Verithiathe honest score on any app
Updated July 2026 · real, multi-region App Store reviews
Head-to-head

Fishing Points vs Windy.app

Fishing Points 4.7★ · Free + IAP 70
Winner Tie
Windy.app 4.7★ · Free to download 68

For dedicated anglers, Fishing Points offers more specialized fishing features and location-saving capabilities, while Windy.app is better for general, detailed weather and wind forecasting, despite its higher cost and aggressive monetization tactics.

Full reviews: Fishing Points · Windy.app

Fishing Points and Windy.app both provide weather and fishing forecasts, but cater to different needs. Fishing Points focuses on specific fishing tools like catch logging and spot marking, though it faces criticism for paywalls and map accuracy. Windy.app excels in detailed wind and weather predictions, but users often complain about its high price and aggressive subscription prompts.

Head to head

Features & Specialization edge: Fishing PointsR1R2R6R8
Fishing Points Fishing Points is praised for its fishing and boating forecasts, including fish activity and weather, and its ability to log catches and mark spots R2R8. Some users appreciate the added fish identification feature, though it's a paid option . However, many users criticize the lack of detailed depth charts and topo maps for freshwater lakes, with some finding existing maps inaccurate or incomplete R1R6R10.
Windy.app Windy.app is highly regarded for its reliable and detailed wind and weather forecasts, which are useful for various activities like boating, fishing, and driving . Users appreciate the customizable options and accuracy of its predictions . However, some users note that basic information like sunrise/sunset times is behind a paywall or desktop-only , and some advanced weather models are restricted . There are also complaints about the accuracy of its fishing statistics and general wind forecasts .
Ease of Use & Reliability tieR2R6R9R21
Fishing Points Fishing Points is generally considered easy to use for marking spots and checking forecasts R2. However, some users experience issues with the app launching R21 or certain features not working, like nautical map depths R6. There are also reports of tide information being inaccurate R9 or wave conditions not showing . Some users find the GPS points to be off .
Windy.app Windy.app is praised for its detailed yet easy-to-use interface once set up . Its forecasts are often described as accurate and dependable . However, some users find the onboarding process glitchy or slow R63, and the user interface can be frustrating to navigate . There are also reports of the app crashing on older devices and general unreliability in wind forecasts .
Price & Value edge: Fishing PointsR1R4R6R7
Fishing Points Fishing Points is a 'Free + IAP' app, but many users feel that essential features are locked behind a paywall, leading to complaints about it not being truly free R4R7R19R25. Some users who paid for premium found it not worth the money due to missing features or inaccuracies R1R6R10. There are also significant complaints about deceptive free trial practices, with users being charged immediately for annual subscriptions and difficulty getting refunds R13R45. Some paying users also reported seeing ads R25.
Windy.app Windy.app is also a 'Free to download' app, but faces strong criticism for its aggressive monetization, with many features behind a paywall and constant reminders to upgrade to Pro R64R67R70R73. Users who paid for lifetime or annual subscriptions report still being asked for more money or having features removed and re-paywalled R64. The pricing is considered very high, with annual subscriptions ranging from $59 to $170, and even a $9 per week option R63R84R91R119. There are also complaints about deceptive advertising regarding fishing features requiring additional plans and issues with trial periods leading to immediate charges .
Support & Refunds edge: Windy.appR13R45R51R62
Fishing Points Users of Fishing Points report significant difficulties with refunds, especially for purchases made through Apple, with both Apple and the developer refusing to help R13R45R51. Some users also mention issues with contacting support or finding a way to cancel subscriptions R13R51.
Windy.app Windy.app users also report problems with cancellations and refunds, with some being charged after trial periods or after canceling R62. However, one user did report being refunded without issues after mistakenly not unsubscribing . Customer service is mentioned as being easy to reach for inquiries , and the developer has shown responsiveness to feedback regarding excessive notifications .
Pick Fishing Points if

You are a dedicated angler looking for an app to log catches, mark fishing spots, and get general fishing activity forecasts . You prioritize specific fishing features over comprehensive weather data R2. You are willing to pay for premium features but are wary of very high subscription costs .

Pick Windy.app if

You need highly detailed and reliable wind and weather forecasts for activities like boating, sailing, or even truck driving . You are willing to pay a premium price for extensive weather data and customization options . You are less concerned with specific fishing-only features and more with environmental conditions .

Evidence note: Both apps have a significant number of negative reviews related to pricing, paywalls, and subscription practices, which skews recent ratings. For Fishing Points, there's a strong theme of dissatisfaction with map accuracy and depth charts for inland waters. For Windy.app, the primary recurring complaint is the aggressive monetization and high cost, even for paid users.

Frequently asked

Is Fishing Points truly free?
No, Fishing Points is not truly free; while it's free to download, many essential features, including advanced forecasts, depth charts, and fish identification, are locked behind a paywall or require a monthly/annual subscription R4R7R19R25.
How accurate are the maps and depth charts in Fishing Points?
The accuracy of maps and depth charts in Fishing Points is inconsistent; some users report them being very accurate for certain areas R5, while many others complain about significant inaccuracies, missing data for inland lakes and rivers, or features not working even after purchasing premium R1R6R10.
Are there hidden costs or deceptive practices with Windy.app subscriptions?
Yes, many users report hidden costs and deceptive practices with Windy.app subscriptions, including being charged immediately after a 'free trial,' having features removed from paid versions and re-paywalled, and constant aggressive prompts to upgrade even after purchasing a subscription R64R67R70R73.
What is the price range for Windy.app subscriptions?
Windy.app subscriptions are considered expensive, with annual plans reported to range from $59 to $170, and some users even mentioning a $9 per week 'best' option R63R84R91R119.

What reviewers actually said

Built only from these 120 real reviews (foreign ones translated). Superscripts jump to the quote here. Apple has no per-review links, so [ref] opens that app's reviews on the App Store.

  1. [R1] Fishing Points 1/5 · US Not what I was looking for: Don’t be like me and pay for a year to find out it’s not worth the money and doesn’t give proper depths and charts
  2. [R2] Fishing Points 5/5 · US It’s good: The weather and fish activity make it very easy to know when to go fishing and I don’t need to spend money unless I want premium and they are never reminding me to buy premium its a very good app In general too.
  3. [R6] Fishing Points 3/5 · US Can’t get the depths to work!: I purchased the premium and when I click on the nautical map to show depths in my lake it doesn’t work. Is this normal? Can you please help me with this! I like the app but the depths is crucial to me! Thanks.
  4. [R8] Fishing Points 5/5 · US Great app: This is a great app for fishing and boating
  5. [R9] Fishing Points 3/5 · US Not the best at tides. Usually 6 hours off. Used to work better on the tides.: Fix the tides
  6. [R21] Fishing Points 3/5 · US App won’t launch: App won’t launch or open as of 5/3/2023. Overall I have enjoyed using this app over the past few years, but I will have to look into another app option if this problem persists. App itself and its features are 5/5, but rating 3/5 due to recent accessibility issues.
  7. [R4] Fishing Points 1/5 · US Pay to use: Not worth your time or money. Everything is locked behind a paywall.
  8. [R7] Fishing Points 1/5 · US Not free: Yet another app that seems free on the surface, but ends up being a monthly subscription. Deceptive practices.
  9. [R13] Fishing Points 1/5 · US Need refund!: Total scam. This app wasn’t even in my subscription list. Took my hard earned money. $49.99. This app is useless. I will just stick to my other fishing app that actually shows other anglers catches and hotspots. And then they make it hard to actually leave a review! It says choose a nickname but every nickname I choose is taken? Yeah ok!
  10. [R45] Fishing Points 1/5 · US Bait and switch: I signed up for what was advertised as a 7-day free trial, but I was charged immediately for a full subscription. I realized within 10 minutes that the app wasn’t what I wanted and deleted it right away. When I tried to request a refund, Apple denied it without explanation, and the company refused to help, saying they don’t deal with purchases made through Apple. This is a bait-a
  11. [R51] Fishing Points 1/5 · US Do not use “free” trial period: They will charge you immediately and keep the money, there is no way to cancel, no way to contact. Apple refuses to support dispute.
  12. [R62] Windy.app 4/5 · US Cancel: You can’t cancel this app!!!
  13. [R19] Fishing Points 1/5 · US Price: It’s not free
  14. [R25] Fishing Points 1/5 · US Ads and gatekeeping features: Every time u open the app there is an ads, this would be fine if it was free app, I am just sick of features being behind a pay wall. If I wanna look at tomorrow’s tides I have to go to google, totally defeats the whole point to the app.
  15. [R5] Fishing Points 5/5 · US The best: This is the best app I’ve used and is really close to be 100 percent accurate
  16. [R10] Fishing Points 1/5 · US Garbage app: Has no depth chart. Useless garbage app. Waste of time
  17. [R64] Windy.app 1/5 · US Garbage: I paid for lifetime and everything I try to use is asking for money. I want a refund
  18. [R67] Windy.app 1/5 · US App turned to hot garbage unless you pay: Can’t even look at stuff without being bothered at least twice to sign up for pro
  19. [R70] Windy.app 1/5 · US 1*: Yet another app that strings you along a stupid quiz before asking you for money at the end. Just say you’re a subscriber service only and stop wasting my time. Let people do your dumb customer survey after they’ve payed to be on ur app.
  20. [R73] Windy.app 1/5 · US Too many: Had to uninstall. Too many reminders about special offers. Very annoying
  21. [R63] Windy.app 3/5 · US Onboarding process hung up: Tried to get on the app after subscribing to the one year $59 option. Can’t find a support phone number and the app is stuck in the enrollment process and I can’t start using the app for some reason. Payment went through so I don’t know what the problem is.
  22. [R84] Windy.app 3/5 · GB Past pro subscriber: The information and data in the pro version is good, but, not at £99 a year. There is too much clutter you can’t remove. And the non subscription version is so restricted it is a waste of time. Windy app please get the pricing down to no more than £30 a year and remove clutter. Your rating will go up and so will your subscribers.
  23. [R91] Windy.app 2/5 · US Didn’t realize I signed up for an annual subscription: A little disappointed about being charged for a full year subscription. I really only needed this for at most a month but I got charged $170 for a full year subscription. I guess I missed that in the T&C’s? Happy to pay for the usage of it but I only needed it for a while. It was very helpful during my trip to the Bahamas so I like the progr
  24. [R119] Windy.app 1/5 · US $70 -$170 per year? Nah: Who wants to pay that? The “best” option is $9 PER WEEK. Lol

Synthesized from 120 recent App Store reviews · updated July 2026 · View on the App Store