccine”, I’ve hit my limit. There are zero safety studies on the “vaccine”, especially on pregnant women, and the more it was administ
  17. [R13] Pregnancy Baby Tracker 1/5 · GB CIO: Actively promotes CIO, big NO from me.
  18. [R16] Pregnancy Baby Tracker 1/5 · GB Advocates sleep training and CIO: Please choose another app. Advocating cry it out sleep training methods and using the words ‘research shows it doesn’t harm baby’ is just not true.
  19. [R19] Pregnancy Baby Tracker 1/5 · GB Child abuse: The weekly visual pregnancy updates are the only good thing about this app. Their articles recommend literal child abuse - advising cry it out for babies as young as 4 months old, and apparently it’s ok if they ‘get so worked up about it they vomit repeatedly’. New parents, please don’t use this app as your guide to caring for your precious child. Learn about nurture. Read about biolo
  20. [R62] BabyCenter Pregnancy Tracker 5/5 · US Great app: Great app I used it for all 5 of my children and it still gives me updates of each and every child’s milestones to this day by email & it gives you helpful information of what to expect at their age & much more helpful tips as a parent!
  21. [R88] BabyCenter Pregnancy Tracker 5/5 · US Baby: I love the app it helps me a lot to learn about my baby/child and it gives you many ideas so you can learn about your baby

Synthesized from 120 recent App Store reviews · updated July 2026 · View on the App Store