Verithiathe honest score on any app
Updated July 2026 · real, multi-region App Store reviews
Head-to-head

Island Building vs Family Island

Island Building 4.7★ · Free + IAP · ⚠ stale 60
Winner Family Island
Family Island 4.8★ · Free to download 75

Family Island offers a more engaging and long-term experience, despite its aggressive monetization, while Island Building suffers from a lack of updates and a finite gameplay loop.

Full reviews: Island Building · Family Island

Island Building is a merge and idle game that many users enjoy for its simple gameplay, but it is plagued by excessive ads, glitches, and a lack of new content after players reach the end of the game. Family Island, a popular island-building game, provides a more immersive experience but is heavily criticized for its 'pay-to-play' model, requiring significant in-app purchases to progress at higher levels.

Head to head

Gameplay & Engagement edge: Family IslandR2R4R8R18
Island Building Island Building is praised by some for being an addictive and fun idle/merge game, with users enjoying the puzzle and building aspects R2R8. However, many find the gameplay boring and repetitive, especially after the initial stages, with slow progression and a lack of clear goals beyond merging boxes R4R18.
Family Island Family Island is described as addictive, fun, and relaxing by many players, offering new things to do daily . However, a significant number of users find the game becomes boring and frustrating due to repetitive tasks and the constant need for energy to progress .
Monetization & Value tieR1R10R12R21
Island Building Island Building is heavily criticized for its aggressive monetization, with users reporting frequent, unskippable ads R1R10R12R21. Some users who purchased IAP to remove ads found the purchases failed or did not deliver the promised perks R1. The game is also seen as a 'money grab' due to expensive upgrades and rigged prize wheels R21.
Family Island Family Island is widely criticized as a 'money grab' and a 'pay-to-play' game, especially at higher levels where energy costs are exorbitant and progression is nearly impossible without spending real money R66R69R70R73. Users report that even significant purchases ($10-$30) only provide a few minutes of gameplay R70.
Reliability & Performance edge: Island BuildingR9R12R40R54
Island Building Island Building users report frequent glitches, freezing, and app crashes R9R40R54. The game is also noted for draining phone battery quickly and causing devices to overheat R9R12.
Family Island Family Island experiences some technical issues, including glitches, login problems, and difficulties with updates . One user also reported a security concern regarding Cash App information .
Content & Updates edge: Family IslandR11R14R20R23
Island Building Island Building suffers from a significant lack of new content and updates, with many users finishing the game and having nothing left to do R11R14R20R23. Some reviews mention the game hasn't been updated in over six months .
Family Island Family Island frequently updates, but recent updates have been met with strong negative reactions, with users stating they ruined the game experience by making resource collection harder and increasing energy demands R84R87R91R96. Some users also report issues with updating the game .
Pick Island Building if

You enjoy idle merge games and don't mind a finite experience, or if you prefer a game that can be played offline .

Pick Family Island if

You are looking for a long-term, engaging island-building game and are willing to either be very patient with energy regeneration or make frequent in-app purchases to progress .

Evidence note: Family Island has a significantly larger number of reviews, which might skew the perception of common issues due to a larger user base reporting them. Both apps are free to download but rely heavily on in-app purchases, leading to similar complaints about monetization.

Frequently asked

Does Island Building have a lot of ads?
Yes, Island Building is heavily criticized for having an excessive number of ads, with users reporting ads every step of the game, every 10 seconds, or multiple ads in a row, even after being promised 'no ads' R1R10R12R37.
Can you finish Island Building?
Yes, many users report finishing Island Building, reaching maximum levels for buildings and tasks, and then having nothing left to do, indicating a finite gameplay experience R11R14R20R26.
Is Family Island a pay-to-win game?
Family Island is widely considered a 'pay-to-play' or 'pay-to-win' game, especially at higher levels, because energy costs for tasks become so high that it's nearly impossible to progress without purchasing energy or other in-app items R66R69R70R73.
Are there issues with recent updates in Family Island?
Yes, recent updates in Family Island have been met with significant negative feedback, with users stating that updates have made resource collection harder, increased energy demands, and generally ruined the game experience for long-time players R84R87R91R96.

What reviewers actually said

Built only from these 120 real reviews (foreign ones translated). Superscripts jump to the quote here. Apple has no per-review links, so [ref] opens that app's reviews on the App Store.

  1. [R2] Island Building 5/5 · US Dream Island: Best puzzle and building game ever!! This game is so exciting as you play number puzzles and all the while you are building your island. No other fun game like Dream Island.. I play this fun little gem all day long..love it!! Five stars..kudos to the developers 😃
  2. [R4] Island Building 1/5 · US DO NOT BUY THIS GAME: Slightly boring , upgrade grill takes two hours!!!!
  3. [R8] Island Building 5/5 · US LITERALLY THE BEST IDLE GAME I HAVE EVER DOWNLOADED: This masterpiece is on par with the likes of dragon city and candy crush. No obligatory ads, fun gameplay that is fast enough to keep you entertained, but not so fast it’s overwhelming. Multiple different progression systems, and this is all from playing for like, 20 minutes. If you’re on the fence, this is your sign to download this absolute le
  4. [R18] Island Building 3/5 · US Good: I just started this game and it is fine I guess kind of boring but ok
  5. [R1] Island Building 1/5 · US False advertisement: Not only do I think these reviews are fake but for you guys to sell something you don’t even receive. it said no ads yet not only did I get ads I got 3 of them in one! Yet you want what $4.99 or $5.99 a month??? It didn’t even work…. Then to make things worse you send a vip pack to “go gold”?!?! Wild.. never in my life.
  6. [R10] Island Building 1/5 · US Commercials Commercials Commercials: The game benefits the creator of the game all I have seen were commercials every step of the game. Can’t even have fun.
  7. [R12] Island Building 3/5 · US OK Game BUT!!!: Its an interesting game when you are bored to death but it forces you to watch ads, and pop up screens for upgrades for a gazillion times it is annoying! It drains battery on your phone too, its summer right now so my phone is getting too hot from using the app.
  8. [R21] Island Building 3/5 · US Eh: Game is pretty fun, but it would be better if I wasn’t forced to watch ads every five minutes when I try to buy an upgrade only to get one gem, and if it weren’t so expensive to buy everything. The only way I would be able to get enough money to just buy one thing is if I leave the app until I get a notification then have to buy double the money just to repeat the process until I can buy somet
  9. [R9] Island Building 3/5 · US Great game: This is a great game and it’s fun but it drains my phone battery fast and is really glitchy. I’ll watch ads to skip deliveries and it will freeze. After I got this game and the ad problem started, it happened to the rest of my phone. Still a good game though.
  10. [R40] Island Building 1/5 · US Glitching: My game is currently glitching. When I click on the plan to take me to my island or to the hotel my game will just shut off. It’s really aggravating Bc I enjoy playing this game.
  11. [R54] Island Building 3/5 · US It shuts me out of the game: Overall it is an amazing game but the new update is horrible. When It MAKES me tap the yellow airplane button It works but then the screen pauses to the airplane and just makes its sound. Then it shows me the island your visiting for 1 second then it just turn black and kicks me out of the game. Please fix these issues. Thank You!
  12. [R11] Island Building 5/5 · US DREAM ISLAND SUPERB GAME!!! 👍: I updated a while back and the name had changed. It was AMERICAN DREAM for years. I love it. So many things to do. But I’m disappointed. I’ve upgraded all my buildings on my island and have nothing to spend my gold bars on. No more tasks to do. I was stunned when I went to see what my tasks were and it was empty. My heart sank. The developer said it sounds like I
  13. [R14] Island Building 5/5 · US I love this game so much: So I just finished the game because I played it so much idk what to do now since I finished it I love this game
  14. [R20] Island Building 5/5 · US Is this the end?: I really enjoy this game it’s my end of the night before I go to sleep relaxer! My computers have reached 88 so is this the end of the game or are additional levels being added in the near future?
  15. [R23] Island Building 5/5 · US Does it only get to level 60?: Not sure because it seems like I can’t get past that. I have 2147483647 xp out of 2147483647 and it says level 60 on the left and 61 on the right but it isn’t changing
  16. [R37] Island Building 1/5 · US Full of ads: Every 10 seconds you have to watch an ad to advance in the game. I don’t see how this is called a game you spend most of your time watching ads on this app
  17. [R26] Island Building 5/5 · US Great game: I really enjoy this game - but when will there be new content !? I’m all upgraded, kinda sad I don’t have anything else to buy =[ When are you adding more content it’s been a year !
  18. [R66] Family Island 3/5 · US Wish I could love this game!: At first it is fun. Lots of rewards of energy but as you move up through the game. It costs so much energy that you cannot proceed unless you pay. I wanted to love this game but and at first I would get lost in the game fir far too long but since I could still level up it was worth it. But now after mere minutes I can’t play any further I am out of energy. I made a c
  19. [R69] Family Island 3/5 · US Money grab: Once you get into the higher level islands you need to spent $40 to complete 1 single island. It’s ridiculous.
  20. [R70] Family Island 1/5 · US Have to pay to play: It’s fun until you reach the higher levels and the max free energy is 120 but it costs 198 to get ONE of the many many items you need to progress to the next quest. Literally impossible to continue playing the game unless you buy energy and about $10 worth of energy lasts about 5 minutes! Fun, right? 🙄
  21. [R73] Family Island 2/5 · US Too bad!: The game is very fun up until the point it becomes such a shameless cash grab. Having the option to purchase advantages is not the problem. The problem is that there are points in the game where it becomes impossible to play for free.
  22. [R84] Family Island 3/5 · US Long time player: I have been playing this game for about 4 years I took a break and came back to it and realized that getting resources is harder now you can’t go on adventure islands and get resources you have to spend energy which is more time consuming and takes the fun out of the game because it’s takes longer to develop the island especially since the adventure islands seem harder towards th
  23. [R87] Family Island 3/5 · US I don’t like: The resources no longer appear the way they did in the old version. I don't like the Castro Grove. The new islands, which only last 23 days, seem like garbage to me. I liked the old version better. It doesn't relax me anymore; it just stresses me out.
  24. [R91] Family Island 1/5 · US New Updates: I came back to this game after not playing for a while and the new updates are terrible. You used to be able to collect resources from other islands and use them on the main island - that was WAY better. The new beavers are terrible. It is nearly impossible to get resources & build things now. That makes it so difficult to upgrade things and move forward through the game. This makes m
  25. [R96] Family Island 3/5 · GB What’s happened?: Been playing daily for around 18 months. Spend money now and again, seems fair as obviously a lot of work goes into it (despite a lot of repeats). However, it’s suddenly become impossible with ridiculous amounts of items needed to complete just one part of island. I’ll not be able to progress at all. Sadly will have to delete despite being on high level:(

Synthesized from 120 recent App Store reviews · updated July 2026 · View on the App Store