Verithiathe honest score on any app
Updated July 2026 · real, multi-region App Store reviews
Head-to-head

Idle Miner Tycoon vs Idle Guy

Idle Miner Tycoon 4.7★ · Free + IAP 60
Winner Idle Guy
Idle Guy 4.8★ · Free + IAP 70

Idle Guy offers a more engaging and fast-paced experience with a clearer progression path, despite its ad issues, making it the better choice over Idle Miner Tycoon's more intrusive monetization and slower gameplay.

Full reviews: Idle Miner Tycoon · Idle Guy

Idle Guy provides a life simulation with a decent story and engaging, fast-paced gameplay, though it's heavily monetized with ads and in-app purchases. Idle Miner Tycoon, while having a larger user base and some fans, is plagued by an overwhelming number of pop-up ads and a slow, grindy progression that frustrates many players.

Head to head

Features and Gameplay edge: Idle GuyR1R2R11R18
Idle Miner Tycoon Idle Miner Tycoon is described as a simple, relaxing game that makes players think about the best options for missions R2R11. However, many users find the game slow and boring, especially after reaching higher levels where progression becomes painfully slow R1. Some players also note that the game doesn't live up to its ads, which depict a faster and simpler experience R18.
Idle Guy Idle Guy offers a life simulator with a variety of options to make money, including local tasks and investments, and is described as fast-paced and engaging . Users appreciate the decent story and options to fix mistakes . However, some players feel the game is unfinished and that the 'idle' aspect is limited, as offline earnings are capped .
Ease of Use and User Experience tieR4R7R10R16
Idle Miner Tycoon Idle Miner Tycoon is criticized for an overwhelming number of pop-up ads and promotions that appear immediately upon opening the app, with users reporting 9 to 17 pop-ups before they can even play R4R7R10R16. This intrusive monetization significantly detracts from the user experience, making the game feel unplayable to some .
Idle Guy Idle Guy also suffers from frequent ads, with users reporting ads every minute or after every action . Some ads are forced, even for those who paid for an ad-free experience R61R73. Despite this, some users find the game enjoyable to an extent and easy to learn .
Reliability and Performance tieR13R19R28R31
Idle Miner Tycoon Idle Miner Tycoon users report several technical issues, including the game not working after updates R13R19, freezing at 8% during loading R28, and frequently closing down . Some players have also lost their game progress R43R53 or experienced bugs preventing progression R31.
Idle Guy Idle Guy has reports of ads not working correctly, with the button to end an ad not appearing, leading to no reward . The game is also noted to freeze when attempting to create a new character or when demanding payment for player treatment .
Price and Value tieR3R6R7R16
Idle Miner Tycoon Idle Miner Tycoon is criticized for being 'pay to win' and 'pay to play', with users feeling pressured to pay for boosts to progress faster R3R6. The game's monetization is described as intrusive, with numerous pop-ups attempting to sell in-game purchases R7R16R51.
Idle Guy Idle Guy is seen as a 'money grab' with a wide array of in-app purchases, including 'No Ads' for $4.99, 'Full No Ads' for $39.99, 'Double Salary' for $99.99, and 'Immortality' for $9.99 R64. Users who paid for ad-free versions still report getting ads R61R73, and some feel progression is limited without paying real money R88.
Support edge: Idle Miner TycoonR28R43R53R76
Idle Miner Tycoon Reviews for Idle Miner Tycoon do not explicitly mention customer support, but some users report issues like lost progress and game-ending bugs without clear resolution, suggesting a lack of effective support R28R43R53.
Idle Guy Idle Guy users explicitly state there is no support for the game, with reports of a dead Discord and abandoned developers, leading to issues with in-app purchases or rewards going unresolved R76.
Pick Idle Miner Tycoon if

you prefer a more traditional idle mining game that can be played offline R29 and are willing to tolerate frequent pop-up ads and a slower progression R4.

Pick Idle Guy if

you are looking for a fast-paced life simulation game with a story and can overlook the aggressive monetization and frequent ads R64.

Evidence note: Both apps are free with in-app purchases, and both suffer significantly from intrusive ads and monetization strategies. The negative skew in recent reviews for both largely stems from these issues, affecting the user experience for both free and paying users. Idle Miner Tycoon has a much larger user base, which contributes to a higher volume of negative feedback regarding ads and slow progression.

Frequently asked

Are there many ads in Idle Miner Tycoon?
Yes, Idle Miner Tycoon is heavily criticized for having an excessive number of pop-up ads and promotions, with users reporting between 9 and 17 pop-ups appearing immediately upon opening the game before they can even start playing R4R7R16R51.
Can you play Idle Miner Tycoon offline?
Yes, Idle Miner Tycoon can be played offline, making it a good option for long trips or when internet access is unavailable R29.
Is Idle Guy a pay-to-win game?
Idle Guy is considered by many users to be a 'money grab' due to its extensive list of in-app purchases, including 'Double Salary' for $99.99 and 'Full No Ads' for $39.99, with some feeling that progression is limited without spending real money R64R88.
Does paying for no ads in Idle Guy actually work?
No, some users who paid for the 'no ads' feature in Idle Guy still report receiving forced ads, which has led to requests for refunds R61R73.

What reviewers actually said

Built only from these 120 real reviews (foreign ones translated). Superscripts jump to the quote here. Apple has no per-review links, so [ref] opens that app's reviews on the App Store.

  1. [R1] Idle Miner Tycoon 1/5 · US Boooooooooring: The game is so slow and boring
  2. [R2] Idle Miner Tycoon 5/5 · US Ayo: Makes you think of the best option needed to complete the mission
  3. [R11] Idle Miner Tycoon 5/5 · US Great game: Pretty simple to understand the basics then the upgrade paths provide good feed back
  4. [R18] Idle Miner Tycoon 3/5 · US Meh maybe good: So this game is good but just in the ads it is a lot faster and simpler
  5. [R4] Idle Miner Tycoon 2/5 · US Used to be fun: I used to play this game daily and it was pretty fun, no pop ups or attempts for adds but unfortunately like every other game it is flooded with them. When I re downloaded it after not playing for a year I was caught off guard by about 15-20 pop ups when I opened the game and it was super annoying, it also keeps offering adds for boost. It’s just not the same
  6. [R7] Idle Miner Tycoon 2/5 · US Garbage still hasn’t changed: I’m still exiting out of each ad that pop up, it’s been 5 minutes and I haven’t even seen the game yet. Haven’t played in a year came back and immediately remembered why this game is trash. IT DOESNT MAKE ME WANT TO BUY YOUR GARBAGE. Just make 1 menu for all your ads and promo, if I’m going to spend money I will. But I will NEVER buy anything off such an intrusive
  7. [R10] Idle Miner Tycoon 1/5 · US Too many ads: I can’t even start to play without at least six ads to upgrade this or that. Not worth it.
  8. [R16] Idle Miner Tycoon 1/5 · US Pop ups: I had to close NINE pop up to try to get me to spend money on this game before I could actually play it. Uninstalled.
  9. [R13] Idle Miner Tycoon 1/5 · US Update: After the last update, the game stopped working. · translated
  10. [R19] Idle Miner Tycoon 1/5 · US Lagging: The app won't open. · translated
  11. [R28] Idle Miner Tycoon 1/5 · US Game ending bug: The game was okay, until I tried to start activities on the main land. That’s when the game closed out and installed an update. Upon completion of the update, I reopened the game and it started loading the game content only to freeze at 8% loaded. It will not load any further from there. Game is dead at this point, so I uninstalled it.
  12. [R31] Idle Miner Tycoon 2/5 · US Bugs Preventing Progression, Excessive Monetization: I actually really enjoyed this game, but after about a week I’m unfortunately just uninstalling. The progression reaches a point where you are making nowhere near enough to progress anywhere in a reasonable amount of time, which is made significantly worse by the bugs plaguing every play session. God forbid you have another device to play this o
  13. [R3] Idle Miner Tycoon 3/5 · US money: This game has potential, but the thing is is that pretty much to progress much faster u need to pay for boost sometimes so little it dosent help at all in the long term.
  14. [R6] Idle Miner Tycoon 3/5 · US BAD PLS FIX: THIS IS PAY TO WIN MAKE IT WITH ADS INSTEAD
  15. [R43] Idle Miner Tycoon 1/5 · US Game: Lost everything
  16. [R53] Idle Miner Tycoon 1/5 · US The worst game: I had a good account and it ask me were do I what to dalownd it and it rest me
  17. [R76] Idle Guy 1/5 · US Dead company: There is no support for this game so if you didn’t get and in app purchase or you got scammed out of a reward or have literally any issue at all your done. Discord is dead and the devs have abandon the game to rake in $$ this needs pulled from the App Store if it’s going unsupported
  18. [R51] Idle Miner Tycoon 1/5 · US 17 Pop Ups On Start: I counted. When you start the game, you get 17 individual pop-ups before you can even play the game. Some of them are trying to sell you in game purchases. Some of them are pointing you to various mini games. It is confusing and annoying, and I will never play it again
  19. [R29] Idle Miner Tycoon 5/5 · US The reason I like the game: It’s fun offline and something good to play for hours on a road trip.
  20. [R64] Idle Guy 1/5 · US Greedy: As someone who enjoys idle games this is a stain. As it turns out “idle guy” is just about making money for the developer. Lets go over how much everything cost. Time Control: 5.99 Free Story(no ads for only stories): 4.99 Double Salary: 99.99 No Ads: 4.99 Full No Ads: 39.99 immortality: 9.99 +10 Years: 2.99 Additional Energy: 4.99 Life Hack Book: 3.99 each. There are fou
  21. [R88] Idle Guy 2/5 · GB Game is likited: Well on level 35 and wants me to offer party but tonplay further it wants you pay money real money doesnt make sense deleted
  22. [R61] Idle Guy 1/5 · US Purchases: I paid to not have forced ads and I still grt then anyway
  23. [R73] Idle Guy 1/5 · US I’m upset: Why am I still getting ads if I paid for no ads and before purchase your game states I will have no in game ads ? I need a refund

Synthesized from 120 recent App Store reviews · updated July 2026 · View on the App Store