Verithiathe honest score on any app
Updated July 2026 · real, multi-region App Store reviews
Head-to-head

Love Island vs Choices

Love Island 4.7★ · Free + IAP 40
Winner Choices
Choices 4.5★ · Free + IAP 60

Choices offers a wider variety of stories and better value for its free tier, despite recent concerns about AI content, while Love Island struggles with aggressive monetization and repetitive gameplay.

Full reviews: Love Island · Choices

Love Island and Choices are both interactive story games with free-to-play models. Love Island is criticized for its repetitive stories and high gem costs, making it feel like a 'cash grab.' Choices, while facing recent backlash for AI-generated content and declining quality, is still praised for its diverse stories and more accessible diamond system in older content.

Head to head

Features & Content Variety edge: ChoicesR1R19R41R58
Love Island Love Island's gameplay is described as repetitive, with the same format and events occurring in every season R1. Some players also note a lack of diverse character options, such as being forced to play as a woman or not being able to date STEM characters R19R41R58.
Choices Choices offers a vast array of genres and stories, with many long-time fans appreciating the inclusivity and diversity . However, recent updates have introduced AI-generated art and writing, leading to a decline in quality, plot holes, and repetitive dialogue in newer stories R61R63R64.
Monetization & Value edge: ChoicesR1R2R3R5
Love Island Love Island is heavily criticized for being a 'cash grab' due to the high cost of gems for desirable choices, outfits, and even basic interactions R1R3R5R6. Earning gems is slow, often only 3 gems per ad with long cooldowns, and tickets to play new episodes also require long waits or purchases R2R5R6R15. Some users report ads disappearing, making free gem earning impossible R16.
Choices Choices also has expensive diamond choices, with some users stating that one choice can cost $2 . However, some players find the initial diamond rewards decent and appreciate the quick ads for more diamonds . Historically, there were more ways to earn diamonds, such as watching 100 ads, but this has been reduced to 10 ads a day, making it harder to earn free diamonds R69R75R76R93. VIP subscriptions are available but are considered expensive by some at £15 a month .
Reliability & Performance tieR4R7R10R32
Love Island Love Island users report issues with forced ads that cannot be closed, leading to game resets R4. Some also experience long download times for storylines, with the game freezing if they exit the app R10. A bug was mentioned where tasks did not award gems R32. One user reported persistent unauthorized charges after an in-app purchase R7.
Choices Choices has a bug where the app forces an update then shuts down, preventing access . Some users also report issues with earning diamonds from tasks or surveys not working R75.
Player Experience & Satisfaction tieR8R14R15R17
Love Island Many Love Island players find the game addictive and entertaining despite its flaws R8R14R15R17. However, there's significant frustration over the need to pay for crucial choices and outfits, which impacts the storyline and character perception R32. Some long-time players feel the game has lost its charm and quality, especially after changes to older seasons . There are also complaints about forced love interests and lack of player choice in relationships .
Choices Choices has a loyal fanbase, with many playing for years and appreciating the older stories R64. However, recent changes, particularly the use of AI for art and writing, have led to widespread disappointment and a feeling that the app has gone 'downhill' R61R63R64R65. Some users also dislike the shift towards more explicit content .
Customer Support tieR7R16R63
Love Island Love Island's support team is criticized for providing copy-pasted answers and not resolving ongoing issues, such as the disappearance of ad options for gems R16. One user also reported that developers could not help with persistent unauthorized charges R7.
Choices Choices' support is not extensively mentioned, but some users note that copy-paste responses are given to negative reviews R63.
Pick Love Island if

You are a fan of the Love Island TV show and enjoy the specific dating simulation format, and you are willing to spend money on in-app purchases to access premium content and choices R8R14.

Pick Choices if

You prefer a wider variety of story genres and have a nostalgic attachment to the app's older, human-written content . You might also be more tolerant of recent AI integration if the core stories still appeal to you .

Evidence note: Both apps are free with in-app purchases, and much of the negativity for both stems from the monetization model and the difficulty of progressing without spending money. Love Island's reviews are heavily skewed towards complaints about gem costs and repetitive gameplay, while Choices' recent reviews are dominated by concerns over AI-generated content and declining quality, despite its higher lifetime rating.

Frequently asked

Is Love Island a pay-to-win game?
Many users describe Love Island as a 'cash grab' where desirable choices, outfits, and even basic interactions are locked behind expensive gem paywalls, making it difficult to fully enjoy the game without spending money R1R3R5R6.
Can you earn free diamonds in Choices?
Yes, you can earn free diamonds in Choices, but the methods have been reduced; historically, you could watch 100 ads for diamonds, but this has been limited to 10 ads per day, and some users report that tasks or surveys for diamonds do not work R69R75R76R93.
Are Choices stories now AI-generated?
Many recent Choices stories and art assets are reported by users to be AI-generated, leading to a decline in quality, plot holes, repetitive dialogue, and a general dissatisfaction among long-time players R61R63R64R65.

What reviewers actually said

Built only from these 120 real reviews (foreign ones translated). Superscripts jump to the quote here. Apple has no per-review links, so [ref] opens that app's reviews on the App Store.

  1. [R1] Love Island 1/5 · US Cash grab game: This game is so money hungry and repetitive. It will have you spending diamonds on top of diamonds even if you JUST spent diamonds on a exclusive choice. It's the same format every. single. season. The same thing happens every single time in the same exact order. No matter what season you play. You barely get any diamonds. You don't even get a reward for playing a full season. Just
  2. [R19] Love Island 2/5 · US Seems cool stuck playing as a woman though: I’d play it through if I wasn’t forced to play as a woman. The art is pretty cool, the hairstyles are great but that’s my only hang up aside from the diamonds system.
  3. [R41] Love Island 4/5 · US Smart People Not Allowed: cute game, but not super fun when you can’t be or date STEM people. is it unrealistic to want a STEM person in this stupid little game show? yes. do i want it anyway? yes.
  4. [R58] Love Island 1/5 · US Smh: Why can’t we play as dudes?
  5. [R2] Love Island 5/5 · US Development in diamonds: You should give 3 diamonds per day so it would be a little more fun to play
  6. [R3] Love Island 3/5 · US I like the game: I enjoy the game I just don’t like that you have to spend diamonds on any of the good choices. Like give more options cause not wasting my money on a game like this.
  7. [R5] Love Island 4/5 · US My current thoughts on the gems and ticket systems: Love Island: The Game is amazing! However, I wish we could earn more gems like 5 or 10 instead of just 3 because outfits and certain choices are expensive. For example, an outfit costs 20 gems. While that is reasonable, it is hard to afford when you do not have enough. There should be a daily log-in reward to earn extra gems. Additionally, waitin
  8. [R4] Love Island 2/5 · US fix your app: its fun but sometimes they wont let you close the forced ads. making you close out the game over and over again, resetting your process and having to do it again. fix it
  9. [R7] Love Island 1/5 · US Ridiculous do not get: Do not get this app, if you have kids in house or little siblings make sure they don’t download this. my sister downloaded this game one night. She had a sleepover at my house. she used the app and bought some things off of it. now the app won’t stop charging my card. I reached out to the developers and they said they can’t help.
  10. [R10] Love Island 1/5 · US cant download: ive been waiting for 5 hours for the storyline to download. it hasnt moved since 36% and the game will freeze of you exit the app. waste of my time
  11. [R32] Love Island 4/5 · US Amazing game it’s js the gems and a bug: I literally love this game sm the thing is I don’t like that we get a specific amount of gems a day when some of us can’t afford that or js don’t feel like paying. Especially with all the cool clothes I wanna get and it cost gems to do the stuff I want in the game which affects my story line. Also there is a bug where for my tasks it doesn’t give me the gem
  12. [R8] Love Island 5/5 · US LOVEE: Genuinely obsessed. Perfect amount of flirty and bold choices. Although can say I’m partial to spending gems and therefore money.
  13. [R14] Love Island 5/5 · US I love this game: when i tell you this game got me addicted. i’ve spent wayyyyy too much money on this game..
  14. [R15] Love Island 3/5 · US uh: i enjoy the game don't get me wrong it's addicting like very addicting but it's hard to play when you have to wait 2 hours for a ticket to unlock the next episode like bro come on n if you want the 2 free tickets it's 4hrs i've already spent over $5 on the gems bec it only gives you 3 if you watch an ad every 10min n its like all the items cost gems n then the quests are also had to complete b
  15. [R17] Love Island 4/5 · US Love it but there’s some discussions.: I really overall love this game a lot! It’s so entertaining and fun, but the thing I don’t like about it is that we don’t get as much diamonds, especially after I buy something, my diamonds become such a small amount. I also don’t like the fact I have to wait 2 hours for the tickets. I would much rather 1 hour and get in a day 4 tickets in total. I would love
  16. [R16] Love Island 2/5 · US Poor game support team and greediness: i recently started playing this 3 days ago, and within this time frame the option to see ads for gems disappeared 3x. contacted game support, they gave me the same copy pasted answer twice and haven’t fixed this ongoing problem. the game also asks for lots of gems just to do simple things like talk privately w your li or just for clothes. It’s a fun game that
  17. [R63] Choices 3/5 · US Downfall: It’s really unfortunate that this app has gone down hill. Starting stories then completely trashing the project because of layoffs is ridiculous. Using AI instead of original creators that built up your app is disappointing. As I’ve gone through recent reviews I have seen the same things. Decline in quality, increase in quantity, and decline in acknowledgement to the issues with their ap
  18. [R6] Love Island 3/5 · US so fun…until you need gems: i really have enjoyed playing this game, but there are so many things you need gems for. it’s impossible to be fun without them. the only way to get them without spending money is watching an ad or two every fifteen minutes for literally 3 gems. i really wish you didn’t need hundreds of gems to be successful in this game but you really do. it’s honestly a money grab.
  19. [R69] Choices 3/5 · US Changes: Part of what attracted me to this app was that even without paying for certain choices you were able to still play the story. Now there have been changes that now you’re paying for more choices. The choices are already expensive not to mention we already only get 2 diamonds for every story we read unless we’re VIP. Then add on that we can only get 10 free diamonds a day in addition to how
  20. [R75] Choices 3/5 · US It’s alright: I enjoy the stories I wish they went back to watch 100 videos get diamonds and keys bc without spending money getting diamonds is hard. You have to read a book you don’t care for to get free diamonds but can only read 2 chapters every 2 hours I enjoy reading and I love most of the stories I just wish getting diamonds was easier than just buying them. There’s an option to play games f
  21. [R76] Choices 2/5 · US This is BAD now: No one likes the AI and clear cash grabbing. It’s becoming increasingly hard to get diamonds because the 100 ads have been dropped to 10 ads a day, you only get the 15 diamonds for the first time you complete a story instead of every time you complete it now, there’s been no events to get diamonds (at least the last couple months I played for), no free passes to read a story witho
  22. [R93] Choices 3/5 · US Ads: I updated and now I can’t find where to earn gems by ads
  23. [R61] Choices 1/5 · US Disappointed: Choices has faced a rapid decline after beginning the use of Ai, we can see it in the horrible face models, awful character lines, and blurry backgrounds. I would once come back to this app every two hours to use my next key, now i find myself deleted the app as soon as I install it, always hoping it’s gotten better. You’d think after introducing VIP there’d be an incentive and profi
  24. [R64] Choices 1/5 · US A Heartbreak: I have been playing this game since I started college in 2017, and the past few years the app has become butchered. So many stories on here have really meant a lot to me, thats the only reason the app is still on my phone, to revisit what used to be but its hard to see what its become. Almost every story has these ai avatars that turn into a new person every time they change expressi
  25. [R65] Choices 4/5 · US Choices ! Do not change please: After having issues with some of the stories, turning from Free to play to VIP, I had quit and then came back recently and found out the choices is now changing to run TV.. AI and videos? What they should do is keep the Choices stories you play which is interactive the same and then have a separate app if people want to watch book videos. If these videos are not gon

Synthesized from 120 recent App Store reviews · updated July 2026 · View on the App Store