Verithiathe honest score on any app
Updated July 2026 · real, multi-region App Store reviews
Head-to-head

Island Building vs Panthia®

Island Building 4.7★ · Free + IAP · ⚠ stale 60
Winner Panthia®
Panthia® 4.7★ · Free + IAP 70

Choose Panthia® for a more engaging experience despite its issues.

While both apps have their strengths and weaknesses, Panthia® offers a more enjoyable gameplay experience with better graphics and a more engaging storyline. However, users on both sides express frustration over ads and in-game purchases.

Head to head

features edge: Panthia®R2R11R68R70
Island Building Island Building users appreciate the variety of puzzles and building mechanics but express disappointment over the lack of new content and updates.
Panthia® Panthia® users enjoy the game's addictive nature and graphics but find the energy system restrictive and frustrating.
ease of use edge: Panthia®R9R12R67R90
Island Building Island Building users report issues with ads interrupting gameplay and glitches that hinder enjoyment.
Panthia® Panthia® users also face ad interruptions, but some find the gameplay smoother overall despite the energy limitations.
reliability tieR40R64R87R112
Island Building Island Building has been criticized for glitches and frequent crashes, making it less reliable for users.
Panthia® Panthia® users report similar issues with freezing and loading problems, but some find it less frequent than in Island Building.
price/value tieR21R22R70R117
Island Building Island Building offers a free tier but users complain about being forced to watch ads for progress.
Panthia® Panthia® is also free but users express frustration over the increasing costs of energy and the need to spend money to progress.
support tieR25R67R97R85
Island Building Island Building users have reported issues with in-app purchases and lack of support for technical problems.
Panthia® Panthia® users also express dissatisfaction with customer support, particularly regarding progress restoration after issues.
Pick Island Building if

you prefer a more casual game with simple mechanics and don't mind ads.

Pick Panthia® if

you want a more engaging and visually appealing game experience despite some frustrations with energy limits.

Evidence note: Both apps have a free tier, which may skew negative reviews due to non-paying users experiencing ads and limitations.

Frequently asked

Are these games free to play?
Yes, both Island Building and Panthia® are free to download and play, but they include in-app purchases and ads that can affect gameplay experience.

What reviewers actually said

Built only from these 120 real reviews (foreign ones translated). Superscripts jump to the quote here. Apple has no per-review links, so [ref] opens that app's reviews on the App Store.

  1. [R2] Island Building 5/5 · US Dream Island: Best puzzle and building game ever!! This game is so exciting as you play number puzzles and all the while you are building your island. No other fun game like Dream Island.. I play this fun little gem all day long..love it!! Five stars..kudos to the developers 😃
  2. [R11] Island Building 5/5 · US DREAM ISLAND SUPERB GAME!!! 👍: I updated a while back and the name had changed. It was AMERICAN DREAM for years. I love it. So many things to do. But I’m disappointed. I’ve upgraded all my buildings on my island and have nothing to spend my gold bars on. No more tasks to do. I was stunned when I went to see what my tasks were and it was empty. My heart sank. The developer said it sounds like I
  3. [R68] Panthia® 5/5 · US Can’t stop playing: This is my favorite game. I can’t stop playing. It’s so addictive. I hate when I run out of energy and I have to wait for the energy to build up. You don’t have to spend money to play this game but you can purchase more energy if you want. Check this game out.
  4. [R70] Panthia® 1/5 · US EXPENSIVE: The energy gets more and more expensive the more I progress in the game. It is highway robbery and I ‘m very unhappy with your racket. The deeper in the game, the more energy one has to spend. It goes from 5 to 20 in two steps.
  5. [R9] Island Building 3/5 · US Great game: This is a great game and it’s fun but it drains my phone battery fast and is really glitchy. I’ll watch ads to skip deliveries and it will freeze. After I got this game and the ad problem started, it happened to the rest of my phone. Still a good game though.
  6. [R12] Island Building 3/5 · US OK Game BUT!!!: Its an interesting game when you are bored to death but it forces you to watch ads, and pop up screens for upgrades for a gazillion times it is annoying! It drains battery on your phone too, its summer right now so my phone is getting too hot from using the app.
  7. [R67] Panthia® 2/5 · US Customer Support: I have loved this game until this morning. Last night they did an update. The game worked fine until I leveled up to the next level and ran out of energy and quit until some energy was restored. When I went back it took me back to where I had started earlier. I contacted customer support and asked them to restore my progress and nothing. I waited for several hours and nothing. I
  8. [R90] Panthia® 3/5 · US Sadly leaving.: Been playing for quite awhile but life is short and the CONSTANT injection of ads just takes too much time. Great graphics and the game is fun but way too many ads.
  9. [R40] Island Building 1/5 · US Glitching: My game is currently glitching. When I click on the plan to take me to my island or to the hotel my game will just shut off. It’s really aggravating Bc I enjoy playing this game.
  10. [R64] Panthia® 1/5 · US Dang it: My game is frozen up.
  11. [R87] Panthia® 3/5 · US Freezes up frequently: I love the game but it freezes up regularly. Very frustrating. The “support” option in the App Store is equally frustrating as it goes nowhere. I’m on an iPhone iOS 26.
  12. [R112] Panthia® 1/5 · US Big Problems!: There is a big problem with the game that needs immediate attention from Meta. When loading the game the screen goes black at the garden and you cannot proceed to th actual game. Furthermore the game is completely ghosted. I have spent a ton of money on this game and now I can’t do anything! This is disgusting!!!
  13. [R21] Island Building 3/5 · US Eh: Game is pretty fun, but it would be better if I wasn’t forced to watch ads every five minutes when I try to buy an upgrade only to get one gem, and if it weren’t so expensive to buy everything. The only way I would be able to get enough money to just buy one thing is if I leave the app until I get a notification then have to buy double the money just to repeat the process until I can buy somet
  14. [R22] Island Building 1/5 · US Not worth your time: This game is not designed to entertain the players, basically has nothing interesting. The purpose is to only let you click the ads, which only benefits the creator of the game. I don’t understand what kind of people will waste time on it to make money for the game developers because it is totally NOT FUN.
  15. [R117] Panthia® 3/5 · GB Money drainer: After playing this game for nearly 2yrs on and off, This game is good for passing the time, but unless you pay you won’t complete any of the competitions. It’s all money money money. This game is good if you don’t really care about making very slow progress, but if you, like me, are hoping for the thrill of completion not just in the normal gameplay but over all then this is not the
  16. [R25] Island Building 2/5 · US Purchase problems.: Love the game. I bought a starter pack, but it told me the purchase failed. I got a refund from Apple. I tried the VIP, and it confirmed I was approved and scheduled to be charged, but it gave me nothing of the perks, nor removal of ads; like I never had any benefits. Is there a way to solve? I’d really like to buy IAP.
  17. [R97] Panthia® 1/5 · US Cannot connect: I have restarted my device, deleted and redownloaded the app and am still stuck on connecting to server….. I have tried to contact the support but all links are not helpful either. I used to love this game!!
  18. [R85] Panthia® 2/5 · US Froze: I have made several purchases. At level 178 it will not allow me to access other parts if the island. Taken over 240 or more coins, no more tress can be chopped, just tells me to find a way io access next part. I am stuck and support no help!
  19. [R1] Island Building 1/5 · US False advertisement: Not only do I think these reviews are fake but for you guys to sell something you don’t even receive. it said no ads yet not only did I get ads I got 3 of them in one! Yet you want what $4.99 or $5.99 a month??? It didn’t even work…. Then to make things worse you send a vip pack to “go gold”?!?! Wild.. never in my life.
  20. [R66] Panthia® 3/5 · US Not free: You need to get ads to keep going. When you open an advertisement it doesn’t get you back to the game, you don’t get your objects, and I haven’t been able to get my Panthia free objects for downloading the game.

Synthesized from 120 recent App Store reviews · updated July 2026 · View on the App Store